Padres Still Face One Huge Offseason Test Before Options Dry Up

The San Diego Padres are facing a crucial offseason as they tackle four major roster gaps while navigating a competitive player market.

The San Diego Padres still have real work ahead of them this offseason, and the biggest holes on the roster are starting to come into focus.

AJ Cassavell of MLB.com recently sorted out the club’s remaining priorities, and the list starts at the top: the Padres need an ace. That looked simpler at the end of the season, when the assumption was that starter Michael King would return and both sides would move on with their baseball lives.

That’s not how it played out. King opted out and has been testing the market, while San Diego has also surfaced as an outlier in the Tarik Skubal chase.

Even there, the Padres are not considered the favorite. The Skubal situation has gone quiet, and the Mets are expected to announce signing him next week. Cassavell also floated Freddy Peralta as a possible ace, though the New York Mets thought that would the case after trading for him last offseason.

A.J. Preller has already made it clear the Padres are looking for more than one arm. He said the club needs “multiples,” and when reporters pressed him on whether that meant two or three, he joked that they should “keep going.”

Beyond the rotation, San Diego also needs a big bat. Cassavell noted that re-signing first baseman Ty France is at least one possibility.

France had a good year in San Diego and is the best first baseman on the free agent market, but he still may not match what most people picture when they hear “big bat.” For now, the market is crowded and the answer is still unsettled, and it may stay that way until the lockout begins.

The final need on Cassavell’s list is a lefty reliever. The Padres have been active in rumor season and have made some actual moves after last offseason was slowed by the impending sale of the team, but there’s still plenty left for Preller to tackle before the clock runs out.

In Other News...

Padres Trade Search Could Finally Solve Two Roster Problems

The Padres are already looking ahead to 2027, and the front office appears to be circling a familiar pair of needs: another starting arm and help in a corner outfield spot. It is the kind of roster check that can shape everything else, especially for a club trying to line up its next competitive window without leaving obvious holes behind.

Among the names being discussed are Reid Detmers and Logan Webb on the pitching side, along with outfielder Charlie McCarthy as a possible fit in the grass. There is also the possibility of shifting Jake Cronenworth if it helps create the flexibility needed to make those kinds of moves, which suggests San Diego is willing to be creative if it means solving more than one problem at once. [Read more 🡒]

Padres May Have A Ty France Problem They Cant Ignore

Ty Frances breakout season in San Diego has put the Padres in a tricky spot as the offseason approaches. After hitting .295 with 21 home runs and drawing National League MVP votes, he has gone from useful lineup piece to one of the more interesting free-agent bats on the market, and the price tag is reflecting that jump in value.

According to MLB insiders, France is looking for a three-year deal with an annual average value in the $14.5 million to $20 million range, a figure that puts the Padres in a familiar but uncomfortable position. He has been open to offers and plans to test free agency after his big year, which leaves San Diego weighing how hard to push to keep a player who finally delivered at a star level. [Read more 🡒]

Padres Face A Real Rotation Question With This Depth Option

The Twins decision to non-tender Bailey Ober has put a familiar name back into the pitching market, and it comes at a time when the Padres are still sorting through their rotation picture. Ober logged 24 starts last season with a 4.47 ERA, and while there were encouraging signs in his arsenal, he also carried the kind of questions that tend to matter more when a club is trying to stabilize the back end of a staff.

For San Diego, that makes him the sort of depth option worth monitoring rather than a clean answer. The Padres are still looking for more reliable starters, so a pitcher with some upside but lingering concerns about fastball velocity and overall effectiveness fits more as a possible add-on than a centerpiece. Whether they decide he is worth that kind of look is part of the broader rotation puzzle they still have to solve. [Read more 🡒]