Giants Already Had A Grant McCray Problem They Couldnt Ignore

Despite Grant McCray's impressive speed and defensive skills, his persistent struggles at the plate ultimately led the SF Giants to move on, highlighting the challenges of sticking in the majors amidst promising competition.

Grant McCray kept flashing the kind of tools that make teams want to keep betting on him. The problem for the Giants never changed: the bat just didn’t come around enough to make the rest of it matter.

In 43 games this past season, McCray hit .143/.250/.273 with two home runs and four runs batted in. He added eight stolen bases, which at least showed the speed that has always made him such an intriguing player. That line was better than what he produced in 2025, but it still didn’t stack up to 2024, when he hit .202/.238/.379 with five homers and 10 runs driven in.

That’s been the story each time the Giants have brought him up over the last few seasons. They either needed outfield help because of injuries or were out of contention and wanted to take a look, and McCray would show enough athleticism to keep the door open. But every time, the same issue followed him: he couldn’t do enough at the plate to stick.

What makes McCray so frustrating, and so easy to keep dreaming on, is that he fits the mold the Giants have been searching for. A homegrown outfielder with speed and Gold Glove caliber defense is exactly the sort of player they’ve wanted for years. McCray just never hit well enough to earn a regular spot.

The Giants got a version of that profile from Jonah Cox in 2026 instead. Cox looked great in center field, was surprisingly solid at second base, and hit fairly well even if he did look a little overmatched at times.

With that kind of crowd in the outfield, McCray became the odd man out. He was one of the team’s 40-man roster cuts after the season, and the Seattle Mariners claimed him off waivers, which wasn’t much of a surprise.

There’s still a case for why another club will keep giving him chances. Players with his skill set tend to get opportunities because one adjustment at the plate can change everything. Even if he never becomes an everyday guy, he can still matter as a fourth or fifth outfielder, especially with his ability to come in late as a defensive replacement or a pinch runner.

The Giants simply had too many young outfielders for McCray to hold onto a spot, the same way Luis Matos was squeezed out after spring training in 2026. San Francisco is likely to keep moving forward with other options such as Turner Hill and Scott Bandura.

McCray did leave behind a few memorable moments in a Giants uniform, including the throw that gunned down a runner on the bases in the game against the Los Angeles Dodgers in 2025 when Patrick Bailey hit his walk-off grand slam. Now the question is whether he can finally put everything together somewhere else.

In Other News...

Giants Lose Another Key Coach As Staff Turnover Keeps Growing

Another piece of the Giants coaching infrastructure is being reshaped, with Alex Burg leaving San Francisco to join the Guardians as a quality control coach. Burg had been with the organization since 2022 and had seen his responsibilities expand during his time on staff, making him one of the more familiar behind-the-scenes figures in the clubhouse.

His departure comes amid a broader round of staff changes for the Giants, who have already brought in James Rowson as offensive coordinator and reassigned several other coaches to new roles. The turnover keeps adding up, and it leaves the club continuing to sort out how its new staff will fit together heading into the next phase of the offseason. [Read more 🡒]

Buster Posey Just Framed The Giants Biggest Offseason Test

Buster Posey has already put a clear shape around the Giants winter, and it starts on the mound. As president of baseball operations, he said the clubs offseason plan is centered on pitching, with only two rotation spots currently spoken for and three more to be filled by a mix of outside additions and internal competition.

The bullpen picture looks just as deliberate, with San Francisco expected to lean more toward trades than free-agent signings tied to qualifying offers. It leaves the Giants with a fairly specific shopping list and a lot of pressure to get the pitching mix right, because the next wave of moves will go a long way toward defining how competitive this roster can be. [Read more 🡒]

Giants Face A Costly Bullpen Dilemma With David Bednar

David Bednar has quickly become one of the more intriguing names on the market, and his situation matters in San Francisco because the Giants are looking for bullpen help while also trying to keep their roster-building options intact. After converting 35 of 39 save chances with a 2.47 ERA for the Yankees in 2026, Bednar now has until Tuesday to decide whether to accept or decline New Yorks qualifying offer, a choice that could shape how aggressively other clubs pursue him.

For the Giants, the appeal is obvious, but so is the cost. If Bednar turns down the offer and signs elsewhere, San Francisco would have to give up a draft pick and international signing pool money under MLBs compensation rules, a tradeoff that lands squarely in the middle of Buster Poseys broader offseason balancing act. The Giants are already weighing bullpen upgrades against injury concerns and the need to add starting pitching, which makes any move for a premium reliever feel a little more complicated than it might look on paper. [Read more 🡒]