The SF Giants came away from the trade deadline with real value, landing a batch of intriguing prospects and moving the pieces they were supposed to move. But there’s still a lingering question hanging over one part of their deadline work: did they leave a little something on the table?
That question starts with Michael Fulmer, a veteran pitcher the Giants never brought up from Triple-A Sacramento despite a season that, by all accounts, was solid enough to earn a look. Even with the bullpen taking hit after hit, Fulmer stayed parked in the minors until the Giants let him go.
From there, the path got a little more interesting. Fulmer signed with the Los Angeles Angels, threw 3 and 2/3 scoreless innings, and then was designated for assignment.
He chose free agency, and the New York Yankees picked him up. He already made his debut for them and worked a scoreless inning.
That’s what makes the Giants’ handling of Fulmer worth revisiting. If the Yankees had enough interest to sign him, it raises the possibility that San Francisco might have been able to squeeze a bit more out of Brian Cashman if Fulmer had been part of the deal that sent Heliot Ramos to New York in exchange for pitcher Henry Lalane and second baseman Kaeden Kent.
Fulmer probably wasn’t going to swing the whole trade. He wasn’t going to be the difference between the Giants and George Lombard Jr. Still, he might have nudged the return in a better direction and brought back one more prospect.
One name worth watching in the Yankees’ system was Eric Reyzelman, a 25-year-old pitcher with Bay Area ties. He was born in San Ramon, went to De La Salle High School, and spent two seasons at the University of San Francisco. As of 2025, he was ranked as a top-25 prospect in the Yankees organization.
The results this season have been rough. Reyzelman has a 7.40 ERA across 41 and 1/3 innings, and things have looked even worse since his move to Triple-A, where his ERA sits at 10.50.
The control has been the issue: he’s walked 22 batters in 24 innings at Triple-A. But the swing-and-miss ability is still there, with 33 strikeouts in Triple-A and 32 more in 17 and 1/3 innings at Double-A this year.
That kind of profile can sometimes travel well if a player gets back to familiar ground, which is why the idea of Reyzelman landing in San Francisco had some appeal. If the Giants had been able to get him by including Fulmer, maybe Northern California would have helped him settle in and get his command back.
That didn’t happen. But given where Reyzelman is now, the Giants may still get another chance if the Yankees decide to move on and release him.
And that’s what makes the Fulmer situation stand out so much. The Giants never even gave him a shot in the majors, and now he’s pitching effectively for other teams. That leaves a pretty basic question: why bring in a veteran like that if you’re not going to use him, either in your bullpen or as part of a trade?
In Other News...
Giants Are About To Get A Real Read On The Yastrzemski Trade
The Giants are expected to get a more concrete look at one of the arms they picked up in last years Mike Yastrzemski trade, with right-hander Yunior Marte on track for a call-up. Marte has worked his way into the conversation after a solid run in the minors, posting a 3.85 ERA between Double-A and High-A while putting himself on the radar as a potential Rule 5 Draft candidate.
For San Francisco, the timing matters because the pitching staff has been hit by injuries and the club could use another reliever option in the near term. Martes arrival would also force a decision on whether to add him to the 40-man roster, giving the Giants a real chance to judge whether the trade is starting to pay off in a way that goes beyond the original headline. [Read more 🡒]
Willy Adames Leaves Giants Facing One Huge Shortstop Decision
Willy Adames has given the Giants plenty to think about as they look ahead to 2026, and not just because of the elbow sprain that is expected to send him toward a PRP injection. The shortstop has also been dealing with a back ailment, and the combination has taken a toll on both sides of his game, leaving San Francisco with a much more complicated middle-infield picture than it anticipated.
For a club that signed Adames to stabilize a premium defensive position, the question now is whether he can still handle shortstop at the level the Giants need. His struggles in the field have already prompted talk of a possible move, and with his availability for next season suddenly in doubt, San Francisco may have to decide whether to keep waiting on a rebound or start planning a different path at a key spot on the diamond. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Loss Boils Over As Logan Webb Hits A First
The frustration had been building for the Giants long before the final inning unraveled, and it spilled over after a disputed call on a Nolan Arenado double that was ruled fair. Tony Vitello was ejected for the second time in three games, and the loss took on an even sharper edge when Logan Webb was tossed for the first time in his career, a rare flashpoint for one of the clubs most steady voices on the mound.
Braxton Roxby also got a first to remember in the same game, making his major league debut and working a clean ninth inning to finish off the side. The right-hander closed it out with Tim Tawa for his first career strikeout, a small bright spot on a night when the Giants were left more focused on the arguments than the box score. [Read more 🡒]