The San Francisco 49ers' 2025 offseason strategy focused more on trimming the roster than on splashy signings. However, they did make significant investments in quarterback Mac Jones and tight end Luke Farrell. While Jones proved to be a valuable backup to Brock Purdy, Farrell's signing hasn't quite panned out as hoped.
The Niners brought in Farrell, previously with the Jacksonville Jaguars, on a three-year, $15.75 million deal, averaging $5.25 million annually. This was a notable investment for a tight end not renowned for his receiving skills.
Farrell had just 36 catches for 318 yards and no touchdowns over the four years before joining San Francisco. The 49ers justified the signing by emphasizing Farrell's blocking abilities, which were supposed to allow All-Pro George Kittle to focus more on playmaking.
Unfortunately, things didn't go according to plan.
Farrell's Role and Performance
Farrell had a chance to step up in Week 1 when Kittle went down with a hamstring injury, landing on injured reserve. However, it was another backup, Jake Tonges, who seized the opportunity and became a notable contributor, not Farrell.
Farrell's blocking didn't provide the expected edge either. According to Pro Football Focus, out of 457 offensive snaps, Farrell was involved in run support for 264 plays and pass protection for just 36. He was a receiving target on 157 snaps, with only 14 targets coming his way.
A particularly rough moment came in a pivotal Week 18 game against the Seattle Seahawks, where Farrell's lack of aggression led to a costly interception by the Seahawks.
Evaluating Farrell's Impact
Pro Football Focus didn't hold back, labeling Farrell as the 49ers' least effective free-agent signing of the year. They noted that despite his reputation as a blocker, Farrell's performance didn't match the expectations set by his contract. He allowed two sacks on 36 pass-blocking snaps and was eventually outperformed by rookie Jake Tonges.
Looking Ahead
With no guaranteed money left on Farrell's contract, the 49ers face a decision on whether to give him another shot. Based on his first-year performance, it seems unlikely he'll have a long-term role with the team. The 49ers will need to assess whether Farrell can still make a positive impact or if it's time to move on.