The 49ers’ Brandon Aiyuk problem has reached the point where almost any trade idea feels worth a look, and Bleacher Report’s Brent Sobleski has floated one that puts a quarterback back into San Francisco’s conversation.
Aiyuk’s value, by the source’s description, is sitting at an all-time low. He has not played a snap since October of 2024, and while it is hard to picture a team giving up meaningful value for him, the word “nearly” still leaves the door cracked open.
Sobleski’s list of potential trade packages across the league mostly centered on draft-pick returns for San Francisco. The Colts’ proposal was the one that stood out, because it would send Anthony Richardson to the 49ers.
From Indianapolis’ side, Sobleski framed it as the kind of move that comes with real risk. The Colts are in what he called a make-or-break season for the current regime, and general manager Chris Ballard’s preference for character could make a player with such a public split from his previous team a tough sell.
Still, there’s a football reason the idea has traction. Indianapolis has not properly replaced Michael Pittman Jr. after trading him to the Pittsburgh Steelers, and Alec Pierce, who signed a $114 million contract extension this offseason to become the team’s new WR1, may not be ready for Week 1 after offseason ankle surgery.
For San Francisco, the appeal is more complicated. The 49ers already have Mac Jones as Brock Purdy’s backup, so on paper Richardson looks like a duplicate rather than a need. But Jones is expected to be gone by 2027 at the latest, and the source notes that he will likely chase a starting job in free agency after reviving his career last season.
That’s where the logic gets interesting for the Niners. If Kyle Shanahan took Richardson on as his next reclamation project, it would give the front office even more reason to shop Jones, especially with the possibility that another team could lose a quarterback to injury before Week 1. There should also be a few teams unhappy with their current situation under center.
Even so, the fit is far from clean. Most 49ers fans would probably prefer to keep Jones as the No. 2, and the source suggests Shanahan may feel the same way. If that’s the case, the Indianapolis idea probably dies right there.
But as trade pitches go, this one has enough intrigue to make you wonder what San Francisco would do if the Colts actually called.
In Other News...
49ers Pass Rush Plans Just Took A Stunning Turn With Bryce Huff
Bryce Huffs path took an unexpected turn after his football career intersected with a far different kind of project, one rooted in mechanical engineering and an environmental problem he has been working on with his brother. The effort focuses on a solution for extinguishing battery fires, and Huff has been using the connections he built through football to help move the venture forward with an international manufacturer.
For the 49ers, it is a reminder that roster plans can change in a hurry when a player sees a future beyond the field. Huff has said he has no regrets about stepping away, pointing to the short shelf life of pro football and the need to have a plan once the game is over. [Read more 🡒]
This Overlooked 49ers Back Could Own The Preseason Spotlight
Sincere McCormick has spent the offseason as the kind of player who can disappear in a hurry, the 90th name on the 49ers 90-man roster and the sort of back who has to make every touch count. Even so, he has a real opening to get noticed in August, with San Francisco carrying depth behind Christian McCaffrey and looking likely to keep its star out of the preseason to protect him.
That leaves McCormick in position to get some late-game work, exactly the kind of extended look fringe players need when rosters are still in flux. He also has something on his side beyond opportunity: his previous stint with the Raiders hinted at a runner who can handle real carries, and this month could be his chance to turn a modest camp role into something more meaningful for whoever is watching. [Read more 🡒]