Jake Bauers may have finished with the edge in a couple of the cleanest power numbers, but Fernando Tatis Jr. built the stronger overall case for the NL utility Silver Slugger.
The Brewers slugger hit one more home run than Tatis, and he also posted the better OPS. He reached base more often, slugged .484 to Tatis’ .470 and finished with 26 homers in 144 games. That’s a strong argument on its own, and anyone backing Bauers has a pretty straightforward case.
Still, Tatis gave the Padres more over the course of a full season. He played 159 games, hit .289 and piled up 181 hits, including 32 doubles.
He finished with 294 total bases, compared with Bauers’ 231. Tatis also had 54 more hits and 63 more total bases, even though Bauers had the one-homer advantage.
Part of that gap came from volume. Tatis had 149 more at-bats, and those extra chances mattered. The Padres kept writing his name into the lineup, and he kept giving them production in return.
That’s what makes his season stand out even more when you remember how it started. Tatis went through an early stretch without a home run, then hit .299 with a .549 slugging percentage from his first homer on. The drought was ugly while it lasted, but the final numbers still put him right there with Bauers in power and ahead of him in everything that adds up over 162 games.
The ballot also reflects how each player got there. Bauers earned his utility spot by handling first base and the corner outfield. Tatis qualified by playing right field and second base.
Once both names are on the same ballot, the question gets simple: whose season would you rather have had at the plate? On balance, Tatis’ combination of games played, hits and total bases makes the stronger Silver Slugger case.
In Other News...
Padres Just Made An Early Pitching Decision Fans Should Watch
The Padres took an early step to protect a pair of pitching prospects, adding right-handers Ian Koenig and Tucker Musgrove to the 40-man roster before the upcoming Rule 5 draft. Its the kind of November maneuver that rarely grabs headlines outside the front office, but it can say plenty about which arms the organization values most as it tries to balance present depth with future upside.
Koenig earned the nod after spending last season between Double-A and Triple-A, where he posted a 4.19 ERA, while Musgrove remains a more complicated case as he works back from nerve transposition surgery and Tommy John surgery. Even with those two secured, the roster picture is not finished, and Francis Pena and Eric Yost are still among the names who could be squeezed out before the draft arrives. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Just Lost One Rotation Option As Preller's Search Gets Tougher
Dustin May is off the board, and that matters for a Padres club still trying to piece together its rotation for next season. The right-hander reportedly agreed to a three-year deal with the Chicago White Sox, taking one more name out of the mix for a San Diego front office that has been canvassing the market for starting pitching help.
Mays 2026 season was uneven, with a 7-9 record and a 4.70 ERA across 31 starts for the Cardinals and Brewers, but he still represented the kind of arm teams can weigh as they sort through a thin market. For the Padres, the search goes on, with interest still tied to pitchers such as Tarik Skubal, Freddy Peralta, Nick Martinez and Matthew Boyd as A.J. Preller keeps looking for a viable fit. [Read more 🡒]
Mets Face A Costly First Base Decision In Pursuit Of Ty France
Ty Frances career-best run with the Padres has put him in a very different market than the one he entered a few years ago. After a 2026 season that ended with a 26th-place finish in National League MVP voting and new highs in both home runs and bWAR, the first baseman has positioned himself as one of the more intriguing names heading into free agency.
Now the New York Mets and Milwaukee Brewers are among the clubs reportedly eyeing him for 2027 and beyond, which is where the price tag starts to matter. France is expected to draw a lucrative deal, with his average annual value potentially topping $16 million, and that kind of number can force a team to make a difficult call at first base even before the bidding really gets going. [Read more 🡒]
