The Padres got strong value from their best players in 2026, but the rest of the roster dragged the overall picture down.
In Bleacher Report’s “2026 Moneyball Rankings,” released Thursday by Joel Reuter, San Diego finished 22nd in MLB with a total roster value of $45.6 million. The formula weighs a player’s WAR against his salary, using $8 million per WAR to calculate value before subtracting the actual pay.
Positive numbers are good. Negative ones are not.
At the top of the Padres’ list were two of their lowest-paid regulars: first baseman Ty France and closer Mason Miller. France was the club’s biggest bargain, putting up 4.5 WAR on a $2 million salary for a net value of $34 million. Miller, who was paid $4 million, delivered 3.1 WAR and finished with a net value of $20.8 million.
Michael King also turned in a strong season with a net value of $17.4 million, while Jackson Merrill checked in at $16.2 million. Fernando Tatis Jr. rounded out the group of top performers after shaking off a rough first two months to finish with 4.3 WAR and a net value of $14.4 million on a $20 million salary.
But there’s a catch. France and King are now free agents, and their futures for 2027 are unsettled.
The deeper numbers are less flattering for the rest of the roster. Xander Bogaerts, San Diego’s highest-paid player at $25 million, and Manny Machado, who made $21 million, combined for 3.7 WAR and a net value of -$16.4 million. Jake Cronenworth, who battled injuries, posted just 0.1 WAR against a $12 million salary, leaving him at -$11.2 million.
There was also little return from the trade deadline additions. Casey Mize and Robbie Ray, both of whom are free agents, combined for -$14.8 million in net value during their short time in San Diego.
Even with those issues, the Padres still finished 90-72 and had a season that included a sweep of the Chicago Cubs in the NL Wild Card Series and a strong showing against the eventual-champion Milwaukee Brewers in the NL Division Series.
For the Moneyball ranking, though, San Diego landed in a tough middle ground, sitting just behind the A’s at 21st and just ahead of the Angels at 23rd.
In Other News...
Padres Rotation Gamble Could Leave A.J. Preller With Another Big Question
The Padres are again staring at the same offseason problem that has followed them for much of A.J. Prellers tenure: how to patch together enough reliable starting pitching without overcommitting to the wrong arm. One possible answer is Foster Griffin, whose recent work after returning from Japan has put him on the radar for a three-year, $39 million deal and made him a name worth tracking as San Diego sorts through rotation options.
Griffins path also invites the kind of caution that comes with any bet on a pitcher whose value has surged in a short window, especially when the comparison to Erick Feddes career arc hangs in the background. Even if Griffin ends up in brown and gold, the Padres would still need more than one addition to feel comfortable about the depth behind him, which leaves Preller with another familiar question to answer before the rotation is truly set. [Read more 🡒]
Padres First Offseason Move Could Matter More Than Fans Think
The Padres have already made a couple of low-profile moves that fit the kind of winter business a front office often likes to do early, adding first baseman/outfielder Nick Pratto and pitcher Angel Hernandez on minor league contracts. Pratto, once regarded as a top prospect, spent time with San Diegos Triple-A club in 2026 and showed improved performance after joining the organization, which at least gives the Padres a more informed look at what he might offer next spring.
Hernandez brings a different kind of intrigue. The 23-year-old is pitching in the Mexican Winter League after being released by the Miami Marlins in 2024, and the Padres are clearly willing to keep tabs on a young arm with some unfinished business. Neither signing changes the roster picture on its own, but moves like these can matter more than they seem when a club is trying to find useful depth and uncover a player who still has something to prove. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Offseason Pressure Is Rising As Rotation Questions Keep Building
The Padres offseason has already been defined by turnover, with 11 position players reaching free agency and leaving plenty of work for the front office before spring training even gets close. Ty Frances strong 2026 season gave San Diego at least one familiar name to think about, even if his contract projection suggests the market may not make a reunion simple. Around the same time, the clubs pitching needs have only become more obvious, and the search for answers is shaping the winter conversation as much as any move on the position-player side.
One name surfacing in that mix is Nick Martinez, as the Padres have been linked to the Tampa Bay Rays right-hander while they try to stabilize the rotation. Michael King remains the arm many fans are hoping to see back in the fold, which only adds to the sense that the staffs shape is still very much unsettled. Even the organizations broader news cycle has had an offseason feel to it, with the San Antonio Missions announcing a new alternate identity for 2027, a reminder that there is plenty changing throughout the system while the big-league club sorts out its most pressing questions. [Read more 🡒]