Bryce Eldridge didn’t just get overlooked in the National League Rookie of the Year race. He got flattened by it.
For a Giants team that had plenty go wrong in 2026, Eldridge was one of the few real bright spots, and yet the rookie vote barely acknowledged him. He received only two fifth-place votes, and the initial results even listed him as a Milwaukee Brewers player. That’s a rough double hit for Eldridge and for the Giants, especially on a night that should have at least offered some recognition for what he did in San Francisco.
Sal Stewart of the Cincinnati Reds won the award, and there’s no denying he put together a strong season. He hit .263/.330/.457 with 32 home runs and 112 runs batted in, and he played in all 162 games.
That durability, paired with the power numbers, clearly carried weight with voters. Even so, Eldridge’s case was stronger than the final vote suggested.
Eldridge finished at .269/.364/.461 with 17 home runs and 57 runs batted in. He appeared in 107 games after not being called up until May, so he simply didn’t have the same runway Stewart had. If he had been in the Giants’ lineup from the start and playing close to every day, there’s a real argument that his power totals would have looked a lot closer to Stewart’s.
There’s also the ballpark factor. Stewart spent half his games in Cincinnati, one of the most hitter-friendly parks in baseball, while Eldridge was working at Oracle, a place that usually doesn’t do left-handed power hitters any favors.
The numbers don’t stop there. Eldridge posted a .825 OPS, better than Stewart’s .787, and he did it at just 22 years old.
The Giants have every reason to believe they may have the better long-term player, even if the award went elsewhere. In 2026, he showed a level of maturity and adjustment that stood out for someone so young.
His season had a clear peak when he hit that walk-off grand slam against the Washington Nationals. He looked unstoppable after that, then hit a rough patch in July before finishing the year strong in August and September.
Now Eldridge heads into 2027 with nearly a full season under his belt and plenty of motivation. The snub should only add more fuel.
He’ll come back with a chip on his shoulder, determined to show he belongs among the best young hitters in the game. The national baseball media may not be there yet, but Eldridge looks ready to make a lot of people rethink that next season.
In Other News...
Giants Offseason Plans Hinge On One Financial Question
The Giants already have a clear shopping list for the offseason, with rotation help, bullpen depth and a better answer against left-handed pitching all sitting near the top of it. The catch is that every one of those needs has to be weighed against the clubs long-term payroll picture, and right now San Francisco is staring at $183 million committed against the luxury tax in 2027.
What makes the planning trickier is that the next Collective Bargaining Agreement cycle could change the luxury tax threshold and the penalties tied to it, which would alter how aggressive the Giants can be in the market. They can identify the free-agent pitchers and bullpen upgrades they want, but how far they can actually go may depend on a financial landscape that is still very much in flux. [Read more 🡒]
Giants May Already Have A First Pitching Fix In Mind
After a disappointing season, the Giants are expected to spend the winter looking for ways to steady a pitching staff that never quite found its footing. One name that has started to surface as a possible fit is Nick Martinez, with Tim Kelly of Bleacher Report predicting San Francisco could target the veteran right-hander on a two-year deal.
Martinez has built a case through his recent performance, and his profile makes him an interesting match for a club that needs reliability as much as upside. He is hardly the only arm the Giants could chase in free agency, but the idea of landing a pitcher with some momentum behind him gives the front office a practical place to start as it sorts through rotation options. [Read more 🡒]
Buster Posey Just Clarified Two Giants Situations Fans Were Watching
The Giants coaching staff is already taking shape for next season, and Buster Posey used his latest update to clear up a couple of the questions that had been hanging over the organization. Taira Uematsu is set to become the new first base coach, while Shane Robinson is being moved into a minor league role. Gary Pettis is returning as third base coach and Ron Washington will stay on as infield coach, giving San Francisco a mix of continuity and change as it sorts out the details around the dugout.
Posey also addressed one of the more closely watched roster matters, confirming that Harrison Bader will remain with the organization. A joint statement is expected soon, which should help settle the uncertainty that followed Baders recent scooter crash incident. For a team trying to steady its offseason messaging, the clarification matters almost as much as the move itself. [Read more 🡒]