The Padres’ farm system has taken a steep tumble, and the latest rankings make the picture pretty clear: there isn’t much depth behind Ethan Salas right now.
Bleacher Report’s Joel Reuter put San Diego last among all 30 MLB systems on Wednesday, a harsh landing for a club that has spent years dealing from its prospect pile to fuel the big-league roster. Salas is still the headliner, and B/R has him ranked No. 13 overall, but he’s also the only true blue-chip name carrying the system at the moment.
That’s where the concern starts. Salas will lose prospect eligibility once he reaches 91 at-bats or spends 19 days on San Diego’s major-league roster during the 2027 season, whichever comes first. After him, the drop-off is dramatic.
The No. 2 and No. 3 Padres prospects in B/R’s system are outfielder Ryan Wideman and right-hander Coleman Borthwick, and both are placed in Tier 4, which means they sit somewhere in the 101-200 range overall. In other words, they’re interesting pieces, but they’re a long way from being impact major leaguers.
Borthwick, the Padres’ first-round pick at No. 21 this year, won’t turn 19 until next April and has not yet thrown a professional pitch. MLB Pipeline doesn’t expect him in San Diego until 2030. Wideman, a third-round pick in 2025 at No. 99 overall, has logged 135 minor-league games, including 109 split between Single-A Lake Elsinore and High-A Fort Wayne in 2026, and MLB Pipeline projects his debut for 2028.
There’s also a small wrinkle in how the two services view the pair: B/R has Borthwick ahead of Wideman, while MLB Pipeline flips them, ranking Borthwick No. 3 and Wideman No. 10 among Padres prospects.
Beyond that, the overlap between the two lists includes catcher Ty Harvey, shortstop Elliott Lascelles and pitchers Kruz Schoolcraft, Lan-Hong Su, Ryan Lynch, Bryan Balzer and Tucker Musgrove. Musgrove stands out as the closest to the majors among that group, and the Padres added him to the 40-man roster on Tuesday. A bullpen role could come at some point in 2027.
The larger story, though, is the one that’s followed A.J. Preller for more than a decade.
Since taking over as general manager on Aug. 5, 2014, he’s built a reputation for moving fast and swinging big. Before the 2015 season even started, he had already pulled off four major trades - the stretch that earned the nickname “Prellerpalooza” - to bring in Matt Kemp, Wil Myers, Justin Upton and Craig Kimbrel.
That aggressive style has never really changed. Preller was later given the president of baseball operations title in 2021, then signed to a new multi-year contract in February 2026.
The results have been strong enough to justify the approach: five playoff appearances in seven seasons since 2020, including a franchise-first three straight from 2024-26. But the World Series title still hasn’t arrived.
The cost of that push has been obvious, too. Over the years, San Diego has parted with a long list of premium minor leaguers, including Trea Turner, C.J. Abrams, James Wood, MacKenzie Gore, Max Fried, Josh Naylor, Emmanuel Clase and Andres Munoz.
The latest example came at the August 2025 trade deadline, when Preller sent Leo De Vries to the Athletics in the deal for All-Star closer Mason Miller. De Vries is now considered one of the five best prospects in baseball.
That’s the backdrop for a farm system that now sits at the bottom of the league. Salas remains a premium talent, but the gap behind him is wide, and the rankings reflect it.
In Other News...
Padres Are Suddenly In The Middle Of A Huge Pitching Chase
The Padres have jumped into one of the winters biggest pitching pursuits, meeting in person with free agent starter Tarik Skubal as they continue to explore a major addition to the rotation. Skubal, a two-time Cy Young Award winner, sits at the center of a crowded market, and San Diego now finds itself competing with some of the sports biggest spenders for a pitcher who could reshape a staff.
The Mets, Blue Jays and Dodgers are also in the chase, which gives the Padres plenty of company and plenty of pressure as the market moves quickly. Skubal is expected to decide before a potential MLB lockout begins on Dec. 1, so this is not the kind of sweepstakes that figures to linger for long. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Pitching Reset Just Put All Eyes On Prellers Next Move
The Padres spent the contract tender deadline trimming and reshaping the pitching side of the roster, non-tendering JP Sears and Garrett Hawkins and sending both into free agency. At the same time, San Diego locked in one-year deals with Jhony Brito and Bryan Hoeing, while also keeping catcher Luis Campusano, catcher Freddy Fermin, and relievers Jeremiah Estrada and Mason Miller under contract.
It leaves AJ Preller with another familiar winter project, and he has already signaled that the staff will be rebuilt through a mix of free agency, trades and player development. For a Padres club that has spent plenty of recent seasons trying to patch together the right pitching mix, the deadline moves were less an ending than a clear reminder that more turnover could be coming. [Read more 🡒]
Padres May Revisit A Risky Rotation Reunion This Winter
The Padres winter shopping list is already taking shape, and starting pitching sits near the top of it. Even after declining Nick Pivettas 2027 club option, San Diego is reportedly still interested in bringing him back, a reminder of how quickly a pitchers standing can change when a rotation needs help and a familiar arm has already shown he can work in this environment.
Pivettas 2026 season was interrupted by injury, but the broader case for a reunion is easy to see from the Padres side. He had delivered strong ERAs in previous seasons with San Diego, and with multiple rotation spots needing attention, the club may end up weighing him against a wider pool of free-agent arms as it tries to stabilize the staff for next year. [Read more 🡒]
