Spring Training is in full swing, and while it’s a time for players to ease back into the rhythm of baseball, some are feeling the heat of competition. For those hovering between the minors and the major league roster, February and March become critical audition periods. Every swing, every sprint, and every throw could tip the scales.
The San Diego Padres find themselves in a classic Spring Training conundrum: four talented position players are battling for a single spot on the Opening Day roster. The decision isn’t just about stats; it’s about what the team needs most. Do they go for speed, defense, or versatility?
Let’s dive into the contenders: Ty France, Bryce Johnson, Mason McCoy, and Will Wagner. Each brings a unique skill set, making the Padres' decision anything but straightforward.
Ty France
Returning to the Padres, Ty France arguably has the most compelling case on paper. After a stint with the Twins and Blue Jays in 2025, France snagged his first Gold Glove Award, proving his prowess as a defensive anchor at first base.
With 10 Outs Above Average (OAA) and 25 doubles last season, his bat might not have been on fire with a .681 OPS, but his glove work alone could earn him a roster spot. Given the Padres' current uncertainty at first base, France’s defensive reliability is a tempting option.
Bryce Johnson
Bryce Johnson might just be the most well-rounded player of the bunch. He made a splash in a limited sample, hitting .342 over 55 MLB games last year.
His speed is a game-changer, making him an ideal candidate for pinch-running duties. When the Padres need someone to burn the base paths and stay in the game, Johnson’s versatility and quickness could be invaluable.
Mason McCoy
While McCoy’s career .181 batting average in 43 MLB games doesn’t jump off the page, his speed and defensive prowess keep him in the mix. Known for his spectacular plays, like the no-handed glove flip that lit up social media, McCoy offers elite defensive skills that could be crucial in late-game situations. His ability to make highlight-reel plays might just give him an edge.
Will Wagner
Will Wagner had a promising debut with the Blue Jays in 2024, batting .305 over 24 games, but he faced challenges in 2025. Despite limited experience, his versatility across the infield is a significant asset. If Wagner can find his groove at the plate this spring, his ability to cover multiple positions could be the ticket to securing that final roster spot.
As the Padres weigh their options, each player’s unique strengths make this decision a fascinating one. Whether it’s France’s glove, Johnson’s speed, McCoy’s defensive wizardry, or Wagner’s versatility, the Padres have a wealth of talent to choose from. With Opening Day on the horizon, these final weeks of Spring Training will be crucial in determining who gets the nod.