The Hall of Fame ballot for the Class of 2027 is out, and one former Padre is back in the conversation.
On Monday, the public got its first look at the ballot that will go to BBWAA voters this week. Among the 14 first-timers and 13 returnees is San Diego native Cole Hamels, who spent the 2023 season rehabbing with the Padres before calling off his comeback. He’s on the ballot for the second time after receiving votes on 23.8% of ballots last year.
Most of the names won’t ring many bells for Padres fans, unless they remember a late-season stopover in 2021. That’s where Jake Arrieta comes in.
Arrieta’s four starts in brown and gold were tied to a rough stretch for the Padres, who finished 79-83 and were scrambling for arms. Yu Darvish landed on the injured list on Aug. 15 with a back injury, and the next day the Padres signed Arrieta. The move filled a need, but the results never came close to matching the reputation.
The former American League Cy Young Award winner went 0-3 with a 10.95 ERA in four starts. San Diego designated him for assignment in September, a move that effectively closed the book on his career at age 35. Five years later, he’s one of the 14 newcomers on the Hall of Fame ballot.
He may also be one of the more interesting cases on a ballot that doesn’t exactly overflow with obvious locks. Former Giants catcher Buster Posey, now the team’s President of Baseball Operations, is the most accomplished of the new names. The rest of the first-time group includes Jon Lester, Andrew Miller, Pablo Sandoval, Brett Gardner and Ryan Zimmerman.
Arrieta’s peak is what gives him any real shot at all. From 2014 through 2017, he made 119 regular season starts for the Cubs and went 64-29 with a 2.67 ERA and 151 ERA+. He struck out more than a batter per inning and posted a 1.03 WHIP.
He also played a central role in Chicago’s 2016 World Series run, winning Games 2 and 6 as the Cubs snapped a 108-year championship drought on the North Side. That stretch included his 2015 Cy Young Award and four seasons that made him look like a certain Hall of Famer.
The question for voters is whether that peak outweighs everything else. Outside those four years, Arrieta went 51-64 over his other eight seasons with the Cubs, Orioles, Phillies and Padres, and his brief stint in San Diego didn’t help his case.
For at least one day, though, the ballot is a reminder of just how dominant Arrieta once was. It’s the reason he’s there - for the first and maybe only time.
In Other News...
Padres Just Got A Public Push In Their Tarik Skubal Pursuit
Mason Miller did the recruiting for the Padres in public, and he did it with the kind of enthusiasm front offices usually prefer to keep behind closed doors. The closer praised San Diego, its fans and the clubs new ownership while making it clear he would love to see Tarik Skubal land there, a notable show of support as the Padres try to position themselves for one of the winters biggest prizes.
Skubal, the reigning Cy Young winner, is just getting into free agency and is expected to hear from several major suitors, including the Padres, Dodgers, Mets and Blue Jays. With Scott Boras representing him, the expectation is that the process will turn into a major negotiation before the MLB lockout deadline, which only raises the stakes for every team trying to make its case. [Read more 🡒]
Michael King Could Decide How Bold The Padres Get Next
The Padres are once again staring at a familiar winter question: how far do they want to push to fortify the rotation, and which arm best fits the price they are willing to pay? Michael King sits at the center of that conversation, with his recent injury history and rebound in performance making him an intriguing option for a club that knows pitching depth can disappear quickly over a long season. His market is being weighed alongside a bigger swing at Tarik Skubal, with ESPNs Kiley McDaniel projecting contract lengths and values that help frame just how much flexibility San Diego might need to preserve.
For the Padres, the choice is not just about talent, but about roster construction and how boldly they want to spend across multiple needs. One path points toward a marquee addition at the top of the market, while another suggests building out the staff with King and Trevor Rogers as part of a broader pitching plan. However they sort it out, the decision will tell a lot about how aggressive the Padres intend to be as they try to keep their rotation from becoming a weakness again. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Free Agency Search May Come Down To One Risky Rotation Call
The Padres are still looking for starting pitching, and Shota Imanaga has emerged as one of the more intriguing names on their free-agent board. He has been a model of consistency over the past two seasons, topping 170 innings in each year, and that kind of durability naturally fits a club trying to stabilize the front of its rotation. A.J. Preller has been weighing his options while also keeping tabs on the market overseas, including scouting in Japan.
The appeal is obvious, but so is the cost. Imanaga is expected to push for a significant raise, and San Diego has to decide how far it wants to go for a pitcher whose age and the competition for his services could complicate the bidding. For a Padres team that needs rotation help, the question is not whether Imanaga makes sense in a vacuum, but whether he is worth the kind of commitment that can shape the rest of the winter. [Read more 🡒]
