The Brewers are turning to Dustin May for Game 3 of the 2026 National League Division Series against the Padres, and the choice comes down to more than just recent form.
Milwaukee had Monday off before the series shifts to Tuesday’s Game 3 action, with the Brewers already up after Saturday’s Game 1 win. Jackson Chourio and William Contreras supplied the home runs in that opener, and Logan Henderson handled Game 2 on Sunday afternoon. Henderson worked five innings, giving up one earned run and two runs overall.
Before the series began, Jacob Misiorowski was set for Game 1 and Henderson for Game 2. Game 3 was the spot that needed answers, and on Sunday Brewers manager Pat Murphy gave one.
MLB.com’s Adam McCalvy shared the news on X, writing, "Dustin May will start Game 3 for the Brewers," McCalvy wrote. "Besides his postseason experience and success this year against the Padres, 'We brought him in to do that,' Pat Murphy said.
RHP Nick Pivetta will start Game 3 in San Diego opposite Dustin May."
May wasn’t the obvious pick at first glance. Robert Gasser also looked like a strong candidate entering the series, and over the final stretch of the regular season he actually outperformed May. Gasser finished with a 3.87 ERA in 21 appearances, including 20 starts, and after Aug. 26 he put together a 1.67 ERA across six outings, striking out 31 and walking 12 in 32 1/3 innings.
May’s late-season line was less eye-catching. Since Aug. 26, he posted a 5.40 ERA with a 26-to-8 strikeout-to-walk ratio in 21 2/3 innings over seven appearances. But the Brewers weren’t choosing only on that stretch.
The bigger edge for May came against San Diego. He faced the Padres three times during the season and was excellent each time.
On May 9, he threw six innings and allowed two runs while striking out seven. On June 15, he delivered a complete-game shutout, giving up just one hit and one walk.
On Aug. 12, he went seven innings and allowed one run with six strikeouts.
That added up to a 1.23 ERA in 22 innings against the Padres this year.
Postseason experience also matters, and May has it. He has made nine playoff appearances in his career and carries a 3.86 postseason ERA. Gasser, by comparison, has a 6.75 ERA in two postseason appearances.
Gasser was the hotter arm down the stretch, but May’s track record against the Padres and his playoff background gave him the nod. In this case, that was enough to put him ahead.
In Other News...
Padres Season Now Hinges On One Painful Game 2 Decision
The Padres had the kind of Game 2 that lingers, the sort that turns a single inning into the center of an entire postseason conversation. Mason Miller was asked to get the final six outs, but he could not finish the job, and Milwaukee walked it off on Jackson Chourios two-run single for a 4-3 Brewers win that pushed San Diego to the brink. Millers command wavered badly along the way, and by the end of the night the choice to keep him in drew plenty of scrutiny.
Now San Diego heads home down 2-0 in the NLDS and staring at a simple but punishing equation: win three straight or the season is over. The pressure is no longer just on the lineup to score or the bullpen to hold, but on the decisions that shape each high-leverage inning from here on out. One game changed the tone of the series, and it left the Padres with very little room to survive another misstep. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Explain Late Mason Miller Call After Crushing Game 2 Collapse
The Padres Game 2 loss in Milwaukee left them staring at an 0-2 hole in the National League Division Series, and the way it unraveled only deepened the sting. San Diego had turned to Mason Miller for six outs in a high-leverage spot, trusting the closer to help lock down the game, but the plan fell apart in the ninth when his command slipped and the Brewers kept pressing until Jackson Chourio delivered a walk-off two-run single.
Afterward, manager Craig Stammen and Miller both addressed the late call to extend him beyond the usual closer usage, a decision that now looms over a crushing collapse. For a Padres team that needed one clean finish to even the series, the choice to ride Miller that long became part of the postgame conversation, with the result leaving San Diego to answer not just for the loss, but for how it got there. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Just Got A New NLDS Concern As Series Shifts Home
As the National League Division Series shifts to San Diego for Game 3, the Padres added another experienced arm to the mix by reinstating right-hander Walker Buehler from the paternity list. To make room, Randy Vasquez was taken off the roster, a move that reflects how tightly San Diego is managing its pitching staff as the series changes venues and the leverage starts to climb.
Buehler is expected to matter if the matchup goes beyond Game 3, which gives the Padres a little more flexibility in how they piece together the back half of the series. For a club trying to control every pitching decision in October, getting him back into the active roster only adds to the questions Milwaukee now has to account for as the series moves forward. [Read more 🡒]