A.J. Preller’s two-word reply at the GM Meetings said plenty about how the Padres are approaching this winter. When MLB.com’s AJ Cassavell asked about the rotation, Preller’s answer was simple: “Keep going,”
That’s the kind of response that makes four starters sound less like a shopping spree and more like the bare minimum. Because when you start trying to sketch out the Padres’ 2027 rotation, the picture gets thin fast.
Randy Vásquez is there, at least in pencil. Joe Musgrove is there too, though with a giant asterisk attached after he returned from Tommy John surgery in October and may not be ready to jump back into a full-time starter’s workload by Opening Day 2027. Beyond that, the list gets shaky in a hurry.
Michael King, Nick Pivetta, Walker Buehler, Casey Mize and Robbie Ray are all free agents now. Yu Darvish’s future is uncertain. And the Padres have just one pitcher returning who handled a meaningful regular-season workload for them in 2026, plus another arm the club would love to see back in the rotation: JP Sears.
Vásquez at least gave San Diego something real to work with last season. He made 23 starts, appeared in 32 games and logged 140 2/3 innings with a 3.90 ERA.
That’s useful production, especially for a team staring at this many openings. He looks like a back-of-the-rotation option worth believing in.
But that’s also the problem. His workload may be the most dependable thing on the staff.
King and Buehler each made 32 starts for the Padres. King delivered 185 innings and a 3.21 ERA.
Buehler gave them 153 2/3 innings and a 4.63 ERA. Those numbers aren’t the same story, but they do add up to one important point: San Diego got 64 starts out of those two arms, and now both are headed toward free agency.
That’s nearly 40 percent of a season suddenly walking out the door.
So if the Padres are going to build a real Opening Day rotation, they need more than names. They need innings.
The cleanest path starts with a frontline arm, whether that means bringing King back or making a bigger swing for Tarik Skubal. Either way, the Padres need an ace.
After that, they’d need two more starters with recent histories of taking the ball every fifth day. Dustin May and Shota Imanaga are two examples of the kind of profile that would fit.
From there, Vásquez can slot in behind that group, and Musgrove can battle for the fifth spot. If Musgrove needs more time, the Padres would still need another starter capable of handling that role. In that scenario, San Diego could end up adding four new starters and still have all of them in the mix by the first week of the season.
That kind of winter would not be overkill. It might be the only way to cover the innings.
If Vásquez makes 25 starts and three newcomers make 30 apiece, that’s a strong outcome. But it still leaves 47 games for Musgrove, the fourth addition and whoever else is behind them. Even if Musgrove and that fourth starter combine for 30 starts, the Padres would still need 17 more from somewhere.
That’s where Sears comes in. The idea is to keep him stretched out at Triple-A and have him ready as the first call when Craig Stammen needs a starter. There’s value in having someone prepared to step in and give you innings without scrambling.
The next issue is what happens when Sears is already in San Diego. That’s where a veteran on a minor-league deal or a trade for an optionable starter could help give the Padres another arm they can keep ready.
A move for Skubal would change the whole temperature of the winter. He would make the Padres better right away, and his arrival would likely push the front office into an even busier offseason.
If you’re Skubal, you want to know who’s covering the other four days and how far ownership is willing to go to turn this roster into a real October team. A record-setting offer would get his attention.
A win-now roster would give him a reason to listen.
Four starters can sound like a lot in November. In San Diego, it might just be what it takes to build an Opening Day rotation.
Sears gives them a plan for the first time somebody goes down. The bigger question is what happens over 162 games once Sears is already needed.
In Other News...
Padres Just Got A Public Push In Their Tarik Skubal Pursuit
Mason Miller did the recruiting for the Padres in public, and he did it with the kind of enthusiasm front offices usually prefer to keep behind closed doors. The closer praised San Diego, its fans and the clubs new ownership while making it clear he would love to see Tarik Skubal land there, a notable show of support as the Padres try to position themselves for one of the winters biggest prizes.
Skubal, the reigning Cy Young winner, is just getting into free agency and is expected to hear from several major suitors, including the Padres, Dodgers, Mets and Blue Jays. With Scott Boras representing him, the expectation is that the process will turn into a major negotiation before the MLB lockout deadline, which only raises the stakes for every team trying to make its case. [Read more 🡒]
Michael King Could Decide How Bold The Padres Get Next
The Padres are once again staring at a familiar winter question: how far do they want to push to fortify the rotation, and which arm best fits the price they are willing to pay? Michael King sits at the center of that conversation, with his recent injury history and rebound in performance making him an intriguing option for a club that knows pitching depth can disappear quickly over a long season. His market is being weighed alongside a bigger swing at Tarik Skubal, with ESPNs Kiley McDaniel projecting contract lengths and values that help frame just how much flexibility San Diego might need to preserve.
For the Padres, the choice is not just about talent, but about roster construction and how boldly they want to spend across multiple needs. One path points toward a marquee addition at the top of the market, while another suggests building out the staff with King and Trevor Rogers as part of a broader pitching plan. However they sort it out, the decision will tell a lot about how aggressive the Padres intend to be as they try to keep their rotation from becoming a weakness again. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Free Agency Search May Come Down To One Risky Rotation Call
The Padres are still looking for starting pitching, and Shota Imanaga has emerged as one of the more intriguing names on their free-agent board. He has been a model of consistency over the past two seasons, topping 170 innings in each year, and that kind of durability naturally fits a club trying to stabilize the front of its rotation. A.J. Preller has been weighing his options while also keeping tabs on the market overseas, including scouting in Japan.
The appeal is obvious, but so is the cost. Imanaga is expected to push for a significant raise, and San Diego has to decide how far it wants to go for a pitcher whose age and the competition for his services could complicate the bidding. For a Padres team that needs rotation help, the question is not whether Imanaga makes sense in a vacuum, but whether he is worth the kind of commitment that can shape the rest of the winter. [Read more 🡒]
