Padres Could Lose Key Free Agents To A Rival Fans Hate

With key players like Adrian Morejon and Ty France potentially on the move, the Padres face pivotal decisions on their foundational roster amid looming free agency challenges.

The San Diego Padres could be staring at a very different roster by 2027, and the free-agent market is where that shakeup may hit hardest. With one of baseball’s deepest pools of impending free agents and an offseason clouded by an expected MLB lockout, the team’s future feels especially unsettled.

That uncertainty is part of why Padres on SI laid out landing spots for five of the club’s most important free agents. Some of the names are obvious keeps. Others look a lot harder to hold onto.

One of the most painful possibilities is Adrian Morejon leaving town. The left-hander has been one of the club’s most effective arms in recent seasons, and even though he has said publicly that he wants to return to San Diego, he is also expected to command a deal close to $100 million.

The prediction here sends him to the Dodgers, a fit that makes plenty of sense on paper. Los Angeles had trouble in the postseason bullpen, has already lost right-hander Evan Phillips, and could also lose left-handed setup man Alex Vesia.

The Dodgers have never shied away from paying big money for relief help, and this would be another example of them trying to patch a weakness while taking a swing at a division rival.

Nick Pivetta is another name the Padres may have a tough time keeping, though this one feels a little more workable. He was excellent in 2025, his first year in San Diego and maybe the best season of his MLB career.

Then 2026 changed the picture fast. A flexor tendon injury sent him to the injured list for nearly five months and turned what had been a player option into a club option, which the Padres declined.

Still, the expectation is that San Diego can work out a new deal that includes some injury protection and remains team-friendly. That would line up with the kind of rotation move president of baseball operations AJ Preller tends to make.

Mason Miller is in a similar spot to Morejon in one important way: both are coming off career years and both are going to be expensive. Miller also made it clear he loves San Diego, but the price tag may be the issue.

He posted a 3.21 ERA and a career-high 4.3 bWAR, then turned down the final two years and $58 million of his contract this offseason because his next deal could stretch longer and top $100 million. If he comes back, he’d again be the ace of the rotation.

But the Padres could also choose to spend elsewhere, especially with other starters like Tarik Skubal still linked to them.

There’s also the bullpen side of the equation, where Jeremiah Estrada looked like a steady veteran arm when healthy. The 34-year-old right-hander got a late start because of quad surgery, then put together a 2.51 ERA through the end of June before a right shoulder strain knocked him out for nearly three months.

He returned for two regular-season appearances and then allowed one earned run in four playoff outings, covering 3.1 innings. He has said he wants to return, and the expectation is that he could be back on a team-friendly deal.

Ty France might be the most surprising name on the list, but his 2026 season made him impossible to ignore. He nearly retired before the year, signed a minor league deal with the organization that drafted him in 2015, and then caught fire at the plate.

In what was arguably his best MLB season, he hit .295 with a career-high 21 home runs. The Brewers have been linked recently, especially after their first baseman left for the Boston Red Sox, but the Mets are also in the mix as a club with a glaring need at first base.

New York had the sixth-worst batting average in MLB last season and no clear everyday answer there. France is expected to land a healthy contract, and the Mets, who led MLB in total payroll last season, could simply outspend everyone else for the bat.

For the Padres, the bigger picture is clear: keeping this group together may be unrealistic, and replacing them all at once would be a major challenge.

In Other News...

Padres Face A New Ty France Question As First Base Plans Shift

Jake Bauers landing a four-year, $58 million deal with the Red Sox has added another layer to the Padres first-base picture, and it could matter for Ty France. San Diego and France have mutual interest in a reunion, but the market is moving around him, and the Padres are weighing whether to bring him back or look elsewhere as they sort out how to fill the spot.

Teruaki Sato is one of the alternatives being considered, and the club could also reshuffle current players if that proves to be the cleaner path. For now, the bigger backdrop is the same one hovering over much of San Diegos winter: how aggressively the new ownership wants to spend, and whether possible MLB salary cap rules end up shaping just how far the Padres can go. [Read more 🡒]

Dodgers Could Hand The Padres A Bullpen Answer Theyll Hate

The Padres are trying to keep Adrian Morejon in the fold, but the left-handers free-agent market is shaping up to be a tricky one for a club already juggling the cost of rebuilding its starting rotation. Morejon has become the kind of bullpen piece teams covet, and that usually comes with a price tag the Padres may have trouble matching if the bidding gets aggressive.

Alex Vesia has emerged as a fallback option, and the irony is hard to miss. The Padres have interest in the Dodgers free agent as a potentially more affordable bullpen answer, even if it would mean turning to a familiar rival for relief help. For a team trying to balance payroll with urgency, the decision could come down to whether it can stretch for Morejon or settle for a move that would sting a little less financially and a lot more emotionally. [Read more 🡒]

Padres Eye Risky Power Bat In A Costly Race They Must Win

Teruaki Sato is moving toward major league free agency at a moment when the market for impact power is as aggressive as it is expensive, and the Padres are among the clubs expected to be in the mix. The Japanese slugger, a Triple Crown winner in Nippon Professional Baseball, has drawn attention from several big-market teams, with the Phillies, Yankees and Mets also listed as potential bidders for a player whose bat would instantly change the conversation in any lineup.

The appeal is obvious enough: scouts love the raw power, and there is a sense that a player with that kind of thump can alter a roster in a hurry. The catch is the cost, which is projected to be in the five-year, nine-figure range once the posting fee is added, and the timing matters too with an expected MLB lockout in December looming over the process. For San Diego, it is the kind of gamble that could pay off in a big way, but only if the front office is willing to live with the swing-and-miss risk that comes with it. [Read more 🡒]