The Giants have reached the part of the season where the only thing left to trade is possibility.
Wins are off the table. Hope isn’t.
And if San Francisco is going to sell hope, the cleanest way to do it is by moving the players who can actually bring something back before the Aug. 3 MLB trade deadline.
That means anyone not in pre-arbitration should be on the market, and the sooner the better before an injury takes somebody off the board.
At 24 Willie Mays Plaza, there’s a case to be made that the roster should be treated like a clearance rack.
Jung Hoo Lee sits near the top of the list of names that could draw real interest. He has an opt-out after 2027, but for a new club he still offers at least a year and a half of affordable bat-to-ball production and solid outfield defense. The kind of return that makes sense there: a top-50 prospect plus another organizational top-20 prospect.
Luis Arraez would also have a strong market, even as a rental with free agency waiting at the end of this season. His contact skills are elite, and his defense has been surprisingly strong this year, which should make him appealing to contenders looking for a steady table-setter ahead of their power bats. The expectation here is a high-upside fringe top-100 prospect or a pair of top-15 system prospects.
One possible fit: the Yankees, who need infield contact and a spark at the top of the lineup. In that deal, Arraez could go to New York for right-hander Chase Hampton, once a top-100 prospect and now the Yankees’ No. 8 prospect, plus maybe shortstop Kaeden Kent, the Yankees’ No. 13 prospect and son of former Giant Jeff Kent. That might sound expensive, but there’s reason to think the market could push the Giants into getting that second prospect too.
Matt Chapman is a different kind of trade chip entirely. The goal there is financial relief.
He’s owed $25 million per year through 2030 and has a full no-trade clause, so the value isn’t really in the player coming back. It’s in getting out from under the money.
The source also notes that, in a small sample, Chapman hasn’t clearly given the Giants more this season than Casey Schmitt did while covering the hot corner during Chapman’s injury absence.
If Chapman is moved, it would take agreement from all three sides: the Giants, the other club, and Chapman himself. One possible route is a Yankees deal in which New York takes on 70 percent of the remaining contract and sends back Spencer Jones. Another possibility is attaching Chapman to an Arraez trade and settling for a smaller prospect return, perhaps just Hampton or Kent.
Robbie Ray is the other premium name. Starting pitching always gets loud at the deadline, and contenders looking for rotation help will only drive his price up before Aug.
- The kind of return projected here is similar to Arraez: a high-upside fringe top-100 prospect or two top-15 system prospects.
The Braves are mentioned as a strong fit, with Owen Murphy and Ethan Bagwell as possible pieces. The Cubs also make sense, with Ethan Conrad and Jostin Florentino as names that could be in play, though the piece makes clear Chicago probably won’t part with catcher Moisés Ballesteros.
Then there are the movable leftovers. Caleb Kilian, JT Brubaker and Sam Hentges are framed as the kind of pieces that might bring back a bag of balls, a player to be named later that never gets named, and maybe a crab sandwich.
Harrison Bader could fetch a generic bullpen arm or a single top-40 prospect, though his $10 million salary next season makes him hard to move unless the Giants eat money or take a bad contract back. The Rays are floated as a possible fit, but only with a healthy dose of guesswork.
And then there are the names that don’t move at all.
Rafael Devers and Willy Adames are listed with the same answer: zilch.
Logan Webb, meanwhile, would be the biggest prize of all. The piece says he could bring back two Top-100 prospects, one for each remaining year of team control, plus another top-10 or top-15 system prospect or two for the rest of this season.
But the Giants aren’t even taking calls on him. For now, he’s staying put.
In Other News...
Giants Just Lost A Bullpen Arm Fans Thought Could Help
Gregory Santos latest stint with the Giants has taken another turn, and it leaves San Francisco without a bullpen arm it had hoped might still provide some help. Santos, who has spent parts of six major league seasons in the game, had been working his way back through the organization after injury setbacks and a recent run in Sacramento, where the Giants were trying to keep him close as depth.
Instead, Santos is moving on after clearing waivers and declining an outright assignment to Triple-A Sacramento. His departure comes with the kind of familiar frustration that follows a pitcher with talent but an uneven health track record, especially one who had already drawn interest from other clubs as a minor league free agent. For the Giants, it is another reminder of how quickly bullpen options can disappear when a player has enough leverage to test the market. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Rotation Trouble Just Hit A Frustrating New Low
Trevor McDonalds start against Toronto quickly turned into the kind of afternoon the Giants have been trying to avoid as the rotation continues to wobble. He was hit hard from the outset, and San Francisco was left chasing the game in a 9-3 loss that put even more stress on a pitching staff already looking for stability.
Adrian Houser at least gave the Giants something to hang onto, covering 5 2/3 no-hit innings in relief and helping keep the bullpen from getting emptied out. Rookie Spencer Miles handled the start for the Blue Jays and allowed two runs over four innings, but the bigger concern for San Francisco remains the same: the rotation keeps putting the club in early holes, and this one felt especially frustrating. [Read more 🡒]
Giants May Already Be Giving Up On A Key Winter Signing
Tyler Mahle arrived in San Francisco as one of the winter additions meant to stabilize a rotation that needed help, but the season has not gone the way the Giants envisioned. The right-hander has struggled to find consistency, and his name is now surfacing in the same trade chatter as other veterans the club could move before the deadline as it tries to retool around a disappointing year.
Buster Posey is reportedly open to dealing established pieces for prospects, and Mahle fits the profile of a pitcher contenders might still believe in because of what he showed a year ago in Texas. Even with the uneven results and a recent hamstring issue slowing him down, there is still a case for clubs to look past the rough stretch and bet on a rebound, which is exactly why his market will be worth watching in the coming weeks. [Read more 🡒]