Giants Face A Risky Infield Choice In Their Pitching Pursuit

The San Francisco Giants face a strategic decision in balancing immediate pitching needs with long-term player potential, as they weigh the trade value of Casey Schmitt against the complexities surrounding Matt Chapman's contract and performance.

The SF Giants’ pitching search has already produced one name that keeps popping up: Casey Schmitt. Jeff Passan of ESPN has reported that San Francisco is open to moving Schmitt in order to land arms, and that chatter picked up even more after the Kansas City Royals sent Maikel Garcia to the Seattle Mariners for pitching help. Garcia was another player Passan had mentioned as a possible trade candidate alongside Schmitt.

That may be the easiest path for the Giants, but it might not be the smartest one. If San Francisco is serious about chasing pitching, Matt Chapman is the player they should at least be willing to put out there too.

There are obvious reasons Schmitt is the more likely trade chip. He’s younger, far cheaper, and coming off a strong season, which naturally makes him more appealing to other teams.

Chapman, by contrast, is coming off a rough, injury-filled year and is still owed more than $100 million. Mark Feinsand of MLB.com even floated Chapman as a possible trade candidate, but the odds are stacked against San Francisco finding a clean deal.

The contract is one hurdle. The no-trade clause is another. Chapman can block any move, which gives him real control over where this goes, if it goes anywhere at all.

And then there’s the production. Chapman is 33 and played in only 84 games last season after appearing in 128 the year before because of injury. At the plate, he hit .235/.324/.368 with seven home runs and 42 runs batted in.

Even so, there’s still a case for him. Chapman remains an elite defender at third base, and that kind of glove can make teams more willing to look past the offensive dip.

But the no-trade clause hangs over everything, and past reporting has suggested Chapman wants to stay on the West Coast because that’s where his family is. That makes a move to the East Coast seem unlikely, even though the New York Yankees would make plenty of sense as a partner given their need at third base and San Francisco’s need for pitching.

From the Giants’ side, Schmitt is the cleaner trade piece. He can’t block a deal, he’s more attractive to other clubs, and he could bring back a stronger return. Still, if San Francisco is trying to upgrade a pitching staff that could use more talent, Chapman should be part of the conversation too.

If the Giants can somehow keep Schmitt, he might end up being the more valuable player going forward.

In Other News...

Former Dodgers Infielder Is Suddenly On The Giants Radar In A New Role

Erick Mejias path back into the majors has taken a sharp turn, and it has put him on the Giants radar in a way few would have expected. The former Dodgers and Royals infielder converted to pitching full-time after the 2024 season, then landed a minor league deal with San Francisco without a spring training invitation. Since then, he has made enough of an impression in Triple-A and at other minor league stops to at least make the transition look more than like a novelty.

Mejia is now pitching in the Dominican Winter League, where the Giants can keep evaluating whether this late-career switch has real staying power. For a club that is always looking for useful arms and creative roster value, the appeal is obvious, even if the next step remains unwritten. If the conversion keeps trending the right way, there is at least a path back to MLB, this time on the mound instead of in the infield. [Read more 🡒]

Former Giants Prospects Are A Harsh Reminder Of How Fast Depth Fades

Luis Matos move to Milwaukee was the latest reminder of how quickly a once-promising Giants depth chart can thin out. After being cut loose by San Francisco, Matos was claimed off waivers by the Brewers and later elected free agency, a path that has become familiar for players trying to keep their careers moving while searching for a clearer opportunity.

Ismael Munguia has also landed elsewhere, signing a minor league deal with the Diamondbacks after bouncing through multiple organizations, while Ryan Murphy is now in the Athletics system on a minor league contract and has been assigned to Triple-A. For the Giants, it is the sort of turnover that underscores how fragile organizational depth can be, especially when former prospects keep resurfacing in other uniforms instead of in the mix back in San Francisco. [Read more 🡒]

Giants Spring Surprise Quickly Became A Roster Reality Check

Jared Olivas spring with the Giants looked like the kind of under-the-radar success story every club hopes to uncover in March. He played his way onto the Opening Day roster after an impressive camp, giving San Francisco a speed option and a fresh outfield look, but the regular season quickly turned into a tougher test. In seven games, he never found much traction before landing on the injured list.

What followed was a fast-moving tour around the league that underscored how fragile a roster spot can be for a player in his position. After a rehab assignment in Triple-A, Oliva was designated for assignment by the Giants, claimed by the Mets, then released and signed to a minor league deal by the Rays. He is now a free agent, and his ability to steal bases could still make him appealing to clubs looking for a low-cost speed piece. [Read more 🡒]