49ers Fans Wont Love What One Scout Thinks About Mike Evans

Despite doubts from scouts, the 49ers are banking on Mike Evans to bounce back under Kyle Shanahan's offensive scheme.

Mike Evans is heading into San Francisco with a point to prove, and one NFL scout didn’t exactly hand him a warm welcome.

The veteran receiver is coming off the shortest season of his career, appearing in just eight games. In that stretch, Evans finished with 30 catches, 368 receiving yards, 12.3 yards per reception and three touchdowns.

Every one of those numbers marked a career low, and some of them dropped well below his usual standard. For the first time in his NFL career, he failed to hit 1,000 receiving yards, 70 receptions or 13.5 yards per catch.

That downturn followed another season in which Evans had already set a career low in yards per reception and receiving yards, even while still putting together a solid year. In 2024, the former Buccaneer also scored 11 receiving touchdowns.

The scout’s read on the situation was blunt: "He's declining, but he's sort of timeless, still big and athletic and gets open. Will be interesting to see how [49ers head coach] Kyle Shanahan utilizes him in different ways."

There’s room to argue the sample size matters here. With nine more games, Evans might have found a better rhythm and produced a stronger finish.

But the numbers still point to a real dip. He was on pace for roughly an 800-yard season, and while he was targeted 61 times, he caught just 30 of those passes in 2025.

Now he gets a fresh start in a new system, and that could matter. Shanahan has a reputation for finding ways to create space for receivers, and Brock Purdy may be a better fit for Evans than Baker Mayfield was at quarterback. That doesn’t make Purdy a major upgrade, but the pairing could suit Evans better.

The 49ers are hoping the move, along with a return to full health, helps spark a rebound in 2026. At the very least, Evans gives them something they’ve needed: steadiness. Brandon Aiyuk hasn’t provided it over the past two years, and Jauan Jennings was still searching for that kind of production when he left.

Evans now gets the chance to show the decline talk was premature.

In Other News...

49ers Fans Can Feel This Blockbuster Defensive Dilemma Building

Maxx Crosbys name is back in the trade conversation, and for a team like the 49ers, that kind of buzz always lands with extra weight. He remains with the Raiders after a previous deal was rescinded, but the idea that he could be on the move before the NFL trade deadline has only added to the intrigue around one of the leagues most disruptive edge defenders.

Crosbys appeal is obvious. Even in an injury-shortened 2025 season, he still produced at an elite level with 10 sacks and 28 tackles for loss, the kind of impact that can reshape a defense. The question for San Francisco is less about fit than cost, because a player with that resume is going to come with a steep price and the 49ers have to decide how much they are willing to give up to chase that kind of upgrade. [Read more 🡒]

49ers Have One Quiet Bargain And One Growing Cap Problem

The 49ers are heading toward 2026 with a rare bit of financial breathing room, sitting on nearly $72 million in available salary cap space and planning to roll some of it over because of the way several contracts are structured. In that kind of setup, the margins matter, and one of the clearest wins on the roster comes from Mike McKivitz, whose play has outpaced his price tag and made him look like a true bargain for a team that has spent plenty elsewhere.

The tougher side of the ledger is Brandon Aiyuk, whose deal has become the kind of cap issue teams try to avoid. If the 49ers decide to move on, they would not be getting much return from the contract itself, which is why his situation stands out as the roster's biggest financial headache even with all that projected space. [Read more 🡒]

49ers May Already Have Their Reason For Passing On Maxx Crosby

The Maxx Crosby chatter has lingered around the 49ers for weeks, but by mid-July there still had been no move, and there may be a simpler explanation than cap gymnastics or trade-package debate. Former defensive coordinator Robert Saleh has been talking up Alfred Collins, saying the young lineman has made real strides and brings the kind of work ethic that can turn a promising interior piece into a problem for offenses, which is the sort of internal development San Francisco has increasingly valued.

That matters because the 49ers appear to be building their front seven with patience, not urgency, and Collins is part of a broader group the team wants to grow into bigger roles. Along with Mykel Williams and C.J. West, he fits a long-view plan that points toward 2026 and away from another blockbuster swing, especially for a team that has learned plenty from past trade decisions and seems content to let its own young defenders answer the biggest questions first. [Read more 🡒]