The Padres have a decision on their hands that suddenly looks a lot bigger than it did a few months ago. Nick Pivetta’s contract situation flipped because of his time on the injured list, and now San Diego holds the cards on a $14 million club option for 2027.
That shift matters because Pivetta entered the 2026 season with the ability to opt out at year’s end. Instead, after spending more than 130 days on the IL, the language in his deal moved that option from his side to the Padres’.
A.J. Preller and the front office now get the final call.
For San Diego, the timing could hardly be more significant. The Padres are already staring at a busy offseason with several important players either headed toward free agency or expected to opt out, which puts even more pressure on the front office to manage what comes next.
On the field, Pivetta gave them plenty to like before the elbow injury shut him down for most of the year. Across eight starts, he put up a 2.86 ERA and a 2.21 FIP. He struck out 10.9 batters per nine and walked only 2.1, and those numbers came in a season that included just four early starts before he missed the next five months.
That production continued what has been his strongest run in San Diego since he signed with the Padres before the 2025 campaign. Based on performance alone, the $14 million price tag for 2027 looks reasonable.
The catch is the health risk. If the Padres pick up the option, they’ll need Pivetta to give them meaningful innings, not just good per-start numbers. That’s the gamble, especially with the front office likely needing to spend heavily this offseason just to keep the pitching staff afloat.
And the list of possible departures only makes Pivetta more important. Michael King, Robbie Ray, Casey Mize, and Walker Buehler are all either unrestricted free agents or facing a player option decision. If those arms end up elsewhere, Pivetta becomes even more valuable to what San Diego is trying to piece together.
So the answer here feels pretty clear: the Padres should take the option. In a winter where the pitching market could get expensive fast, locking in a 33-year-old veteran who has already shown he can miss bats and limit damage is the move.
In Other News...
Padres Should Let Tucker Musgrove Decide Their Next Bullpen Move
Tucker Musgroves 2026 season gave the Padres a real reason to pause before rushing to add another veteran arm. In 34 1/3 innings, he piled up 68 strikeouts, which is the kind of swing-and-miss stuff teams covet from the middle innings, even if the command still needs work. For San Diego, the question is not whether the talent is there, but whether the organization should let that talent breathe a little longer before cluttering the bullpen picture.
Musgroves walk issues make the next step less about projections and more about opportunity. Before the Padres chase another experienced reliever, they should see whether he can sharpen his command and force his way into the 2027 mix on merit. A clear chance to compete for a bullpen role would tell the club a lot about where he stands, and it might save them from buying insurance before they know what they already have. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Prospects Are Forcing A Tough Preller Trade Question
The Padres have more than a little young depth bubbling up in the upper minors, and it is starting to make their next roster decision feel less straightforward. Tucker Musgrove, Ryan Wideman, Winyer Chourio, Elliot Lascelles and Lan-Hong Su are all drawing attention, giving the organization a few different ways to think about its future rather than leaning on one clear answer.
Musgrove stands out as the one top-ten prospect who could realistically factor into the big league picture next year if he sharpens his control, which only adds to the pressure on how San Diego values its system. A.J. Preller is expected to explore trade options involving prospects at the upcoming GM meetings, so the question is not just which young players the Padres believe in, but which ones they might be willing to use to upgrade the roster now. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Roster Picture Is Changing Faster Than Fans Realize
The Padres roster picture is already shifting around the edges, and Ethan Salas remains one of the biggest reasons why. The youngest catcher ever to appear in a postseason game is expected to see more action in San Diego by 2027, even with plenty of competition at his position. For a club that has spent plenty of time balancing short-term contention with long-term development, Salas continues to stand out as a name fans should keep tracking.
He is not the only minor leaguer who could matter soon. Gutierrez has put himself into the conversation as another potential piece for next season, while Hawkins could end up in a bullpen role if departures open the door. The Padres have been evaluating recent performances closely, and the next wave of internal options may arrive faster than many around the team realize. [Read more 🡒]