Before the Padres hand another veteran a middle-innings job, they ought to see what Tucker Musgrove can do with a real shot.
That’s the basic case here: keep a bullpen lane open long enough to find out whether the prospect can handle it. The winter always seems to produce a familiar reliever with a track record and a contract, and by April that arm can be sitting in the roster conversation while a younger pitcher is left waiting on the outside. The Padres do not need to shut that door on Musgrove before he’s had a chance to push through it.
Musgrove has already put something on the table. MLB.com’s AJ Cassavell pointed to his 68 strikeouts in 34 1/3 innings during the 2026 season, while also noting that walks remain an issue and that Musgrove could contribute in 2027.
The strikeout total is exactly the kind of headline number that makes a reliever interesting. But the rest of the profile matters just as much, maybe more.
Big strikeout totals can bail a pitcher out of trouble. The problem is when the trouble starts with free passes. If Musgrove is putting runners on in close games, that’s the kind of thing that can make a bullpen inning unravel fast, and major league hitters won’t pass up the chance to sit on a mistake.
What the Padres need to learn is whether he can consistently get ahead, recover after missing, and finish at-bats without wearing himself down because he can’t throw enough strikes. He probably still needs more time in the minors, but that shouldn’t mean a vague path or an empty promise. If he’s going to work toward a role, the assignment should be clear and the opportunity real enough that good pitching actually earns something.
A.J. Preller doesn’t have to lock up every bullpen opening with a veteran name.
Minor league deals and spring training competition can provide coverage without boxing out a prospect before he gets a fair look. Before spending money on another depth reliever, the Padres should ask how much of an upgrade they’re actually buying and whether Musgrove could cover those same innings.
There’s a broader roster point here, too. Clubs need affordable arms who can handle meaningful work, and those players have to be given a path to the majors.
Musgrove has done enough to keep that path open. The Padres should let him make the case on the mound and see where the pitching leads.
In Other News...
Padres Prospects Are Forcing A Tough Preller Trade Question
The Padres have more than a little young depth bubbling up in the upper minors, and it is starting to make their next roster decision feel less straightforward. Tucker Musgrove, Ryan Wideman, Winyer Chourio, Elliot Lascelles and Lan-Hong Su are all drawing attention, giving the organization a few different ways to think about its future rather than leaning on one clear answer.
Musgrove stands out as the one top-ten prospect who could realistically factor into the big league picture next year if he sharpens his control, which only adds to the pressure on how San Diego values its system. A.J. Preller is expected to explore trade options involving prospects at the upcoming GM meetings, so the question is not just which young players the Padres believe in, but which ones they might be willing to use to upgrade the roster now. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Roster Picture Is Changing Faster Than Fans Realize
The Padres roster picture is already shifting around the edges, and Ethan Salas remains one of the biggest reasons why. The youngest catcher ever to appear in a postseason game is expected to see more action in San Diego by 2027, even with plenty of competition at his position. For a club that has spent plenty of time balancing short-term contention with long-term development, Salas continues to stand out as a name fans should keep tracking.
He is not the only minor leaguer who could matter soon. Gutierrez has put himself into the conversation as another potential piece for next season, while Hawkins could end up in a bullpen role if departures open the door. The Padres have been evaluating recent performances closely, and the next wave of internal options may arrive faster than many around the team realize. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Face Tricky Offseason Call On Proven Starter After Contract Twist
Nick Pivettas future with San Diego just got a little more complicated, and the timing could hardly be worse for a Padres front office already weighing a busy offseason. His player option for 2027 converted into a $14 million club option after he spent more than 130 days on the injured list with an elbow injury, turning what had looked like a straightforward contract situation into another decision point for A.J. Preller and the clubs decision-makers.
The part that makes it tricky is that Pivetta was effective when he did take the mound in 2026, giving the Padres enough reason to believe in his value even as his health remains a real question. With payroll and pitching depth both under pressure, San Diego now has to sort through whether to bring him back on that price tag while the rest of its free-agency picture comes into focus. [Read more 🡒]