A no-trade clause can look like a small line in a contract. In the right moment, it can become the whole story.
That’s the kind of leverage Andy McCullough and Dennis Lin of The Athletic dug into, laying out how these clauses shape trade talks and why they matter so much when deadline chaos starts to build. For players, the clause is more than protection. It gives them a say, and sometimes that say changes everything.
The New York Mets have two notable players with no-trade clauses in Francisco Lindor and Bo Bichette, while Juan Soto’s path also included one of those moments where a player’s approval had real weight. The San Diego Padres needed help from a player tied to that landmark trade to make their version of the Soto deal happen.
That player was Eric Hosmer, who had signed an eight-year, $144 million contract with the Padres. Team owner Peter Seidler even offered Hosmer additional money to waive his no-trade clause and accept a move to the Washington Nationals, a destination Hosmer had no interest in.
“Peter, man, you’ve given me enough over the years,” Hosmer replied as he turned down the offer.
Hosmer was eventually traded to the Boston Red Sox, becoming a footnote in the larger deal. But the episode showed exactly how much power sits inside a no-trade clause when a team is trying to close a major move.
“No-trade clauses do not mean no trade consideration,” said super agent Scott Boras. “What they mean is there’s just another step in executing the trade. And that is the consent of the player.”
One player with full no-trade protection put it even more plainly: “Whatever it is, it has to come to you. Having the certainty, having the final say, it’s just huge.”
Those clauses are now part of the conversation for players like Lindor, Bichette and Mike Trout, and they can make front offices think twice before even picking up the phone.
“It’s definitely steered me away from making some phone calls,” one general manager said. “There are guys where I just assume that they put us on for a reason.”
That hesitation is one reason teams have become more guarded about handing them out. The Atlanta Braves, for example, have a blanket policy against including them.
“We feel more pushback than we used to,” said one agent who has worked through these negotiations. “It used to be a lot easier to get a no-trade clause than it is now.”
And from the player side, the appeal is obvious. In a market where buyers outnumber sellers and players often want to stay put, the clause can be one of the most valuable pieces of security in the sport.
“They don’t realize how valuable it is,” one agent said, “until they use it.”
In Other News...
Padres Just Pushed Ethan Salas Into A Much Bigger Moment
Ethan Salas is moving up again, with the Padres promoting the young catcher to Triple-A El Paso after a strong Double-A season. It is another sign that San Diego still sees the 18-year-old as a major part of its future, and it comes at a time when the organization is sorting through its long-term roster picture with the trade deadline closing in.
A.J. Preller has already made clear that Salas belongs in the conversation about what comes next for the Padres, even as the front office weighs every possible avenue to improve the club now. The promotion only adds to the intrigue around a prospect who has climbed quickly, because the next step in his development is arriving just as San Diegos bigger decisions are starting to come into focus. [Read more 🡒]
Padres May Be Eyeing Another Preller Deadline Swing With Yankees
The Padres are once again doing what A.J. Prellers front office tends to do this time of year: casting a wide net and checking on a club with enough talent to make almost any deadline conversation interesting. According to the report, San Diego has had scouts stationed at multiple levels of the Yankees minor league system, a sign the Padres are not just tracking one name but trying to build a fuller picture of what New York might be willing to move.
That kind of coverage leaves plenty of room for different kinds of deals, from prospect-heavy returns to more immediate help or even larger multi-player swaps if the two sides line up. The Padres and Yankees have already shown they can navigate complicated trade talks, and San Diegos history with New York includes the seven-player Juan Soto deal that reshaped both organizations, so this is the sort of deadline link that bears watching closely. [Read more 🡒]