MLB’s finalist lists for the 2026 major awards mostly lined up with how the season played out, but a few omissions stand out enough to make you stop and look twice.
The league’s finalists were announced for MVP, Cy Young, Rookie of the Year, Manager of the Year, and Reliever of the Year, with voting handled by members of the 30 BBWAA chapters. Most ballots list five players, though MVP ballots can go as deep as 10, and the votes are weighted before being totaled.
For the most part, the process produced clean results. But three players got left out in ways that raise real questions about how voters are weighing performance.
Cam Schlittler is the biggest one. His 2026 season was supposed to be a test case for how much voters value elite pitching, and the answer came back harshly: the presumptive American League Cy Young Award winner wasn’t even named a finalist. The AL finalists were Bobby Witt Jr., Yordan Álvarez, and Junior Caminero.
On the numbers, Schlittler had a strong argument. He finished first among AL players in bWAR at 7.0 and third in fWAR at 6.2, both comfortably ahead of Caminero.
WAR doesn’t tell the whole story, of course, especially because it doesn’t capture the moments when a player delivers in the biggest spots. That’s where Win Probability Added and Situation Wins Saved come into play.
Those win-probability metrics are part of what pushes Álvarez over the top in the award race. But when Schlittler is stacked up against Caminero in those categories, the Yankees starter comes out ahead there, too.
The bigger philosophical wrinkle is right there in the award itself. Pitchers have their own Cy Young trophy, but the honor still goes to the most valuable player in the league.
Hitters have their own equivalent in the Hank Aaron Award. And yet full-time pitchers have been shut out of MVP consideration for a long time.
Clayton Kershaw was the last one to win it, back in 2014. Since then, none have seriously threatened the top of the ballot.
Jacob deGrom’s 2018 season ended with a fifth-place finish, the highest by a full-time pitcher since.
The Rookie of the Year race produced another omission that’s hard to ignore. McLean, who entered the season as one of the favorites, did not make the finalist cut despite a first full MLB season that was plenty good enough to keep him in the conversation.
In 31 starts and 179.2 innings, the right-hander went 9-7 with a 3.16 ERA and a 26.0% strikeout rate. He also posted 3.0 bWAR and 3.5 fWAR, which topped Sal Stewart’s total.
Stewart’s case leaned heavily on the kind of counting stats that jump off the page: 32 home runs, 112 RBIs, and an All-Star selection. McLean may have lost out because voters placed more weight on those raw totals than on overall value.
Even with McLean left off the finalist list, the Mets still have a shot at a draft pick. His teammate Carson Benge was named a finalist, and if Benge wins the award, New York would receive a pick at the end of the first round of the 2027 MLB Draft.
McLean still has a route to helping his club in that way, too. Because he spent the entire season on the active roster, he can still qualify later if he becomes a Cy Young Award finalist in either of the next two seasons. With his raw stuff, that possibility is very much alive.
The third snub came in the Reliever of the Year race, where the finalist pool looked more like a closer-only club than a true cross-section of the best bullpen arms. All six finalists were closers, which left out Adrián Morejón even though he finished third among National League relievers in fWAR.
That’s the Trevor Hoffman Award race in a nutshell. The Padres already have a finalist in Mason Miller, and he’s fully deserving. But Morejón’s absence brings up the broader issue of whether high-leverage arms who don’t get ninth-inning save chances are being judged fairly.
There’s a natural bias toward closers. Teams usually want their best reliever facing the toughest outs, so the role carries a certain built-in prestige. But only one reliever can be the closer, and that can leave elite bullpen arms fighting for attention in the shadows.
Morejón’s case is a good example. His 2.5 fWAR is close to Trevor Megill’s, and Megill got there in 15 fewer innings. Still, Morejón’s workload matters, too: 76 appearances and 86 innings made him a constant presence for San Diego, and that kind of usage can be just as valuable as the save total voters tend to gravitate toward.
In Other News...
Padres Rumors Could Force A Real Jake Cronenworth Conversation
The Padres offense spent much of the 2026 season looking uneven, then found its footing at the right time and carried that momentum into the playoffs. Even so, the front office appears ready to keep reshaping the roster, with reports pointing toward a possible overhaul of the starting rotation and interest in Pittsburgh second baseman Brandon Lowe as an offseason target.
Lowes fit is easy to see on paper, especially for a club that has not gotten the kind of production it wants from Jake Cronenworth at second base. A move in that direction would not just add another bat, it would force a real conversation about where Cronenworth stands in San Diegos plans and how aggressively the Padres want to keep upgrading around their core. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Lose A Familiar Presence As Another Staff Hole Opens
A.J. Ellis is moving on from the Padres baseball operations department, taking a job with the Mets as their major-league strategy coordinator. For San Diego, it means losing a familiar and well-regarded presence behind the scenes, one who had become part of the organizations day-to-day fabric after his playing career.
Ellis is heading to New York to join Andy Greens coaching staff, reconnecting with a longtime friend in a new setting. The Padres now have another internal role to sort through, with his departure leaving a practical gap in the responsibilities he handled around the organization. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Enter An Offseason That Could Reshape Their Biggest Strengths
The Padres are heading into an offseason that could alter the very areas that have helped define them, with starting pitching and bullpen construction near the top of the list. General manager A.J. Preller has already signaled that the club sees both flexibility and opportunity in how it attacks those needs, and there is enough returning relief depth to give San Diego a base to work from. Randy Vasquez, Yuki Matsui, Kyle Hart, Bradgley Rodriguez, Jeremiah Estrada and David Morgan are all expected back, giving the front office some familiar pieces before the real sorting begins.
Still, the picture is far from settled, especially with the status of Adrian Morejon and Jason Adam unresolved and other spots on the roster also in play. First base and the bench are part of the conversation too, and free agent Ty France has made clear he would like another run in San Diego. For a team that has leaned on pitching depth and versatility, this winter looks less like a routine tune-up and more like a chance to redraw the roster in a few important places. [Read more 🡒]