Casey Mize didn’t exactly ease Padres fans into believing the trade was going to work out.
His first start in San Diego was rough in every direction: nine hits, three walks and eight earned runs over 3 1/3 innings against Arizona. For a rental starter brought in at the deadline, and one who cost two pitching prospects, that kind of debut was enough to set off plenty of frustration.
Since then, though, Mize has done exactly what the Padres needed him to do. He followed that outing with six innings of two-run ball against Milwaukee, then backed it up in Cleveland with his best showing yet in a Padres uniform. Against the Guardians, he went six scoreless innings, gave up just three hits and threw 86 pitches in a 5-0 San Diego win.
That gives him back-to-back quality starts, and more importantly, it gives the Padres a version of Mize that looks much closer to the pitcher they thought they were getting.
He didn’t overpower Cleveland. He struck out only three and had to work through traffic, but he kept the game under control and let the defense handle plenty of the heavy lifting behind him.
For San Diego, that’s enough. The club wasn’t trading for a headline-grabbing ace.
It was getting a 29-year-old former No. 1 overall pick to supply steady innings in a playoff race.
The early concern made sense because Mize’s first impression carried real weight. Before the trade, he had put together a 2.70 ERA with 85 strikeouts and just 19 walks across 16 starts for Detroit, the kind of line that suggested a reliable mid-rotation arm at the right point in his career. Then Arizona lit him up, and the whole thing looked shaky immediately.
That’s why these last two starts matter so much. Mize is still a pending free agent, and the Padres made this move for a postseason push. What he does from here will come down to whether he can keep taking the ball, keep the innings under control and keep the bullpen from having to pick up too much slack.
The Arizona disaster didn’t vanish. It just doesn’t look nearly as loud now. If Mize keeps pitching like this, that debut will end up being remembered as a brutal first night followed by a fast recovery.
In Other News...
Padres Have A New Late-Inning Weapon Drawing Serious All-MLB Buzz
The late innings in San Diego have looked a lot different with Mason Miller in the mix, and the buzz around him now stretches well beyond Petco Park. In a season where All-MLB team projections are already sorting out the best arms in the sport, Miller has pushed his way into the conversation alongside the games top relievers, thanks to the kind of overpowering stuff that can change a game in a hurry.
What makes it even more interesting for the Padres is how that kind of impact plays in a race full of established names and breakout arms, from starters like Dylan Cease to relievers such as Louis Varland. San Diego has been looking for a true late-game edge, and Millers rise gives them one, while also putting him on a short list of pitchers whose seasons are getting serious national attention. [Read more 🡒]
Reds Bullpen Churn Continues As Another New Arm Already Disappears
The bullpen carousel keeps spinning for a pair of former Padres arms, and neither Matt Waldron nor Ron Marinaccio found much stability after leaving San Diego. Waldron was with the Blue Jays only briefly before his latest stop ended, while Marinaccios run with the Reds also moved quickly, underscoring how little margin there is for relievers who are trying to work their way back through injuries and inconsistent results.
For Padres followers, it is another reminder of how quickly the margins can close on pitchers once they move on. Waldron and Marinaccio both entered new organizations looking for a fresh start, but recent performance issues and health concerns have left both searching again, with Marinaccio now choosing free agency after his stint in Cincinnati. [Read more 🡒]
Joe Musgrove Could Change Everything For The Padres Right Now
Joe Musgrove is getting closer to a return, and for the Padres, that alone matters in a season where every rotation turn feels magnified. The right-hander recently got up to 70 pitches in a rehab start, a meaningful checkpoint as San Diego keeps one eye on its playoff position and the other on the health of a staff that could use another proven arm.
The bigger question is what comes next once Musgrove is activated. The Padres know the upside he brings, but they still do not have a clear read on whether he will quickly look like the version who steadied the rotation before, and that uncertainty hangs over a club trying to separate itself in a tight race. If he does, the staff gets deeper in a hurry, and San Diegos postseason case looks a lot stronger. [Read more 🡒]