Casey Mize’s first month with the Padres has turned the conversation from deadline prize to October question mark.
San Diego paid up at the trade deadline, sending away its No. 2 overall prospect and other pieces to land the right-hander, a move that made sense at the time because the club badly needed starting pitching. Mize arrived with a 2.70 ERA through his first 16 starts for a Tigers team that was selling, and the Padres were clearly betting on the upside of a pitcher still just three years removed from Tommy John surgery and working on an expiring contract.
But the fit has not gone smoothly. In nine starts for San Diego, Mize has posted a 6.64 ERA, walked 17 batters against 24 strikeouts, given up twice as many home runs as he allowed in Detroit this season and put up a minus-1 bWAR since joining the club.
That leaves the Padres with a bigger postseason decision than they probably expected when they made the deal. San Diego’s offense looks ready to roll into October, but Mize’s role now feels unsettled, and manager Craig Stammen didn’t dodge the issue when asked about it.
“He hasn’t been who he was previously in the season,” Stammen said. “But he’s got a track record of being a very solid major league pitcher for a long time.
… There are ups and downs throughout the season. And right now he’s just in a little down period.
But we’ve got a week left in the season. He’s probably got one more start left.
We value him as a big piece of our pitching staff.”
Mize’s résumé still gives San Diego reason to believe there’s something usable here. He made the All-Star team in 2025 with a 3.15 ERA, though the back half of that season went sideways fast; over his final 12 starts, he put up a 4.96 ERA. The following October, he made two postseason appearances, both three-inning starts, and allowed one run in each outing.
Mize was blunt about where things stand now. He said he knows the results have dipped, but he also made it clear he’s not backing off the work.
“It’s just obvious that I’m not able to consistently put good ones together like I was early for the first two-thirds of the season or whatever,” Mize said. “This is a great team, and they deserve a lot better than what I’ve been giving them.
But I’m giving everything I got, man. I’m laying it all out there every time, every pitch, and unfortunately it just hasn’t been good enough for myself or for this team.
And I’m gonna keep doing that, keep freaking working at it and giving everything I got.
He has one more regular-season start left, with San Diego set to finish against the Arizona Diamondbacks. That outing could go a long way toward determining whether Mize gets a spot on the wild-card roster.
In Other News...
Tatis Just Turned A Padres Bullpen Question Into Front Office Pressure
With the Padres back in the postseason, Fernando Tatis Jr. has already shifted the conversation from celebration to retention, publicly urging president of baseball operations A.J. Preller to bring back free-agent reliever Adrian Morejon. It is the kind of comment that lands differently when it comes from one of the franchises face-of-the-team players, especially with Morejon having become a key part of San Diegos bullpen mix.
Now the question is less about whether Morejon has earned a strong case and more about whether the Padres are willing to act on it under their new ownership. Keeping a reliable arm in place always comes with financial tradeoffs, and Tatis public push adds a little more heat to a decision Preller already has to weigh carefully as San Diego looks ahead beyond this October run. [Read more 🡒]
Craig Stammen Made The Padres Embrace A Risky Plan At Last
In late July, Craig Stammen had plenty of reason to be skeptical about A.J. Prellers unconventional pitching plan. The Padres were trying to navigate a rotation that no longer fit the traditional mold, so the club began leaning on pitchers in specific matchup roles instead of asking them to work as classic starters. It was a risky shift, but one that matched the roster the Padres had in front of them.
Once Stammen embraced it, the approach helped steady the team through a useful stretch and kept San Diego in the race long enough to justify adding more pitching at the trade deadline. The arrangement also underscored how much of the burden on the rotation belonged to both Stammen and Preller, whose shared fingerprints were all over the problems and the fixes that followed. [Read more 🡒]
Padres Clinched A Spot But This Series Still Carries Real Stakes
The Padres may already have punched their ticket to October, but the margin for error is still thin as they open a series with the Diamondbacks, who remain alive in the playoff race. San Diego enters the matchup sitting atop the wild-card picture, and Arizona needs every game it can get, which gives this weekend an October feel even before the postseason begins.
Casey Mize is set to start the opener for San Diego against Brandon Pfaadt, and both clubs are likely to treat the series like a test run for the kind of decisions that get magnified in the playoffs. For the Padres, it is less about securing a berth now and more about lining up the rotation and navigating a game that still matters plenty in the standings. [Read more 🡒]