Jesús Rodríguez flashed enough with the bat in 2026 to keep the SF Giants interested, but the bigger question now is where he fits in 2027. That part is still murky.
He debuted last season and did well in a short look while bouncing around to a few spots. Even so, his path to a real role is complicated by one simple issue: the Giants still don’t have a clean defensive home for him.
When San Francisco acquired Rodríguez from the New York Yankees in 2025, the idea was that he could grow into a multi-position catcher. Austin Barnes, formerly of the Los Angeles Dodgers, was the kind of template the Giants had in mind - a player who could handle catcher and provide some coverage elsewhere.
Rodríguez has that sort of versatility on paper. In practice, though, he hasn’t shown he owns any one position.
The Giants gave the 24-year-old infielder an extended look behind the plate after calling him up in May, even though he wasn’t fully ready for the job. That move lined up with the club’s thinking at the time, as it appeared they were prepared to move on from Patrick Bailey and wanted to sort through alternatives.
Rodríguez’s numbers at catcher were rough. He posted -3 Defensive Runs Saved and -2 Fielding Run Value, and he did not throw out a runner in 10 tries. Small samples can distort defensive metrics, but in this case the numbers fit what showed up on the field.
He is not coming at catcher from zero experience, either. Rodríguez has more than 1,500 innings there in the minors, so this isn’t a matter of him needing to learn the position from scratch. The Giants, ideally, would want him to be a workable option there by now.
They also gave him a shot in the outfield, but that experiment looked unfinished. His best defensive spots are first base and third base, yet those lanes are crowded. Rafael Devers and Bryce Eldridge are handling first base, while Matt Chapman and Casey Schmitt are locked in at third.
That leaves Rodríguez needing to prove he can handle one of the positions where San Francisco actually has room for a bat. Right now, that probably means catcher, second base, or one of the outfield corners. And the clock matters, because he has already used two minor league option years.
What the Giants do know is that the bat plays. Rodríguez makes a lot of contact, works the opposite field, and doesn’t look like a player who is going to swing and miss his way out of opportunities.
He probably won’t pile up walks or extra-base hits, but he does keep the ball in play. In 58 plate appearances, the right-handed hitter put up a .728 OPS with two home runs and eight RBI.
In Other News...
Giants 2027 Lineup Projection Leaves Several Starting Jobs Up For Grabs
The Giants are already looking far beyond this season, and their early 2027 Opening Day lineup projection shows just how much can still change between now and then. Based on players currently in the organization and the assumption everyone is healthy by Opening Day, the outline includes familiar names such as Eldridge, Devers, Schmitt, Mayer, Davidson, Bader and Susac, but it also leaves plenty of room for movement as the front office continues to shape the roster.
What stands out most is how many everyday jobs are still up for grabs, with second base, left field and catcher among the spots that remain unsettled. Those positions could look very different after offseason additions, trades or medical updates, which is a reminder that even a preliminary projection is more of a snapshot than a promise. For now, the Giants have a framework, but several of the most important decisions are still waiting to be made. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Trade Could Haunt San Francisco Far Longer Than Fans Expected
The Rafael Devers deal was always going to be measured against more than just what the Giants got back in the moment, and the early returns have only made that harder on San Francisco. In 2025, the club sent Kyle Harrison, Jordan Hicks, Jose Bello and prospect James Tibbs III to Boston, hoping the swap would reshape the roster in a hurry and give the lineup a marquee middle-order bat.
Instead, the long view is starting to look more complicated for the Giants. Harrison has settled in nicely with the Brewers, Hicks has taken a step forward as a reliever with the White Sox and Tibbs has been productive in the Dodgers system, which leaves San Francisco not just tracking Devers, but also wondering how much value it may have given away in the process. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Have An October Pitching Question That Could Shape 2027
The Giants know the pitching picture is going to need attention again, and the conversation starts with a staff that finished 23rd in baseball with a 4.34 ERA in 2026. That kind of number leaves little doubt about where the pressure points are heading into the winter, especially for a team trying to sort out how to get back to a more reliable level on the mound.
One route is the free-agent market, where Nick Martinez, Shawn Armstrong and JoJo Romero stand out as possible fits for San Francisco in 2027. Each brings a different recent track record and a different way to help a staff that needs more stability, and the Giants will have to decide whether one of them is the kind of answer that can actually move the needle or just part of a larger reset. [Read more 🡒]