The 49ers have built plenty of winning teams under John Lynch and Kyle Shanahan, but Andrew Whitworth sees one stubborn weak spot in the operation: San Francisco keeps passing on premium draft picks for the offensive line.
That, in Whitworth’s view, says something bigger than roster strategy. It suggests the 49ers don’t fully trust themselves to nail high-end offensive line talent when the stakes are highest.
The former NFL offensive tackle and Super Bowl champion pointed to the team’s draft history up front. San Francisco has not spent a first- or second-round pick on an offensive lineman since Aaron Banks went No. 48 overall in 2021. The only other first-round offensive lineman the 49ers have taken since 2017 was Mike McGlinchey in 2018, and he later left in free agency after seven seasons.
Whitworth said that kind of approach can work only if a team is elite at identifying linemen early. As he put it: “When you’re going to allocate a first-round pick or second-round pick to an offensive lineman, a lot of people love that theory, but you better be damn good at picking it," Whitworth said.
"Because when you hit on an offensive lineman, it can be unbelievable for your franchise early in the draft because a great offensive line, a great D-line is the story to successful football teams. But when you miss on a high pick like that … you draft an unproductive lineman, you are cooked because now you’re getting a second, third, fourth-tier lineman who’s going to have to play."
San Francisco has taken a different route, building around Trent Williams and filling in the rest of the line with later picks and cheaper options. Williams, a seven-time Pro Bowler before the 49ers traded for him in 2020, has been the foundation. Jake Brendel, meanwhile, arrived as an undrafted free agent in 2016 before joining the team in 2021.
Whitworth believes that setup has already exposed how dependent the offense is on Williams. In eight games without him, the 49ers are 1-7. In 40 games with him, they are 31-9.
“They’ve had arguably - what I would consider in my opinion - the greatest of all time in Trent Williams as their left tackle,” Whitworth said. “But when he’s gone, we are going to have to draft a guy.
We are going to have to develop some young guys that become elite guys if we want to continue to have success, because a lot of their offensive success has been built around Trent. If you look at their team when he’s not in there, there’s a huge difference and fall-off in their production offensively.”
The rest of the line has mostly been assembled through the middle and late rounds. Dominick Puni, Connor Colby and Colton McKivitz were selected in the third, fourth and fifth rounds, respectively.
Day 3 picks such as Jaylon Moore, Nick Zakelj, Jarrett Kingston and Justin Skule never became major pieces. This year, fourth-round pick Carver Willis and fifth-rounder Enrique Cruz may end up in roles, but they also could settle in as backups.
For Whitworth, the larger picture is simple: the 49ers have leaned on volume and patchwork more than premium investment. That may be manageable for now, but it leaves a real question hanging over the future once the 38-year-old Williams is no longer there to hold the line.
In Other News...
Deebo Samuel Just Got Linked To A Brutal NFC West Return
Deebo Samuel is already a familiar name around the NFC West, but the next chapter of his career could keep him in the division in a way 49ers fans would not love. After spending time with Washington and then San Francisco, the former Pro Bowl wideout is now being mentioned as a possible fit for a Rams offense that could use another proven target behind Davante Adams and Puka Nacua.
The appeal is easy to see from Los Angeles side, with the current depth chart still leaving room for a veteran receiver who can stabilize the middle of the lineup. Samuels recent production suggests he still has enough left to matter, and the idea of him landing on a short-term deal only adds to the intrigue as the Rams weigh whether to make a move that would hit close to home in the division. [Read more 🡒]
Purdy And Kittle Just Entered Rare 49ers History
Brock Purdy and George Kittle have become one of the most efficient quarterback-tight end combinations the league has seen, and the numbers now back up what has been obvious on Sundays for a while. Per Pro Football Focus, the 49ers duo sits fourth all-time among qualifying pairings in expected points added per play, and over the last four seasons Purdy has leaned on Kittle as a true centerpiece of the passing game.
From 2022 through 2025, Purdy targeted Kittle 269 times and got big-play production in return, with the connection driving both yardage and touchdowns at a level that has helped define San Franciscos offense. Even in 2025, the link stayed among the leagues best at the position, which is why the 49ers can feel good about how central Kittle has been to Purdys rise, even if the next chapter of that partnership still comes with some uncertainty. [Read more 🡒]
Three 49ers Camp Battles Could Shape Shanahans Season
Training camp usually sorts out depth charts, but for the 49ers, a few of the most important decisions are already taking shape before the pads even come on. Left guard is one of the cleaner competitions, with Connor Colby entering as the favorite and Carver Willis and Robert Jones trying to force their way into the picture. It is the kind of battle that can quietly matter a lot in Kyle Shanahans offense, where one spot on the interior can affect everything from protection to run-game timing.
The secondary has its own set of questions, and those could be just as revealing. Renardo Green is facing real pressure at cornerback from Jack Jones and rookie Ephysians Prysock, while at safety Malik Mustapha appears set, leaving JiAyir Brown, Marques Sigle and Ashtyn Davis to sort out the other starting role. With so much competition clustered in a few spots, camp will not just determine who starts, but how much flexibility the 49ers have when the season begins. [Read more 🡒]