The SF Giants’ bullpen problems in 2026 didn’t start this year. The cracks go back to the Tyler Rogers trade, and the numbers make that hard to ignore.
Before Rogers was dealt, San Francisco’s relief corps had a 3.26 ERA, second-best in baseball. Rogers was a central part of that group alongside Camilo Doval, Randy Rodríguez and Erik Miller. Miller, though, missed the second half with an elbow sprain, and the whole unit eventually unraveled from there.
By the time the season wound down, that core had been broken apart. Doval and Rogers were moved at the trade deadline, while Rodríguez had Tommy John surgery.
Rodríguez had earned an NL All-Star nod, and Doval and Miller each flashed effectiveness, even if the underlying numbers weren’t always as strong. Rogers, though, stood out as the most reliable piece.
He could take the eighth inning every other day and keep doing it without losing much, which is a rare kind of value in a bullpen.
Since the trade, the Giants have posted a 4.28 ERA out of the bullpen, which ranks 20th in baseball over that span. That slide isn’t all on one transaction, but it does show how important Rogers had been for years.
San Francisco still hasn’t found much stability in the relief mix over the last 11 months. The club has kept cycling through arms, but no real answers have stuck.
Rogers, meanwhile, landed with the Toronto Blue Jays on a three-year, $37 million deal that includes a team option for a fourth year. Toronto is in town for a three-game series, and Rogers has been excellent in his first season there, putting up a 1.77 ERA in 42 appearances. Only a handful of relievers have appeared in more games, and only Brent Headrick of the New York Yankees has a better ERA at 1.45.
The Giants had to act because Rogers was on an expiring deal, and the return was Drew Gilbert, Blade Tidwell and José Buttó. If Gilbert develops into a role player for a couple of seasons, the deal will have worked out well.
It could look even better later if Tidwell finds a spot on the pitching staff. This isn’t really about reopening the trade.
It’s about recognizing just how important Rogers was to that Giants bullpen.
In Other News...
Giants Draft Plans Just Got Shaken Up By A Pitching Scare
The Giants entered draft season with real flexibility at No. 4 overall and a bonus pool that gives them room to be aggressive, which is why a hard-throwing high school arm like Brody Bumila had been on the radar. San Francisco has been linked to plenty of pitching possibilities, and Bumilas fastball made him the kind of upside play that can fit in a draft where the club could choose to chase ceiling or spread its money around.
Now the calculus looks different after the elbow scare that knocked Bumila off the board for the early rounds. He had been a name worth watching for the Giants, but with his stock suddenly clouded, San Francisco may have to pivot toward other arms or a different kind of prospect altogether as draft day approaches. [Read more 🡒]
Heliot Ramos Just Delivered The Kind Of Night Giants Needed
Heliot Ramos gave the Giants the kind of jolt they have been waiting for in the middle of a long season, turning his return from a right quad strain into a statement night against the Blue Jays. Back in the lineup after a rehab assignment, Ramos has wasted little time getting comfortable again, and his power has shown up immediately, with four home runs in his first eight games since coming off the injured list.
The bigger picture for San Francisco is encouraging, too, because the outfield is almost whole again and the club is starting to see what it can look like when Ramos is healthy and driving the offense. Harrison Bader remains the lone holdout while he works back from plantar fasciitis, leaving the Giants with one last health question in the grass even as Ramos keeps giving them reasons to feel better about the lineup. [Read more 🡒]