One of the biggest questions hanging over the San Francisco 49ers this season is simple: who backs up Christian McCaffrey, and how much can that player actually lighten the load?
Seth Walder of ESPN has a pretty aggressive answer. He predicted rookie Kaelon Black will not only win the job, but do enough to cut into McCaffrey’s production in a real way.
Walder has Black putting up 650 yards, a number that would top Brian Robinson Jr.’s output for the 49ers last season by 250 yards.
That would be a serious jump. Robinson wasn’t especially effective on his carries, but he is still a veteran NFL runner, and he remains a backup on the Atlanta Falcons. His workload also dropped sharply, from 187 carries in 2024 to 92 with the 49ers in 2025.
McCaffrey handled the rest. He logged 311 carries, the most of his career. The problem for San Francisco is that whenever McCaffrey has gone over 270 carries in a season, he has gotten hurt the next year.
That’s exactly why the 49ers can’t keep leaning on him like that. They need another runner who can take more than 92 rushes this season.
Black’s path is not just about beating out McCaffrey’s workload, though. He also has to get past second-year runner Jordan James. James didn’t get a touch in the regular season last year, and as a former fifth-round pick, he doesn’t have much of a resume to lean on.
Even so, neither Black nor James was on the field enough in the preseason to lock down the backup job.
So if Black really does reach 650 yards, it would mean more than just a productive rookie season. It would show he earned the backup role, cut into McCaffrey’s touches, and beat out James in the process.
It could also push the 49ers toward believing Black has a future as a starter once McCaffrey moves on.
The swing factor is the passing game. Black didn’t do much there, while McCaffrey remains a weapon as a receiver and a strong pass protector.
That leaves a possible split where Black handles more of the rushing work, and McCaffrey stays on the field for passing downs.
In Other News...
Brock Purdy Hit Could Bring NFL Fallout After 49ers Opener
Brock Purdys season-opening performance in Melbourne was memorable for more than just the box score, because one of the biggest moments came when the 49ers quarterback took a hit from Rams defensive tackle Tyler Davis that drew a roughing-the-passer flag. Purdy finished the game 25 of 34 for 205 yards with three touchdowns and one interception, but the contact he absorbed is the kind of play that tends to linger after the final whistle once the league reviews it.
The NFLs guidelines leave room for fines on penalties like that, and there is already speculation that the collision may have crossed into helmet-to-helmet territory, which could bring added discipline. For San Francisco, the immediate concern is the health of its quarterback and the protection he gets going forward, while the larger issue is whether the league decides the hit in Melbourne was simply a penalty on the field or something more costly when the office in New York takes a closer look. [Read more 🡒]
Rams Hit On Brock Purdy Could Bring NFL Punishment
Brock Purdy still delivered a productive outing in Melbourne, but one of the biggest moments in the 49ers game came on a hit from Rams defensive tackle Tyler Davis that drew a roughing-the-passer flag and raised the possibility of a helmet-to-helmet call. The play stood out not just because of the contact itself, but because it landed on a San Francisco quarterback who kept the offense moving anyway, finishing 25 of 34 for 205 yards with three touchdowns and one interception.
For the NFL, the question now is whether the play turns into more than a penalty on the field. League discipline can follow this kind of hit if officials and review determine it crossed the line, though it remains to be seen whether fines will actually come down. For the 49ers, the larger concern is the same one every team has in moments like this: protecting Purdy while keeping him upright enough to do what he did in Melbourne. [Read more 🡒]
Nick Bosa's 49ers Return Took A Strange Turn After The Rams Win
Nick Bosas return in the 49ers season opener against the Rams was one of the biggest on-field positives of the night. Coming back from a torn ACL, he made his presence felt with four tackles, two tackles for loss and a quarterback hit, a reminder of how much San Francisco missed him when he was out. For a player whose impact is usually measured in pressure and disruption, simply getting through that first game healthy mattered as much as the stat line.
The strange part came afterward, when a social media post began circulating with a quote falsely attributed to Bosa about honoring Charlie Kirk, a statement he never made. It was the latest example of how quickly fake quotes can spread around NFL players, following similar fabrications that have previously targeted George Kittle and C.J. Stroud. For the 49ers, it turned a straightforward comeback story into an unnecessary off-field distraction. [Read more 🡒]