Buster Posey’s first big swing as the SF Giants’ president of baseball operations was a loud one, landing shortstop Willy Adames on the largest deal in franchise history. That move made it easy to imagine a front office ready to keep charging hard. But most of Posey’s work since then has been far more measured, with the blockbuster trade for Rafael Devers in June of 2025 standing out as the clear exception.
Now the Giants are coming off a 65-97 season in 2026, and the big question is how far Posey will go this winter. Pitching will be a priority - that much seems certain - but last offseason Posey said the same thing and ended up with Adrian Houser and Tyler Mahle in the rotation, plus a cluster of injured relievers to patch together the bullpen.
The results were ugly enough that the Giants should be more active this time around, even if they still don’t look like a club ready to blow up the payroll. Greg Johnson is still in the picture too, and while he may not be as public about it as last offseason, the message is probably still the same: don’t spend too much on a starter.
So what kind of free agents fit the Giants’ lane? Think of it in three buckets.
The first group is the one that feels out of reach. Tarik Skubal, Randy Arozarena, Freddy Peralta, Michael King, Sonny Gray, Jazz Chisholm Jr., David Bednar, and Adrian Morejon all land in the “too hot” category.
In other words, the kind of names that show up near the top of every “Top X MLB Free Agents” list and probably won’t be coming to San Francisco. After a season like 2026, it’s hard to picture the rest of the ownership group signing off on a major payroll jump.
Some of these players also received qualifying offers, which could cost the Giants draft compensation or international bonus pool money, though that might change under a new CBA. Either way, this doesn’t look like the tier where Posey will shop.
Then there’s the group the Giants likely want no part of. Walker Buehler, Chris Bassitt, Patrick Corbin, Kiké Hernandez, Austin Slater, Robert Stephenson, and Jordan Romano all fit the “too cold” label.
These are the kinds of bets that could leave the Giants spinning their wheels again: veteran starters on one-year deals hoping for one last useful season, or relievers coming off injuries. Stephenson, a Bay Area native, is the one exception the piece leaves a little room for - a minor league deal wouldn’t be outrageous - but if that sort of move becomes the backbone of the bullpen plan, fans would have every reason to be frustrated.
The same caution applies to the outfield. A right-handed platoon bat is not an absolute must, especially with Victor Bericoto showing promise, but adding someone like Slater or Hernandez alone would not really solve the issue.
That leaves the middle ground, and that’s where the Giants’ most realistic targets seem to live. Kevin Gausman, Shota Imanaga, Clay Holmes, David Peterson, Kris Bubic, Casey Mize, JoJo Romero, Kenley Jansen, Raisel Iglesias, Steven Okert, Randal Grichuk, and Taylor Ward all sit in the “just right” tier.
These are the kinds of players who could fit on reasonable deals: starters on two- or three-year contracts, relievers and closers on one- or two-year pacts, and outfielders on one-year arrangements. The appeal is simple - enough upside to matter, without pushing the Giants into uncomfortable territory.
That middle lane is also where the prediction for San Francisco’s offseason lands. The Giants should be more aggressive than they were a year ago, but not to the point of another Adames-sized splash. A sensible winter, perhaps headlined by a reunion with Gausman, would be enough to make the roster look sturdier and give fans at least some reason to believe 2027 can go better.
In Other News...
Bryce Eldridge Just Got The Perfect Fuel For A Bigger 2027
Bryce Eldridges rookie season gave the Giants enough reason to believe they may have found something real, even if the broader league did not fully catch up yet. He finished with only two fifth-place votes in National League Rookie of the Year voting, a reminder that awards often reward the loudest full-season cases, not always the player who looks like he is just starting to turn the corner. Sal Stewart of the Reds took the honor after playing all 162 games and putting up the kind of power numbers that tend to stick in voters minds.
For San Francisco, though, Eldridges case is less about where he landed in one award race and more about what came next. He got into 107 games, posted a higher OPS, and still looked like a player with more growth ahead of him than behind him. If the rookie year was the introduction, the Giants have every reason to think the next step could be the one that changes how the rest of the league talks about him. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Offseason Plans Hinge On One Financial Question
The Giants already have a clear shopping list for the offseason, with rotation help, bullpen depth and a better answer against left-handed pitching all sitting near the top of it. The catch is that every one of those needs has to be weighed against the clubs long-term payroll picture, and right now San Francisco is staring at $183 million committed against the luxury tax in 2027.
What makes the planning trickier is that the next Collective Bargaining Agreement cycle could change the luxury tax threshold and the penalties tied to it, which would alter how aggressive the Giants can be in the market. They can identify the free-agent pitchers and bullpen upgrades they want, but how far they can actually go may depend on a financial landscape that is still very much in flux. [Read more 🡒]
Giants May Already Have A First Pitching Fix In Mind
After a disappointing season, the Giants are expected to spend the winter looking for ways to steady a pitching staff that never quite found its footing. One name that has started to surface as a possible fit is Nick Martinez, with Tim Kelly of Bleacher Report predicting San Francisco could target the veteran right-hander on a two-year deal.
Martinez has built a case through his recent performance, and his profile makes him an interesting match for a club that needs reliability as much as upside. He is hardly the only arm the Giants could chase in free agency, but the idea of landing a pitcher with some momentum behind him gives the front office a practical place to start as it sorts through rotation options. [Read more 🡒]