Mason Miller’s 2026 season will be remembered for a lot more than one painful walk off the mound in Milwaukee.
Yes, the image lingers: the Brewers pouring out of the dugout to celebrate, Miller heading the other way, head down, after a brutal Game 2 loss in the NLDS. In his biggest outing of the year, he looked mortal. That was rare territory for a pitcher who spent most of 2026 making hitters look helpless.
Miller took the loss after allowing two runs on one hit and issuing three walks as the Padres fell to the eventual World Series champions. Jackson Chourio delivered the knockout blow, battling through a 104 mph 1-2 fastball, laying off a nasty slider just below the zone, then driving a 101 mph four-seamer to center to bring home the tying and winning runs. Milwaukee’s 4-3 win pushed the Brewers ahead 2-0 in the series, and San Diego eventually dropped the matchup in four games.
Afterward, Miller owned it. “The cardinal rule is you don’t beat yourself. I beat myself today.”
That moment may stick in the public memory, but it doesn’t come close to defining what he did across the season. If the numbers hold, Miller is set to be named the NL Reliever of the Year on Wednesday night, a fitting reward for a year that bordered on absurd for long stretches.
The case for one of the best closer seasons ever is strong. Since 2000, only two relievers have posted more fWAR than Miller’s 3.7 in 2026: Éric Gagné in 2003 at 4.7 and Liam Hendriks in 2019 at 3.8.
Miller’s 47.4% strikeout rate topped every pitcher in baseball by a wide margin, with Jacob Misiorowski next at 37.9%, and it came just shy of Josh Hader’s all-time mark for pitchers with at least 70 innings, set in 2019 at 47.8%. His 1.17 FIP ranks second in history among pitchers with at least 70 innings, trailing only Gagné’s 0.86 in 2003, though that peak is complicated by admitted PED usage.
For the first 53 appearances, Miller was operating on another level entirely. He went 4-1 with a 0.81 ERA and 0.81 WHIP, struck out 101 batters against 20 walks in 55 ⅓ innings, and converted 32 of 33 save chances. Among qualified relievers, he led the way in ERA, fWAR at 3.3, strikeout rate at 48.1%, batting average against at .133, FIP at 0.64 and average fastball velocity at 101.4 mph.
Then the workload started to show.
Miller’s late-season stretch was rougher. He took a loss and blew a save in back-to-back outings on Aug. 25 and 30, and both times he gave up a home run.
Those were the first two homers he had allowed in more than a calendar year. Over his final 13 regular-season appearances, he posted a 4.91 ERA, giving up eight earned runs and three home runs in 14 ⅔ innings.
Before Aug. 24, he had allowed just five earned runs all year.
The postseason followed that same uneven path. He allowed a hit while earning a save against the Cubs in Game 2 of the wild card series, then struggled again in Game 2 of the NLDS while trying to lock down a six-out save.
One possible explanation is simple wear and tear. Including the playoffs, Miller threw 76 ⅓ innings in 2026, topping his previous career high of 65 in 2024.
Even with the late dip, there’s no real mystery about his standing in the sport. Miller still brings a 101-plus mph fastball and a slider that might be the best in baseball, and hitters had almost no answer for either pitch. His slider produced a .086 expected batting average and a 56.3% whiff rate in 2026, while opponents managed only a .192 xBA against the fastball.
Two days after the disappointment in Milwaukee, Miller had something much bigger to celebrate. His wife Jordan gave birth to the couple’s first child, a son named Lincoln.
“Obviously, Game 2 [was] not what I had hoped for or planned on,” Miller said. “Going from that feeling, not really contributing a whole lot to now being a dad and being able to be there for my wife, I think it's moments like that that give you the perspective that's important, that keep you grounded and go out and try to be the best that you can every single day.”
He missed Game 3 of the NLDS, which the Padres won 4-3, then returned for Game 4 and threw a scoreless seventh inning in what became his final appearance of the season.
That’s the thing about closers: the job is brutal, unstable, and lonely. The final three outs are the hardest ones to get, and Miller spent most of 2026 making them look routine.
One bad night in Milwaukee doesn’t erase that. His collapse in Game 2 belongs in the story, but so does everything that came before it.
The dominance is the part worth remembering.
In Other News...
Padres Just Sent A Strong Signal In Their Ace Pursuit
The Padres have already moved from internal planning to early-stage recruiting in their pursuit of Tarik Skubal, discussing the free-agent ace with agent Scott Boras at the General Managers Meetings and setting up an in-person meeting with Skubal next week. For a club trying to shore up multiple rotation openings, that kind of direct contact is a clear sign San Diego intends to stay aggressive in the pitching market.
Skubal brings the kind of rsum that can change the tone of an offseason chase, with two American League Cy Young Awards and a 2026 season that ended with a 2.72 ERA and 186 strikeouts. The Padres are among several teams in the mix, but the fact that they are already lining up face-to-face time suggests they are serious about making a run at one of the premier arms available. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Offseason Suddenly Hinges On One Looming Yu Darvish Decision
The Padres are already working through a busy offseason, with the front office casting a wide net for starting pitching and some help on the position-player side. There is plenty of optimism around the rosters core after Mason Miller was named National League Reliever of the Year and landed on the All-MLB First Team, while Fernando Tatis Jr. also earned All-MLB First Team honors, giving San Diego a high-end foundation to build around.
Still, one of the biggest questions hanging over the winter involves Yu Darvish, whose next step could shape how the Padres approach the rest of their pitching plans. Reports have pointed to family as the key factor in whether he returns in 2027 or steps away, and that uncertainty comes as Adrian Morejon is expected to draw plenty of interest in free agency, leaving San Diego with several moving parts to sort out before the market settles. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Risk Wasting Mason Miller If Rotation Questions Go Unanswered
Mason Millers first season in San Diego was everything the Padres could have hoped for at the back end of games, and then some. After arriving as an elite late-inning weapon, he turned in a 1.67 ERA with 38 saves and 129 strikeouts in 70 innings, enough to earn the inaugural BBWAA National League Reliever of the Year award and set a Padres record for a reliever.
The challenge now is making sure that kind of dominance does not get buried behind bigger issues elsewhere on the roster. San Diego is still sorting through its starting rotation after Michael King opted out and Nick Pivettas option was declined, and the front office is already being linked to top free-agent starters as it looks ahead to 2027. If the Padres cannot stabilize the rotation, Millers value in the ninth inning could end up masking a much larger problem. [Read more 🡒]