A.J. Preller gave Padres fans a familiar kind of answer on Friday: plenty of detail, no hard promise.
During an appearance on 97.3 The Fan with Ben Higgins and Steve Woods, Preller was asked a straightforward question - whether Nick Pivetta and Joe Musgrove would pitch for the Padres this season. He walked through where both pitchers stand, laid out the process, and still stopped short of guaranteeing either one makes it back.
That kind of response can drive fans crazy, especially when they’re already tired of vague injury updates. But in this case, the caution fits the reality. There’s progress here, just not certainty.
A few hours after Preller’s interview, both pitchers took a meaningful step at the Padres’ complex in Arizona. Pivetta faced hitters and threw about 20 pitches.
Musgrove also faced hitters and threw 23. It was the first live batting-practice work for either pitcher since their elbow injuries.
That matters. It’s real movement.
It is not, however, the same thing as being ready to return. A live BP session is only one checkpoint.
The next questions are how each arm responds, whether they can handle a rehab assignment, and whether they can build back up to a starter’s workload without a setback.
The two pitchers are not in the same spot, either.
Pivetta is coming back from a flexor strain that has sidelined him since April. Before the injury, he put together a strong season, posting a 2.87 ERA in 31 starts in 2025 and finishing sixth in National League Cy Young voting. The Padres know exactly what he can mean when he’s healthy.
Musgrove’s path is much murkier. He had Tommy John surgery in October 2024, then ran into another setback in spring training.
He hasn’t appeared in a major-league game since the 2024 postseason. On the Padres’ official injury tracker, Pivetta is listed with an expected return in August, while Musgrove is marked for late August or September.
That’s why lumping them together can make the situation sound more encouraging than it really is. Pivetta has a reasonable route back into the rotation in August.
Musgrove is more of a late-season possibility. The Padres can’t treat those timelines as interchangeable, and Preller wasn’t going to pretend otherwise.
The broader backdrop only adds to the tension. San Diego is below .500, four games out of the final NL Wild Card spot, and running out of time before the Aug. 3 trade deadline. The rotation has been a problem, with Padres starters carrying a 4.69 ERA into Friday, the fourth-highest mark in baseball.
That’s why the names Pivetta and Musgrove still matter so much. They’re the kind of arms that can change the feel of a staff in a hurry. But for now, the Padres are still waiting on the next step.
According to the latest update, both pitchers may need another live session before they can begin rehab assignments. Even if everything goes right from here, a return is still expected in the middle or later part of August.
In Other News...
Royals Deadline Plans Suddenly Come Down To One Costly Contract
The deadline chatter around expensive veterans usually starts with the teams trying to add, but San Diego keeps showing up in the conversation because its books are tight and its margin for error is thin. The Padres are sitting roughly $13 million above the $244 million competitive balance tax line, and as a second-time luxury tax offender, they do not have much room to maneuver if they want to keep chasing help without making another costly commitment.
That is why the broader market matters to them, even when the focus is on clubs like Kansas City and other teams weighing salary dumps before the August 3 deadline. If a club is looking to shed payroll, the Padres have to be ready to think creatively about what kind of contract they can absorb, what kind of prospect return might follow, and how far they are willing to push their own financial limits in the process. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Deadline Tension Grows As Ty France Sends Clear Message
With the trade deadline closing in, the Padres are once again in that awkward middle ground where the front office has to think in two directions at once. San Diego has playoff hopes worth protecting, but it also has players who could draw interest if the club decides to reshape the roster, and Ty France has become one of the more interesting names in that conversation after a strong season at the plate.
France has made it clear he would prefer to stay put, and his comments add a personal layer to a deadline that already feels complicated for the Padres. He has been one of the more productive bats in the lineup, which only increases his value around the league, but it also makes the decision harder for a team trying to balance immediate contention with whatever comes next before the deadline passes. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Could Land An Elite Arm Without Touching Their Top Prospects
The Brewers are still looking for pitching help as the trade deadline approaches, and their search has already put them in the middle of plenty of speculation. Milwaukee has been tied to Tigers ace Tarik Skubal, but ESPN's Paul Hembekides floated a different kind of swing in a recent trade concept, one that would let the Brewers chase an elite arm without reaching into the very top of their farm system.
In that scenario, the cost would come from depth rather than the club's blue-chip names, with Milwaukee parting with its No. 6, No. 8 and No. 10 prospects instead of anyone from the top five. The idea is only a proposal for now, but it underscores how aggressive the Brewers could be if they decide to go beyond the usual deadline shopping and target a late-inning difference-maker. [Read more 🡒]