Giants Already Have One Painful Question About That Red Sox Trade

Despite trading for an injured prospect, the Red Sox's unexpected move for Erik Miller has paid off as he excels in their bullpen, leaving the Giants to ponder the cost of their decision.

The Boston Red Sox made a move that turned heads ahead of the 2026 Major League Baseball trade deadline, and early on, the return is looking like a win.

Boston shipped former top prospect Marcelo Mayer to the San Francisco Giants in exchange for left-handed reliever Erik Miller and minor league outfielder Carlos Gutierrez. Mayer still hasn’t made his Giants debut, and there’s a reason for that: he’s dealing with an injury. Alex Pavlovic of NBC Sports Bay Area reported on Aug. 24 that Mayer was not doing baseball activities at the time.

Mayer could still pan out in San Francisco down the line, but for now the health questions remain. Miller, meanwhile, has been exactly what the Red Sox hoped for and then some.

Since the trade, Miller has appeared in 10 games for Boston and has yet to allow an earned run. He’s worked 10 1/3 innings, posted an 18-to-3 strikeout-to-walk ratio, and put up a 0.76 FIP and a 0.968 WHIP.

He’s also struck out 15.7 batters per nine innings. Boston has gotten elite relief work, and the Giants have to feel the sting of losing him, especially with their bullpen sitting 19th in baseball with a 4.23 ERA.

Just Baseball noted on X that Miller is the only pitcher since the trade deadline who hasn’t allowed an earned run while striking out 11 or more batters per nine innings.

"The only pitcher since the trade deadline that hasn't allowed a run with 11+ K/9, min. 10 IP:ERIK MILLER‼️

What an addition Miller has been to Boston's bullpen! pic.twitter.com/5TzzBkMEBD"

Miller also comes with three more seasons of team control beyond 2026, which only adds to the appeal for Boston. Giving up Mayer was a bold call, but if Miller keeps pitching like this, the trade will look better and better for the Red Sox.

Part of what makes the deal easier to accept for Boston is the organization’s depth in the middle infield and at the infield corners. No. 1 overall prospect Franklin Arias is one step from the majors and tearing the cover off the ball.

Caleb Durbin looks like the third baseman of the future. Willson Contreras has time left on his deal beyond 2026 and will handle first base, while Arias should slide into one of the middle infield spots when he gets the call.

Trevor Story also has another season left on his contract in 2027 before a club option in 2028.

Boston has also gotten encouraging production this season from Nick Sogard, Anthony Seigler and Andruw Monasterio.

So far, the Red Sox have turned a player who had struggled into a reliever who could be a long-term bullpen fixture. Right now, that’s a strong outcome for Boston.

In Other News...

Giants Injury Crisis Could Force A Veteran Move Fans Didn't Expect

The Giants have spent much of the 2026 season piecing together a roster that has been battered on both sides of the ball, with injuries hitting position players and pitchers alike. In response, the front office has already cycled through plenty of roster moves just to keep the club afloat, and now the search for help appears to be widening beyond the usual internal fixes.

Among the veteran names being discussed are Eugenio Surez, Michael Lorenzen, Zack Littell and Austin Slater, a group that would give San Francisco more depth and flexibility as the injury problems continue. It is the kind of backup plan teams rarely want to lean on for long, but for a Giants club trying to stabilize the daily lineup and the pitching staff at the same time, the need for reinforcements is becoming impossible to ignore. [Read more 🡒]

Giants Infield Shuffle Could Mean More Than A Buddy Kennedy Exit

Bryce Eldridge is back with the Giants after a brief stay on the bereavement list, and the roster move that made room for him sent Buddy Kennedy off the 40-man roster. It is the kind of infield shuffle that can look routine on the surface, especially for a player like Kennedy, who has hit much better in Triple-A than he has in the majors and has spent much of this season fighting for a foothold.

The wrinkle for San Francisco is what comes next, because Kennedy has already used up his option years and now has to go through waivers. If another club claims him, the Giants lose a depth piece they clearly had room for only in the short term; if he gets through, his past outright assignments give him the ability to choose free agency, leaving his future tied to a process the Giants cannot fully control. [Read more 🡒]

Giants Suddenly Face A Willy Adames Problem That Wont End Here

Willy Adames first season in San Francisco has taken another hard turn, with the Giants confirming the shortstop has a left UCL sprain and will go through rest and rehabilitation after receiving a PRP injection. The club said the usual recovery window is 3-4 weeks, but manager Tony Vitello made clear the outlook is far murkier than that, saying it is unlikely Adames will return this season and that surgery is not currently on the table.

For a Giants team already trying to manage a long list of health issues, the timing is brutal. Catcher Jess Rodrguez has hit a setback in his recovery from right elbow neuritis, while right-hander Adrian Houser is now working through a right flexor strain with rehab plans still to be determined. Even without a definitive end point on Adames, the bigger concern for San Francisco is how quickly this latest injury stretches an already thin roster even further. [Read more 🡒]