The Padres’ decision to send Ethan Salas to Triple-A has set off the usual deadline chatter, but the more interesting question might not be whether San Diego is dangling its top catching prospect. It might be whether the club is quietly getting him ready to step into a job that could open up very soon.
Salas didn’t need much time in Double-A San Antonio to force the issue. He hit .286/.361/.417 with seven home runs there, then wasted no time making noise in his first Triple-A game. In that debut, he went 3-for-4 with a double, a triple and two RBI, a quick flash of why the Padres have treated him like a future cornerstone.
That’s why the idea of a showcase feels a little thin. Four games in El Paso won’t suddenly rewrite years of scouting, tracking data and medical information for any team already interested in him. If another club wants Salas in a blockbuster, the evaluation is already well underway.
The bigger clue may be on the Padres’ own roster.
San Diego is carrying Freddy Fermin, Luis Campusano and Rodolfo Durán, a three-catcher setup that looks less like a coincidence and more like a sign of what’s coming. All three hit right-handed.
Salas hits left-handed. And the Padres didn’t build that group until July 20, when they recalled Durán after Miguel Andújar went on the IL.
They could have used that spot on another bench bat. Instead, they chose to keep three catchers around less than two weeks before Monday’s deadline.
That can be read as insurance. It can also be read as a team preparing for movement.
Durán is the depth piece here. The real decision sits with Fermin and Campusano.
Fermin is the easier one for San Diego to part with internally. He’s valued for his defense and for the way he handles a staff, but the bat has been a problem: .168/.260/.227 with a .537 OPS.
Campusano brings much more offense, hitting .286/.393/.505 with a .898 OPS. The catch is that he’s out of minor-league options, which means the Padres can’t simply tuck him away in Triple-A once Salas is ready.
TLDR: Fermin is easier to move internally, but Campusano is easier to sell externally.
That’s where the trade logic starts to get loud. The Padres have a roster jam at catcher, a top prospect climbing fast and a clear need for pitching.
Those are the kinds of ingredients A.J. Preller tends to attack before a deadline.
If there’s a natural fit outside San Diego, the Yankees make the most obvious sense. New York’s catching production was one of the weakest in baseball around the All-Star break, with Yankees catchers hitting .176 with a .521 OPS and 46 wRC+. Brian Cashman is looking for help.
Campusano would give them a right-handed bat to pair with the left-handed Austin Wells. He’s affordable, under control beyond this season and can help at catcher or DH. The defense comes with questions, but the Yankees are shopping for offense.
Fermin would bring steadier defense and more experience working with pitchers, though his bat would not solve the problem that pushed New York into the market in the first place.
There has been no credible report tying Campusano or Fermin to the Yankees, and nothing indicating either player is being shopped. But the roster math is hard to ignore. And it still feels more believable than the idea that rival executives need four Triple-A games to decide whether Ethan Salas can play.
In Other News...
Mason Miller Just Made Padres Deadline Tension Feel Very Real
The Padres are still feeling the pressure of a deadline that arrives with the club hovering just above the break-even point and three games left before the window closes. A loss to the Giants only sharpened the sense that this is a roster in motion, with the front office weighing ways to steady a rotation that has needed help and a bullpen that has been one of the teams clearer strengths.
Mason Miller only added to the intrigue by talking openly about the deadline and the rumors that inevitably follow a pitcher of his stature. His comments came with the kind of perspective that matters in late July, when San Diego is looking at starting pitching upgrades, possible bullpen movement and even outfield help, all while trying to decide how aggressive it wants to be without losing sight of the cost of doing business. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Cannot Afford Another Deadline Mistake With Rotation Help Desperate
The Padres keep circling the starting-pitching market, and Freddy Peralta has emerged as one of the more intriguing names for a club that badly needs help in the rotation. The Mets right-hander has the kind of track record that still gets attention around the league, even after a rough season has made the price tag and the risk harder to sort through.
Peraltas current numbers do not exactly scream certainty, but that has not stopped contenders from weighing the upside against the possibility of paying too much. San Diego is not alone in the chase, with Arizona also in the mix, and the real test for the Padres may be whether they can resist turning a thin market into another deadline overreach. [Read more 🡒]