The Padres can spend all winter chasing arms and still wind up with a lineup hole that matters just as much. That’s the trap at first base, where Ty France’s pending free agency could quietly shape the rest of the offseason.
A.J. Preller has plenty of pitching business to handle.
Michael King, Nick Pivetta and Walker Buehler are free agents. Casey Mize and Robbie Ray, both deadline additions, are free agents too.
Ryan Weiss is the first new piece in a rotation that still needs several more. In AJ Cassavell’s MLB.com offseason rundown, starting pitching took up almost the entire checklist.
First base showed up late, but it shouldn’t be treated like an afterthought.
France gave the Padres a lot more than bargain-bin value. He hit .295/.363/.502 with 21 home runs in 133 games, and that production mattered because the lineup had its share of uneven stretches. The names around him had their own issues: Jackson Merrill posted a .743 OPS, Manny Machado hit 30 home runs and finished at .710, and France’s .865 OPS helped keep the offense moving when others were up and down.
That’s what makes the decision so important. Replacing France is not a small task, especially when he was so productive after arriving on a minor league deal. The Padres found those numbers cheaply, but the cost of replacing them is a different story entirely.
Gavin Sheets is part of the conversation, but he looks more like a fit for a narrower role than an everyday answer. He hit 17 home runs in 363 at-bats and slashed .212/.313/.397.
That left-handed pop has value, and the Padres still want him available for specific spots. Against a tough righty, at DH, or as a pinch-hitting option off the bench, there’s a clear path for him to help.
But if he ends up with the first-base job by default, the Padres would be asking him to carry more offense than his 2026 numbers suggest he can provide.
Left field is another need, but if the Padres are deciding where to preserve money for a bat, first base has to come first.
Cassavell reported that France wants to return and that the Padres would love to bring him back. That makes the next step obvious: find out what it costs before the market forces a decision. France is 32, and he has a season that gives his agent plenty of leverage.
That choice also ties back to the pitching search. Preller has to balance what he wants to spend on a starter he trusts against how many innings he can patch together with cheaper arms.
But those calculations get a lot cleaner if first base is already settled. If the price on France climbs past what the Padres believe his next few seasons are worth, they should turn that money toward another everyday first baseman who can get on base and drive the ball.
The goal isn’t to preserve the position. It’s to replace the production.
In Other News...
Fernando Tatis Jr. Has A Rare Awards Twist Padres Fans Should Watch
Fernando Tatis Jr. has turned a season of positional flexibility into an unusual awards subplot, landing as a finalist for the Silver Slugger in both right field and at second base. For Padres fans, it is another reminder of how much value he created while moving around the diamond, all while putting together a .289/.358/.470 line with 25 home runs and 38 stolen bases.
The twist is less about whether Tatis belongs in the conversation and more about how the voting landscape shakes out across the National League. He is up against a crowded field in both the outfield and utility-style races, which makes this one of those cases where his versatility could help him in one category and complicate things in another. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Suddenly Face A Big Adrian Morejon Question
Adrin Morejns offseason just became one of the more interesting subplots on the Padres roster. After emerging as San Diegos top left-handed setup reliever in 2026, he declined the clubs qualifying offer and is now headed for free agency, a move that keeps his market open while also giving the Padres a chance to recoup draft compensation if he lands elsewhere.
The bigger question is what kind of contract and role Morejn will find after a year that included a shoulder injury. For San Diego, it leaves a familiar bullpen piece in limbo at exactly the moment the front office has to decide how much risk it wants to take on a pitcher whose value is clear, but whose next deal may be shaped as much by health as by performance. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Could Lose Key Free Agents To A Rival Fans Hate
The Padres are staring at a messy 2027 offseason, and it is not just because of the usual free-agent churn. With an MLB lockout looming in the background, the roster could be in flux at the exact moment several important pieces are set to hit the market, creating a tricky stretch for a team that has spent years trying to keep its core intact.
Among the names in the mix are Adrian Morejon, Nick Pivetta, Michael King and Ty France, a group that gives San Diego plenty to think about both on the field and in the front office. Some of those players have already signaled a desire to stay, but the Padres are not the only ones with a say in how this plays out, and rival interest from clubs like the Dodgers and Mets could make a tense situation even more complicated. [Read more 🡒]
