Buster Posey is the name that jumps off this year’s Hall of Fame ballot, and for good reason. The former Giants catcher, the backbone of three championship clubs in San Francisco, is one of 14 newcomers the Baseball Writers’ Association of America will weigh for induction in July, with results set to be announced Jan. 19.
Posey is joined by other first-time candidates Jon Lester and Brett Gardner, both of whom built their cases on October success as much as anything else. Lester helped the Red Sox and Cubs win World Series titles, while Gardner was a steady force across 10 Yankees teams that reached the postseason. To get in, a player needs 75 percent of the vote.
This ballot is heavy on rings and postseason moments, but lighter on the kind of gaudy career totals that usually smooth the path to Cooperstown. That’s what makes Posey such a fascinating test case. If voters reward his peak, it could open the door for others whose cases lean more on greatness at the top than on long accumulation.
Posey’s résumé with the Giants is impossible to miss. He finished his career with a .302 batting average and won the National League MVP in 2012, the same year San Francisco captured its second title in a five-season run that stretched from 2010 to 2014. The Giants beat the Rangers in 2010, the Tigers in 2012 and the Royals in 2014, powered by a pitching staff led by Tim Lincecum, Madison Bumgarner and Matt Cain, along with a “core four” bullpen.
His fingerprints were all over those runs. Posey started 56 postseason games behind the plate, and 23.2 percent of them ended in shutout victories. His 13 postseason shutouts are the most by a catcher in MLB history, ahead of Yadier Molina’s eight and Yogi Berra’s seven.
Posey retired at 34 after a strong 2021 season, when his .889 OPS helped drive the Giants to a franchise-record 107 wins and their latest NL West title. He is now the club’s president of baseball operations.
The bigger question now is how voters balance that peak against the fact that Posey walked away before piling up the kind of career totals that usually catch the writers’ eye. He retired with exactly 1,500 hits, the fewest by a Hall of Fame position player elected by the writers since Ralph Kiner’s 1,451 in 1975. He would also be the first player elected by the writers with fewer than 6,000 plate appearances since Jackie Robinson was honored in 1962.
If Posey gets strong backing, it could also help the cases of several returnees. Chase Utley, Andy Pettitte and Félix Hernández are back on the ballot, and all three have been building momentum.
Utley, a six-time All-Star who was central to the Phillies’ run of five NL East titles, two NL pennants and a World Series championship from 2007 to 2011, has the kind of WAR and OPS+ numbers that usually stand out in Hall discussions. But like Posey, he finished with fewer than 2,000 hits and 300 home runs. His support has climbed from 28.8 percent in 2024 to 39.8 percent last year and 59.1 percent most recently.
Hernández, the 2010 AL Cy Young Award winner, has also surged. He finished with three other top-five Cy Young finishes and more than doubled his support last year, jumping to 46.1 percent from 20.6 percent in his debut. Pettitte, appearing on the ballot for the ninth time, reached 48.5 percent last year after steady gains over the previous two voting cycles.
Omar Vizquel, meanwhile, has gone sharply in the other direction. The all-time leader in games played at shortstop peaked at 52.6 percent in 2020, but after allegations of abusing his spouse and a minor-league batboy, he fell to 18.4 percent last year. This will be his 10th and final appearance on the writers’ ballot.
The BBWAA’s screening committee also added a group of first-year names that includes pitchers Jake Arrieta, Andrew Miller, Wade Davis, Ervin Santana and Joakim Soria; infielders Pablo Sandoval, Asdrúbal Cabrera, Starlin Castro, Kyle Seager and Ryan Zimmerman; and outfielder Jay Bruce.
And if Posey does clear the first-ballot hurdle, July in Cooperstown could carry a distinct Giants flavor. Bruce Bochy, who managed those three title teams, is up for consideration by the Hall’s Contemporary Baseball Era Committee.
So is Brian Sabean, the Yankees’ scouting director when they drafted Derek Jeter and the Giants’ general manager when they selected Posey. Dusty Baker, who won more games in a Giants uniform than any other player, will also be considered by the committee for the first time.
In Other News...
Giants May Have Found A Rotation Fit With One Huge Risk
The Giants are clearly treating the starting rotation as one of the biggest priorities of the offseason, with three spots already spoken for and one more still up for grabs among pitchers already in camp. President of Baseball Operations Buster Posey is expected to add a free agent to round out the group, and Kris Bubic has emerged as a name to watch because he brings both familiarity with the National League West and the kind of left-handed profile that can fit a lot of different plans.
Bubic also comes with the sort of rsum that makes him easy to envision in orange and black, including an All-Star season and enough underlying performance to suggest there could be upside if everything clicks. The catch, of course, is the part teams can never fully ignore with pitchers: health. For a Giants club trying to stabilize the back end of its rotation, he looks like a plausible answer, but one with a risk factor that could shape how aggressively the front office wants to move. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Bring Back A Once-Hyped Arm With Something To Prove
Esmerlin Vinicio is back in the Giants system on a minor league deal, according to the teams transaction log, giving San Francisco another look at a pitcher who once carried plenty of helium in its 2019-20 international free-agent class. Vinicio was regarded as the top prospect in that group, and his path since then has been a familiar one for young arms trying to find their footing: a move from the rotation to the bullpen and a search for a role that can stick.
The right-handers recent work at Eugene suggested there is still something to work with. He turned in a 3.14 ERA with 60 strikeouts in 51.2 innings before earning a late-season promotion, enough to keep him in the conversation as the organization sorts through the rest of that once-promising class. Adrin Sugastey and Aeverson Arteaga have already reached free agency or been re-signed as well, a reminder that the Giants are still trying to see which pieces from that group can still carve out a future. [Read more 🡒]
Giants Finally Moved On From Ryan Walker For A Return Worth Watching
Ryan Walkers rough 2026 season had made him a difficult fit in San Franciscos bullpen picture, and the Giants finally decided to move on by sending the reliever to Milwaukee in a deal that brought back two right-handed pitching prospects. For a club that has spent plenty of time trying to patch together pitching depth, the return is the kind of move that can matter more in the long run than it does on the day it is announced.
Blake Holub and Gavin Perry give the Giants a pair of arms with some upside to follow, with Holub coming off a strong Triple-A season and Perry still early in his pro career after being drafted recently. The trade leaves Milwaukee hoping it can get Walker back on track, while San Francisco gets a look at two pitchers whose development could become part of the next wave of bullpen and rotation depth. [Read more 🡒]
