Padres Could Lose A Bullpen Strength They Cant Easily Replace

With key players facing potential exits, the Padres grapple with how to preserve the backbone of their powerhouse bullpen.

The Padres’ bullpen could be headed for a real shakeup this offseason, and the left-handed side is where the tension sits.

Adrián Morejón, Yuki Matsui and Wandy Peralta are all in play in one form or another, while Kyle Hart is the easiest name to sort through. San Diego holds a $2.5 million club option on the 34-year-old swingman, who posted a 5.30 ERA over his two seasons with the Padres and no longer has a minor-league option remaining. Paying the $200,000 buyout on Hart looks like the straightforward move.

The harder calls involve the other three arms, and Morejón stands above the rest. He is headed for free agency, and the Padres can’t treat that as a routine roster decision.

He earned an All-Star nod, worked a career-high 86 innings in relief and finished the regular season with a 2.83 ERA. Even more valuable, he gave San Diego a left-handed leverage option who could finish a game if Mason Miller wasn’t available.

That kind of arm doesn’t come around cheaply.

Free-agent relievers can be risky bets, especially on long deals, but Morejón has already shown the Padres exactly how he fits. San Diego knows his role, knows his stuff and knows how his arsenal plays in this bullpen.

That makes him the one lefty A.J. Preller has to push hardest to keep.

Matsui brings a different kind of dilemma. After an uneven start in San Diego, he settled in and delivered a 1.83 ERA over 64 innings in 2026.

His splitter and slider can wipe out hitters, but the walk rate near 14 percent keeps things from ever feeling fully settled. He has two guaranteed years left and $13.5 million on the table, though he can opt out.

He could find a similar deal elsewhere, but he also has reason to value the security and comfort of staying put.

Peralta is the most familiar of the group, and also the least essential. He logged 77 1/3 innings and posted a 3.61 ERA, giving the Padres steady middle relief in a bullpen that was asked to carry plenty of load.

But the strikeout rate - just 15 percent - tells a less flattering story. San Diego also only temporarily added him to its playoff roster when Miller was placed on the paternity list, and when October pressure arrived, the club went with other options.

Still, Peralta may simply take the money. He has passed on an opt-out in each of the last two offseasons, and $4.45 million is waiting for him in 2027. Staying again feels like the most likely path.

That leaves Preller with a fairly clear pecking order. Hart’s option can be declined.

Matsui’s choice is mostly his to make. Peralta looks like a reasonable middle-relief keep at the right price.

Morejón is the one San Diego cannot afford to shrug off. Letting him walk while hanging onto cheaper left-handed depth would save money, sure, but it would also strip away one of the bullpen’s defining strengths.

In Other News...

Padres Deadline Gamble Became A Frustrating Miss When It Mattered Most

When San Diego went shopping at the deadline, it was looking for help that could stabilize the roster and deepen the pitching mix for the stretch run. The Padres came away with pitcher Casey Mize and infielder Gage Workman from Detroit, parting with prospects Kash Mayfield and Jackson Wolf in a move that was supposed to make sense in the moment and look even better later.

Instead, the deal has been hard to defend as the season has played out. Mize never found much traction after arriving in San Diego, and the expected boost on the mound never really materialized before an ankle injury sent him to the injured list. What was framed as a calculated gamble now reads more like a frustrating miss, especially with the Padres having paid real prospect capital for a return that fell well short of what they needed. [Read more 🡒]

Padres Suddenly Linked To An Outfield Move That Could Test Tatis

The Padres offseason search for offense may already have a familiar name attached to it. MLB insider Robert Murray of FanSided reported that San Diego could pursue a trade for Guardians outfielder Steven Kwan, a two-time All-Star and four-time Gold Glove winner who has long made sense as the kind of contact-heavy, high-floor player the Padres have tended to value when looking at ways to stabilize the lineup and the outfield.

Kwan would not just be another depth add, though. San Diego has shown past interest in him, and if the club seriously pushes in that direction, it could force some real thought about how the batting order is constructed around Fernando Tatis Jr. for next season, which is part of what makes this rumor worth watching as the winter market develops. [Read more 🡒]

Michael King Just Addressed The Padres Question Fans Keep Asking

Michael Kings postseason run naturally stirred up the kind of contract chatter that follows any pitcher who looks like hes raised his value on the biggest stage. For Padres fans, the question has lingered because King is not just another arm in the rotation, he has become one of the most important pieces of the staff and a pitcher the organization would prefer to keep in place.

King addressed the speculation directly and made clear he would like to stay in San Diego, describing the city as a second home. The contract mechanics still leave room for a decision down the road, with money and timing set to become a bigger part of the conversation as the deal moves forward, but for now the more interesting part is the tone King set after the season: he sounded like someone who wants this to keep going. [Read more 🡒]