Hot stove season is built for guesses, and ESPN’s Paul Hembekides tossed out one that fits the Giants’ winter in a pretty clean way: Shota Imanaga to San Francisco.
Hembekides made the prediction on the Nov. 6 episode of ESPN’s Baseball Tonight with Buster Olney, and it was exactly that - a landing-spot call, not a report that anything was close. Still, the match makes sense on paper because the Giants need another proven starter, and Imanaga brings both volume and a different look to a rotation that already features Logan Webb and Landen Roupp.
The idea that works best for San Francisco is a short commitment. A two-year deal around the separately projected $40 million range feels like the sweet spot. Push beyond that, and the Giants would need a lot more faith that the home run issues won’t keep biting.
San Francisco’s offseason rotation picture already has Webb, Roupp, and Adrian Houser in place, with one outside addition and an internal battle expected to fill the rest. Imanaga could slide into that fourth established spot without forcing the team to abandon its younger arms.
The workload is a big part of the appeal. Imanaga made 32 starts for the Chicago Cubs in 2026 and finished with a 3.77 ERA, 174 strikeouts, and 37 walks across 174.1 innings. For a Giants staff that has dealt with plenty of injuries, that kind of durability matters.
He’d also give the Giants a left-handed starter in a rotation otherwise made up of three right-handers. His strike-throwing gives the staff a solid base, even if handedness alone doesn’t justify the price tag.
The obvious drawback is the long ball. Imanaga gave up 35 home runs in 2026 after allowing 31 in 2025. He limited traffic with his command, but when he missed, the damage was real.
Oracle Park at least gives San Francisco a reason to think the risk is manageable. Statcast’s 2026 home run park factor for the venue was 79, with 100 as league average, which points to a friendlier setting for a pitcher with that kind of profile.
That said, this is still a fit argument, not a promise that the home run problem goes away. Imanaga would still have to pitch on the road, and the Giants would need more than park help to keep the loud contact in check.
Hembekides’ destination call should be kept separate from the money projection. In his Nov. 3 free-agent rankings, ESPN’s Kiley McDaniel pegged Imanaga at two years and $40 million, or $20 million per season.
That number works as a benchmark, not a final price. It would also keep the Giants’ commitment to two seasons for a pitcher entering his age-33 campaign.
McDaniel also listed Imanaga as ineligible for a qualifying offer, which means no draft-pick compensation would come with the signing. That matters for a team trying to preserve as many assets as possible.
Giants On SI’s Nick Martinez contract analysis put the ceiling at two years and $36 million. Imanaga’s projection would add $4 million overall, or $2 million per year, while bringing in a pitcher who is three years younger.
The extra strikeouts and the age edge strengthen the case for spending a little more. The home run issue is still the main concern, and San Francisco should weigh those tradeoffs together instead of treating either veteran as the automatic answer.
Even if the Giants landed Imanaga, the bullpen would still need work. Any rotation addition has to leave room for improving the late innings too.
At around two years and $40 million, Hembekides’ prediction fits the Giants’ situation. If the deal starts creeping into a guaranteed third year, San Francisco should look elsewhere and not assume Oracle Park can absorb all the risk.
In Other News...
Giants Just Sent A Clear Message About What Could Be Next
The Giants latest roster housekeeping sent a pretty clear signal about how theyre approaching the winter. By non-tendering outfielder Victor Bericoto while still tendering contracts to Camilo Doval, Sam Hentges, Casey Schmitt and Randy Rodrguez, the club kept its core options intact and created a little more flexibility around the edges of the roster.
Bericoto is expected to come back on a minor league deal, which would open a 40-man spot without really closing the door on him. More importantly, the move hints that San Francisco may not be done shaping the roster, with the front office leaving itself room for additional signings or other adjustments as the offseason unfolds. [Read more 🡒]
Giants May End Up Regretting These Two Roster Decisions
The Giants moved on from two familiar pieces of their roster mix, trading reliever Ryan Walker to the Brewers and designating Christian Koss for assignment before sending him to the Rays. On paper, both departures made sense after underwhelming 2026 showings, especially with San Francisco having other options in place to cover those roles.
Still, the part that could linger for the Giants is where those players landed. Milwaukee and Tampa Bay have built reputations for squeezing more out of marginal talent than most clubs, and that is what makes these moves worth watching beyond the immediate roster shuffle. If Walker or Koss finds a better version of himself in a new uniform, it will be the sort of decision that looks far less routine in hindsight. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Just Shifted On A Logan Webb Scenario Fans Feared
Logan Webb has long been the kind of pitcher the Giants have treated as off-limits, the sort of arm a front office builds around rather than puts on the market. But according to MLB insider Robert Murray, San Francisco has changed its posture this offseason and is now open to listening to trade offers for the right-hander, a notable shift from its previous refusal to even engage in Webb discussions. For a team that has leaned on Webb as one of its most important rotation pieces, the idea alone marks a real change in how the organization is approaching its roster.
Webb is still under contract for the next two seasons on his five-year deal, which only adds to the intrigue around why the Giants would even be willing to hear teams out. Listening is not the same as moving him, of course, but it does signal that no scenario is entirely off the table as San Francisco weighs its next steps. For now, the question is less about whether Webb is available than how far the Giants are willing to go before drawing the line. [Read more 🡒]
