Brock Purdy’s fast start in 2026 has dragged an old debate back into the spotlight, and former Oakland Raiders CEO Amy Trask says the response to her past comments has gone too far.
Purdy has powered the San Francisco 49ers to a 5-0 start, throwing 13 touchdowns through five games as his season has taken off. That production has reopened discussion around Trask’s controversial ranking of Purdy during the 2024 playoffs, when she placed him behind the other seven quarterbacks still alive in the postseason. Trask said she recognized his ability but did not think he belonged in that top tier.
Now, she says the backlash has turned ugly. Trask said she has received “venom and threats” over those remarks, and she used social media to draw a hard line between criticism and abuse.
“I made this comment almost 3 years ago, shortly thereafter I acknowledged that I made a mistake (I even offered to buy Brock ice cream),” she wrote in a tweet. “The reason I share this now is to address those who are spewing venom and making threats - it’s okay to make a mistake, and it’s fine to tell someone they made a mistake - it’s not okay to do so with venom and threats - venom and threats directed at me are of no consequence to me, I don’t care - but directing venom and threats at others can have a devastating impact, so don’t.
Purdy’s numbers help explain why the conversation has resurfaced. Through five games, he has completed 69% of his passes for 1,196 yards, 13 touchdowns and two interceptions.
His play has also drawn praise from Tom Brady, who referred to Purdy as a potential MVP contender.
The bigger point from Trask was clear: disagreement is fair game, but threats are not. Purdy’s surge may have revived the old argument, but she said personal abuse should never be part of it.
In Other News...
49ers Need Answers At Key Spots Before Washington Tests Their Depth
With Deebo Samuel out for Week 6, the 49ers are staring at a receiver shuffle that puts added pressure on the rest of the group as they prepare to face Washington. San Francisco has spent the week sorting through options, with younger wideouts Jacob Cowing and Jordan Watkins in line for a bigger look and fullback Kyle Juszczyk working his way back after a knee injury that cost him time in Week 4.
The defensive side brings its own questions, with Dre Greenlaw suspended and rookie linebacker Jaden Dugger positioned for a much larger role than he has had so far. Mykel Williams is also being eased back in after his ACL injury, and the 49ers are still monitoring how Colby holds up against a strong opponent as the depth chart gets tested in a hurry. [Read more 🡒]
49ers Must Clean Up One Costly Issue To Stay Unbeaten Monday Night
A 49ers team still working through injuries and a suspension gets a prime-time chance to keep its unbeaten start rolling Monday night against Washington, and the matchup carries a little extra weight beyond the standings. San Francisco is also on the cusp of another piece of history, entering the game with a chance to add to its long track record under the lights while leaning on the kind of statistical edge that has helped it look like one of the leagues most complete teams so far.
Washington offers a different kind of test, though, because Jayden Daniels can stress defenses in a hurry and the Commanders have been good at taking care of the ball. For San Francisco, the cleaner path is obvious: stay sharp on third down, avoid giveaways, and make the most of what should be favorable moments late in the game. If the 49ers can do that, they should be in position to keep both the win streak and the bigger Monday night chase intact. [Read more 🡒]
49ers 5-0 Start Has Been Driven By One Surprising Change
Five straight wins have the 49ers off to a fast start, and the early formula looks a little different from the one fans have grown used to. The victory over Seattle fit the pattern: San Francisco has leaned less on Christian McCaffrey than in previous seasons, while Brock Purdy, Mike Evans and the passing game have taken on a larger share of the load.
Kyle Shanahan has clearly adjusted the offense to keep McCaffrey from carrying the same burden so early in the year, a shift that has helped preserve his workload for later on. Rookie Kaelon Black has also chipped in during spells when the 49ers have needed another option, giving San Francisco a different kind of balance than the one that often defined its best stretches in the past. [Read more 🡒]