The Giants have a bullpen problem to solve, and Hoby Milner fits best as part of the answer only if the role is crystal clear.
San Francisco’s relief group finished 2026 with a 4.14 ERA and 27 blown saves, so there’s no shortage of work to do when free agency opens. A left-hander with an unusual delivery could help broaden the mix, but the fit has to be specific. Milner shouldn’t be viewed as a cure-all.
His 2026 numbers across 42 innings with the Chicago Cubs and Seattle Mariners make him worth a closer look. He turned in a 3.64 ERA and 1.24 WHIP, while allowing 10 walks and striking out 25. Based on 177 batters faced, that worked out to a 5.6% walk rate and a 14.1% strikeout rate, according to his Baseball Savant data.
The appeal is obvious enough. Keeping walks down would help the Giants avoid giving away free baserunners and stretching innings. Milner’s low release point also gives hitters a different visual than the typical lefty.
But the strikeout total is the catch. Twenty-five punchouts in 42 innings does not point to a pitcher the Giants should trust as their main answer in high-stress moments with runners on base.
That’s why any interest should come with limits attached. A one-year deal would make sense if his medical evaluation checks out and the matchups line up. Anything longer would need more proof than a quirky delivery and a solid ERA.
That view is a recommendation, not a report of contract terms or a prediction about the market.
Milner can still have value for San Francisco as one piece of a larger bullpen rebuild. He could handle selected middle-inning work and give the manager another left-handed option while the Giants continue looking for pitchers who can miss more bats when the game tightens.
Before making that call, the club should dig into how his pitches performed against both sides of the plate, how he dealt with inherited runners and whether his command held up in back-to-back outings. Being left-handed by itself is not enough reason to spend a roster spot.
The broader idea is simple: define the job first, then find the arm that matches it. On that standard, Milner deserves consideration. The Giants should just make sure they are paying for the innings he is expected to cover, not the ones they hope he might someday handle.
In Other News...
Giants May Have Found Another Low-Cost Pitching Gamble Worth Watching
With the free-agent market for pitching already looking thin, the Giants are among the teams sorting through familiar names and bargain-bin fits, and Carlos Hernndez has emerged as one worth a closer look. Connor Brogdon and Hernndez both electing free agency only underscores how many clubs may be shopping in the same narrow lane, and San Francisco has reason to keep tabs on a pitcher who can bring a power arm and some experience without demanding much financial commitment.
Hernndez is the kind of low-cost gamble that can make sense for a Giants staff trying to find value wherever it can. His past performance metrics, injury history and pitch mix all come with obvious caveats, but the appeal is clear enough, especially when compared with Anthony Molina as a possible template for how San Francisco might think about slotting him into the pitching picture. The open question is whether the Giants think the upside is worth the risk, and whether Hernndez ends up being the sort of under-the-radar addition that can stick long enough to matter. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Took A Chance On Jerar Encarnacion And Got Nothing Back
Jerar Encarnacion earned a spot on the Giants opening-day roster in 2026, but his time in San Francisco never really got off the ground. The bat never came around the way the club hoped, and by May he had been designated for assignment, a quick end for a player the organization had taken a shot on and hoped might provide some middle-of-the-order upside.
After choosing free agency, Encarnacion headed to Japan and joined the Yokohama DeNA BayStars, where the change of scenery seemed to help. He got into 64 games and turned in better offensive numbers, though his season ended with a right leg injury in the postseason that kept him out of the Japan Series. Even so, the BayStars are expected to keep him around for 2027, giving him a chance to build on that rebound. [Read more 🡒]
Willy Adames Must Fix This One Problem For Giants In 2027
Willy Adames first season-plus in San Francisco has given the Giants a clearer read on what they have at the plate, and it is a profile that has shifted in a few important ways. His batting average and slugging percentage ticked up from 2025 to 2026, but the bigger picture pointed the other direction, with his on-base ability and walk rate slipping as his approach became a little less controlled.
The numbers behind that change are the kind the Giants will study closely as they map out 2027. Adames chased more pitches outside the strike zone and offered at fewer strikes inside it last season, a combination that can chip away at a hitters overall value even when the power production holds steady. For a lineup that needs more reliable traffic on the bases, the next step is clear enough: improving his plate discipline has to be part of the offensive conversation. [Read more 🡒]