Christian McCaffrey isn’t going to carry the 49ers forever, and the team has already started building the next layer behind him. In April, San Francisco used a third-round pick on rookie Kaelon Black, a move that one 49ers insider saw as a bad sign for Jordan James, the back the team drafted in 2025.
Grant Cohn laid out his read of the situation in a Tuesday post on X via 32BeatWriters, and he didn’t exactly paint a rosy picture for James.
“If the 49ers truly were optimistic about Jordan James, they wouldn’t have taken Kaelon Black in Round 3," he posted. "Black is two years older than James and will have every opportunity to be McCaffrey's main backup.
"That being said, the 49ers rarely take McCaffrey off the field, so neither Black nor James will play much while McCaffrey is healthy. If McCaffrey goes down, Black and James probably will split carries.”
James’ case gets harder when you look at his 2025 season. He didn’t record a carry or a rushing yard that year, which leaves plenty of questions about where he fits long term. Right now, his path appears limited to competing for a shared role with Black, though any touch could still be the kind that changes the conversation fast.
Even with that uncertainty, the 49ers may have plenty to like in the room from a coaching standpoint. Kyle Shanahan has two backs with strong college résumés to work with if McCaffrey is unavailable.
Black won a national championship with Indiana in 2025 and posted 1,040 rushing yards while improving his yards per carry for a third straight season, finishing at 5.6. James, meanwhile, put up at least 750 rushing yards in each of his final two college seasons, including 1,267 in 2024. He also scored double-digit touchdowns in both of those seasons, and his 7.1 yards per carry in 2023 led the Pac-12.
So while the pecking order behind McCaffrey may still be taking shape, San Francisco at least has options. If the starter is sidelined, Shanahan has two young backs with real production on their résumés - and a competition that looks far from settled.
In Other News...
Robert Saleh Just Sent 49ers Fans A Strong Alfred Collins Message
Robert Salehs latest comments offered a familiar kind of reassurance for 49ers fans: the coach who helped bring Alfred Collins to San Francisco still believes the defensive tackle has the tools to become a difference-maker. Saleh, now leading the Titans, was part of the staff that drafted Collins during his second stint as the 49ers defensive coordinator, and his confidence in Collins work ethic carries extra weight after a rookie year that never really got on track.
Collins had to deal with a rocky first season, including a training-camp absence tied to a contract standoff, but the expectation now is that hell be in camp from the start and get a cleaner runway. San Francisco also added Osa Odighizuwa this offseason, a move that should help the interior rotation and ease some of the burden on Collins as he tries to turn promise into production. [Read more 🡒]
49ers Gave This Undrafted Receiver A Real Shot To Make Noise
Wesley Grimes landed in Santa Clara as more than just another undrafted flyer, which is saying something for a 49ers receiver room that always seems to have a few names fighting for one last opening. The former NC State wideout signed a three-year deal that includes $200,000 fully guaranteed, a small but meaningful sign that San Francisco is willing to give him a real look instead of treating him like a camp body.
Grimes brings the kind of athletic profile that can turn a training-camp rep into a conversation: a 4.35-second 40-yard dash and a 35-inch vertical leap. Just as important for a team built around timing, spacing and yards after the catch, his style lines up with what the 49ers want to do, which is why this is the sort of signing that can quietly become more interesting as summer unfolds. [Read more 🡒]