From the outside, the idea sounds neat enough: Mac Jones goes to Philadelphia, Jimmy Garoppolo comes back to San Francisco, and everybody gets what they need. But for the 49ers, that kind of swap looks a lot less like a solution and a lot more like a problem waiting to happen.
With the NFL trade deadline set for Nov. 10, backup quarterbacks are already starting to drift into rumor season. Jones fits the profile that always gets people talking - an experienced veteran on a cheap deal who could steady a team in need of help. Still, the 49ers have shown no interest in dealing him, even as hypothetical offers start to surface.
Sports Illustrated’s Conor Orr recently outlined a “dream” scenario that would send Jones to the Eagles, whom he sees as a team that might want a quarterback change this season. Orr pointed to the instability of Tanner McKee and the uncertainty surrounding Jalen Hurts in 2027 after his recent blood clot situation. In that same idea, the 49ers would get Garoppolo back to serve as Brock Purdy’s backup.
The logic is easy to follow. Jones knows Kyle Shanahan’s offense, which would make him a relatively simple fit for a new play-caller, or for Mannion, who coached in the Shanahan-adjacent Matt LaFleur system [as quarterbacks coach for the Green Bay Packers]. And if San Francisco were actually going to move Jones, the team would need another quarterback lined up behind Purdy.
That’s where the trade falls apart.
The 49ers have real title aspirations after starting the season on one of the league’s longest winning streaks, and Shanahan already got above replacement-level production from Jones when Purdy was injured last season. In San Francisco’s world, a useful backup isn’t a luxury - it’s survival. Shanahan has had to play multiple quarterbacks in every season since becoming the 49ers’ head coach, which makes Jones far too valuable to send away unless another answer is already in place.
And the numbers help explain why the front office would hesitate. Jones kept the playoff push alive while Purdy was hurt in 2025, going 5-3 in eight starts with 2,151 passing yards, 13 touchdowns, six interceptions and a 69.6% completion rate.
Recent reports have pegged the asking price at a second-round pick, though it remains unclear what San Francisco would accept for an impending free agent. There’s also no cap pressure pushing the 49ers toward a move; Jones carries just a $3.1 million cap hit this season.
Garoppolo, meanwhile, doesn’t look like a clean answer. He was San Francisco’s starter from 2017 through 2022, including the Super Bowl LIV run, but the ending got messy.
The 49ers traded up for Trey Lance as Garoppolo’s replacement, and injuries to Lance and Garoppolo eventually opened the door for Purdy. Shanahan moved on from Garoppolo once for a reason.
There’s little to suggest bringing back an older version of the same quarterback would be an upgrade over Jones.
There’s also the matter of Garoppolo himself. He effectively retired this year after failing to reach a deal with the Arizona Cardinals and deciding not to return to the Los Angeles Rams as a backup. A return to San Francisco in that same role would be a hard sell, especially after the team previously moved away from him.
Then there’s the final wrinkle: the Eagles. Even if the source frames them as not really contending in 2026, the deal would still hand Philadelphia a path to reclaim the NFC East and make a playoff push this year. San Francisco would be helping another NFC contender, and that alone makes the whole idea feel like a deal the 49ers should want no part of.
In Other News...
49ers Trade Could Already Be Bad News For Jordan Watkins
The 49ers move to bring DeForest Buckner back to San Francisco bolstered one side of the ball, but it also has a ripple effect elsewhere on the roster as the trade deadline approaches. For a team already trying to keep its offense balanced, any new addition can change the math, and that is where Jordan Watkins enters the conversation. The rookie receiver has been part of the mix, but his role is hardly locked in with the 49ers still navigating their passing-game plans.
San Francisco has been connected to more help at wide receiver, and that kind of talk always creates pressure on the players fighting for snaps. Watkins has flashed enough to stay in the picture, but if the 49ers do make another move for a pass catcher, the competition for playing time could get even tighter. For now, he remains one of the names to watch as the front office weighs how aggressive it wants to be before the deadline. [Read more 🡒]
49ers Face An Uncomfortable Mac Jones Reality As Deadline Nears
Mac Jones has become one of the quieter names in the trade chatter around the 49ers as the NFL deadline draws closer, and that silence says plenty. Despite the speculation that always follows a backup quarterback with a recognizable track record, no real market has developed for Jones, leaving San Francisco in the familiar position of carrying a passer whose value around the league has not matched the buzz around him.
With the deadline set for Nov. 10, the most realistic outcome now looks like Jones simply staying put and seeing out his contract in San Francisco. The one thing that could change the picture is a major injury to a playoff contenders starting quarterback, which would suddenly turn a backup into a far more urgent target, but until something like that happens, there is not much reason to expect movement. [Read more 🡒]
49ers Face A Second-Half Decision These Fill-In Standouts Earned
The Week 8 bye should bring a familiar wave of reinforcements back to the 49ers, with key names like Nick Bosa, Deebo Samuel and Mike Evans expected to rejoin the lineup. But the break also handed San Francisco a reminder that some of its depth pieces have done more than merely hold the fort. Jordan Watkins has settled in at wide receiver, Kaelon Black has chipped in as a runner with a touchdown, and Gracen Halton has made his presence felt on defense when the 49ers needed answers.
For Kyle Shanahan, the tricky part now is figuring out how much of that production deserves to stick. Watkins has earned a bigger look after handling a heavy workload before the bye, while Black's burst gives the backfield another option worth keeping active. Halton, meanwhile, has turned momentum plays into real pressure, and with the starters coming back, San Francisco has a second-half rotation decision on its hands that could shape more than just the next game plan. [Read more 🡒]