The Padres thought they were getting the kind of starter who could steady a rotation. Six outings later, the Casey Mize move looks a lot different.
San Diego swung the Aug. 3 trade deadline deal with Detroit, sending No. 2 prospect Kash Mayfield and left-hander Jackson Wolf to the Tigers for Mize and utility man Gage Workman. At the time, the Padres were praised for landing a pitcher in the middle of the best season of his career, carrying a 2.70 ERA across 16 starts.
Since the switch, though, Mize has been hit hard. He’s 1-3 with a 6.67 ERA in six starts for San Diego, and he’s given up at least four runs in four of them.
His first six outings as a Padre have produced 27.0 innings, 20 earned runs, nine walks and 15 strikeouts, along with a 6.94 FIP and 1.52 WHIP. His -0.3 fWAR is the worst on the active staff.
“Just some bad execution,” Mize told reporters after his most recent start, a 7-3 loss against the Cincinnati Reds in which Mize gave up five hits and four earned runs across just four innings. "But better days ahead.”
That’s the frustrating part for San Diego: the Padres don’t have the luxury of waiting forever. Mize is on an expiring contract, and this isn’t about long-term development - it’s about getting results right now. His three losses in a short span have only made the path to a wild-card berth tougher.
Meanwhile, the other side of the deal has started to look better for Detroit.
Wolf, who was a fourth-round pick in the 2021 draft, has settled in at Triple-A with a 1.59 ERA since the trade. That’s a sharp turnaround from the 7.05 ERA he carried in 2026 before the move.
Mayfield, a 21-year-old left-hander, has been sidelined since July 24, but he was in the middle of a solid second season in High-A with a 3.54 ERA. He is ranked as the Tigers’ eighth-best prospect.
Workman, for his part, has barely registered in San Diego, going 1-for-3 over two appearances.
Mize is scheduled to make his next start next Tuesday against the Washington Nationals. The Padres, who are a half-game ahead of the Arizona Diamondbacks for the final National League wild-card spot, would love to see that outing point in a different direction.
In Other News...
Padres Just Watched A Familiar Yankees Problem Resurface
The Yankees had a jolt of concern in the middle of a game against the Padres when center fielder Trent Grisham exited with right hamstring discomfort after a stolen base attempt. Aaron Boone said imaging is expected to help clarify the injury, and for now the club is treating it as something that appears serious without making any immediate call on an injured list move.
For San Diego fans, it was another reminder of a familiar issue following Grisham around this season, since he had already missed time with a similar hamstring strain. Even before any formal diagnosis, the timing matters for New York because a center fielder trying to stay on the field after one leg issue is now dealing with another, and the next step will tell the Yankees how long they might be without him. [Read more 🡒]
Michael King Can Make The Soto Trade Hurt Yankees Again
The Padres got one of the more useful pieces from the Juan Soto deal in Michael King, and now he gets a chance to line up against the Yankees in the series finale. San Diego has used King as a starter after bringing him over from New York, and the move has paid off in a big way as he has become a steady arm in the middle of the rotation.
King's rise makes the old trade look even more layered for both sides, since the Padres were trying to turn Soto's final year of control into long-term value. A strong outing against his former club would only add to the sense that San Diego extracted real pitching help from a deal that was always going to be judged through more than one lens. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Near A Nick Pivetta Decision They Cant Afford To Miss
Nick Pivettas path back to the Padres has already taken a few detours, and the next checkpoint comes in a bullpen session that should help determine whether he is ready to rejoin the active roster. After his minor league rehab assignment was paused following one outing because of elbow discomfort, he returned for two more appearances, keeping his comeback alive while San Diego weighs how to use him if he clears the final hurdle.
The timing matters because the Padres have built more stability into their rotation through recent acquisitions and better work from the group already in place, which gives the club some flexibility but not much room for a misstep. With a narrow lead in the NL wild card race, the question is not just whether Pivetta is healthy enough to help, but whether the Padres can decide quickly and correctly on a starter-or-bullpen role before the pressure of the stretch run tightens even more. [Read more 🡒]