The Giants know exactly where the pressure is this offseason: the pitching staff needs help, and Buster Posey made that plain during Tuesday’s end-of-season press conference. If San Francisco decides to attack the problem through a trade, Sandy Alcantara looks like a name worth circling, even if the Marlins reportedly aren’t eager to move him.
Miami, despite not being all that competitive in 2026, apparently still sees Alcantara as a core piece. President of baseball operations Peter Benedict and general manager Gabe Kapler may not be shopping him, but the Giants could still try to make the idea more appealing. Zack Minasian’s past with Kapler and Posey’s connection as a former player under him could help open the door.
Alcantara’s 2026 season gives San Francisco a lot to think about. He posted a 3.87 ERA, made 36 starts and led the league with 214 innings. Later in the year, he even made a few relief appearances and worked as a closer.
That kind of versatility would give the Giants choices if they ever got serious about a deal. The cleanest plan would be to keep him in the rotation, but the bullpen could also be a landing spot if the Giants decide the back end of games needs the bigger fix.
The 2022 NL Cy Young Award winner is also tied to a $21 million club option for next season, and Miami is expected to pick it up. That’s a hefty number for a closer, but after how badly the Giants struggled to finish games last season, they may have to consider paying up.
There’s risk here, of course. Alcantara is 31, can become a free agent after 2027, and the uncertainty around a possible 2027 lockout only adds another layer of unpredictability. That uncertainty might also be what makes him available at all.
If the Giants are looking for a trade chip, Jung Hoo Lee could fit the bill. Miami needs corner outfield help, and San Francisco might be willing to move Lee if it meant landing an elite arm. Lee faded in the second half of 2026, and questions have started to build around his value.
Lee is due $23,250,000 next year, which puts his salary in the same neighborhood as Alcantara’s. He also has a player option after 2027, and while he could test free agency, it might make more sense for him to opt in and secure $51 million over the final two years of the deal.
Even then, the Giants would probably need to add prospects to make the package work, possibly someone like Bo Davidson or Parks Harber. It would be a significant swing, but not an outrageous one. And if things went sideways again, San Francisco could always flip Alcantara to a contender at the 2027 trade deadline and recoup some prospect value.
In Other News...
Former Giants Outfielder Suddenly Matters In Yankees Playoff Push
The Yankees still managed to secure the top AL Wild Card seed at 93-68 even with Aaron Judge sidelined for a significant stretch, and now they head into the postseason with their lineup still missing its biggest bat. Judge is expected to miss at least the Wild Card series against the Red Sox, which puts added pressure on the rest of the roster to make up for his absence in a matchup that figures to be tight from the start.
Heliot Ramos, recently acquired from the Giants, has not produced much at the plate since joining New York, but his value may be rising at exactly the right time. The Yankees could lean on him against left-handed pitching in the playoff lineup, giving the former San Francisco outfielder a chance to matter in a series where every at-bat will carry extra weight. [Read more 🡒]
Tony Vitello Just Raised A Troubling Giants Question That Wont Go Away
The Giants end-of-season discussion offered plenty of familiar offseason themes, from a bullpen that needs to be addressed to a coaching staff that could look different by spring. But one of the more revealing moments came when Tony Vitello was pressed on a basic managerial question: whether he still has control of the clubhouse. His answer never quite landed in a direct way, which only added to the sense that this remains a live issue inside the organization.
Vitello has already shown a willingness to defer to veteran players, and his handling of Willy Adames playing through injury was one example that stuck out. For a team trying to reset after a disappointing season, the bigger question is whether that approach reflects steady leadership or a manager still feeling out the boundaries of his own authority. However the Giants choose to build the roster and staff this winter, that uncertainty is not going away quietly. [Read more 🡒]
Rafael Devers Has A Giants Honor Case Fans Will Debate
The All-MLB Team race is back on the board, and Giants fans now have a familiar star to weigh in on. Rafael Devers is the clubs nominee for the fan vote, with ballots open until Oct. 9, giving supporters one more chance to recognize a season that featured plenty of impact at the plate even if it ended early.
Devers case is a straightforward one on offense, but it comes with the kind of wrinkle that can make these honor debates linger. He was shut down in mid-September after landing on the 60-day injured list with a core injury that required surgery, cutting short his first season in San Francisco. The production was there, the availability was not, and for Giants fans that split will likely shape how they judge his place on the All-MLB ballot. [Read more 🡒]