Joe Musgrove’s road back from Tommy John surgery is no longer just about whether he can pitch in October. It’s about whether the Padres can actually count on him after he does.
That’s the wrinkle in the return plan. Musgrove and the team are weighing shorter starts or even a temporary move to the bullpen after another setback in his recovery.
He went five innings and allowed one run for Triple-A El Paso on Aug. 27, but he needed 12 days between his August rehab outings and had still not thrown his next bullpen session as of Friday. The arm is coming, just not on a clean enough schedule yet.
And that’s the issue. If the Padres ask him to work in shorter bursts, or if they shift him to relief, the question isn’t only how many outs he can get. It’s how fast he can bounce back.
A reduced role sounds sensible on the surface because it should cut down the workload. But if Musgrove still needs several days to recover after a short outing, then the Padres are left with a pitcher who might only be available once in a series.
That kind of limitation can work only if the innings are sharp and the usage is perfectly managed. Otherwise, it creates a roster puzzle that everyone in the dugout - and every opponent - can see.
Musgrove knows what has to happen.
“I just need to be able to show them I can recover and be someone they can count on,” Musgrove said.
There’s no denying what Musgrove has meant to the Padres. He threw the first no-hitter in franchise history and delivered one of the biggest performances in team history in 2022, when he fired seven scoreless innings in the decisive Wild Card game against the Mets. He’s a hometown pitcher who has been central to some of the franchise’s biggest October moments.
That kind of history should buy him every fair shot to finish this comeback. It should not, however, guarantee him a postseason roster spot.
October rosters are trimmed to 26 players for each series, and those spots can change from round to round. Every arm has to fit a purpose.
The Padres also aren’t short on options. They added Robbie Ray and Casey Mize at the trade deadline.
Walker Buehler and Randy Vásquez have been strong in the second half. Nick Pivetta is also nearing a return.
Between those starters and a bullpen built to shorten games, the Padres are not in a position where they need to force Musgrove onto the roster.
At this point, Musgrove would be a luxury, not a necessity. If he can recover well enough to pitch more than once in a series out of the bullpen, the Padres can think hard about bringing him. If he can’t, then the answer is already sitting there.
In Other News...
Padres Playoff Push Runs Through Juan Soto Trade Fallout
Even now, the Juan Soto deal keeps showing up in the Padres day-to-day reality, not just in the memory of last years headlines. The trade reshaped both San Diego and Washington in ways that are still being felt, with players such as Josh Bell and CJ Abrams helping define the Padres side of the story while James Wood and others have become part of the Nationals rise into a more interesting club than they were when the swap first happened.
When the Padres line up against Washington, they are not just facing another opponent in the playoff chase. They are seeing the ripple effects of a franchise-altering move that continues to influence both rosters, both front offices and the way each team has built around the pieces it received. For San Diego, the matchup is a reminder that the Soto trade is still very much part of the present, even as the bigger question of who ultimately got the better end of it remains open. [Read more 🡒]
Diamondbacks Face A Brutal Late Wild Card Test Against San Diego
The Wild Card picture has tightened enough that every series feels like it carries a little extra weight, and the Padres are right in the middle of that squeeze. ESPNs MLB experts, including Jorge Castillo, are leaning toward San Diego to grab the third and final National League Wild Card spot over Arizona, a call driven mostly by what the Padres can still lean on when games get tight: a deeper lineup and a bullpen that can shorten nights in a hurry.
Even with recent offensive struggles and some uncertainty in the starting rotation, San Diego still has the kind of names that can tilt a race, from Fernando Tatis Jr. and Manny Machado to Xander Bogaerts. And if the Padres can hand leads to Mason Miller late, the margin for error gets a lot smaller for everyone else chasing them, which is exactly why this stretch run feels so uncomfortable for the Diamondbacks. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Win Created A Yankees Pitching Decision Worth Watching
The Padres latest win over the Yankees did more than add another result to the standings. It also pushed New York into a roster move that is worth keeping an eye on as the regular season winds down, with the Yankees needing to manage both performance and flexibility on the pitching side.
Elmer Rodriguez was optioned to Triple-A Scranton/Wilkes-Barre to open a spot on the active roster, a routine transaction that keeps the right-hander in the organization and available for a potential return later. He has made six starts this season with a 5.40 ERA and a high walk rate, and the Yankees will be hoping a stretch in the minors helps him sharpen the command issues that have made his big league role harder to hold. [Read more 🡒]