The Dylan Harper debate hanging over San Antonio this offseason might be the rare argument that ends with everybody getting to claim victory.
FanDuel has Harper as the early favorite for Sixth Man of the Year next season, a pretty eye-catching spot for a player who is still only going to be 21 in his second NBA season. That kind of preseason buzz says plenty about how much talent people see in him. It also says plenty about how quickly the conversation around his role has gotten complicated.
The split is simple enough on the surface: should the 2025 No. 2 overall pick start right away, or should he come off the bench for a stretch? But the more you look at it, the less those sides really clash. If Harper has the kind of sophomore year people are projecting and walks away with the 6MOY award, San Antonio may end up proving both camps right.
There’s a strong case for Harper as a starter. He already looks like a player who can open games next to Victor Wembanyama and Stephon Castle, and he may already be one of the Spurs’ five best players.
His playoff run made that hard to ignore. He was one of the most polished prospects in the class, with a ceiling that some believed matched Cooper Flagg’s, and his size, playmaking, and long-term value to the franchise all point toward a player who should naturally be in the starting group.
Still, the Spurs are not operating in a vacuum. This is a team chasing a championship, and that means roles matter more than labels.
Being good enough to start and actually starting are not always the same thing, especially when there are “beasts all over the court.” Harper doesn’t lose much by coming off the bench if the bigger picture is served.
That’s where the Sixth Man angle gets interesting. To win the award, Johnson will need to keep his young guard on the floor enough to matter.
Manu Ginobili averaged 29 minutes a night in his second season and spent much of his prime in the 27-to-30 range as the team’s sixth man, and Harper could land somewhere similar. The Spurs already leaned on minute distribution last season, when De’Aaron Fox led the team at 31 minutes per game, and that workload should only become more spread out now that the roster is even deeper.
So if Harper plays like the player many expect, the people pushing for him to start will have plenty to point to. And if he also finishes the year with the Sixth Man of the Year trophy, that would be a pretty clear sign that Coach Johnson handled the situation exactly right.
It may not settle the argument for good. But it would validate both sides.
In Other News...
Tim Duncan Vs Steph Curry Should Not Even Be A Debate
The Tim Duncan-Steph Curry comparison always starts with style, because the two stars helped define very different eras of basketball. Duncan was the steady force of the Spurs machine, a two-way anchor whose presence translated into year-after-year contention and a trophy case filled with Finals hardware. Curry, meanwhile, changed the geometry of the game with his shooting and pushed the Warriors into a new offensive age, building a legacy that is just as unmistakable even if it looks nothing like Duncans.
Still, the debate gets sharper when the conversation turns from aesthetics to rsum. Duncans case is rooted in consistency, playoff reliability and the kind of championship equity that comes from being the constant in every run, while Currys case leans on revolutionary impact and the way his titles were shaped by a roster that kept evolving around him. For Spurs fans, the appeal is obvious: Duncans greatness never needed asterisk management, and that is exactly why this argument keeps circling back to him. [Read more 🡒]
Stephon Castle Looks Like A Spurs Cornerstone But One Debate Remains
Stephon Castle spent his first full run with the Spurs looking every bit like a player the franchise can build around. In 68 regular-season games, he was in the starting lineup almost every night, then carried that same role into the postseason while keeping his all-around production steady and his scoring on the rise.
The part that still hangs over his breakout is less about talent than control. Castles turnover total was a real issue, and the Spurs know that if he is going to keep growing as a lead option, his ball-handling has to become cleaner and more reliable. [Read more 🡒]
Bleacher Report Just Validated What Spurs Fans Always Knew About Tim Duncan
Tim Duncan has always been the kind of player Spurs fans appreciated in the way only they could, with the quiet certainty that his value went far beyond the box score. Bleacher Reports latest defensive ranking only adds another layer to that long-held view, placing Duncan near the top of the all-time list and reinforcing the idea that his best work in San Antonio was often felt more than it was celebrated.
What makes the case even stronger is how complete Duncans defensive rsum really was across his 19-year career. He never won Defensive Player of the Year, yet he still set an NBA record with 15 All-Defensive First Team selections, a reminder that his impact on the Spurs identity was as foundational as his offense and maybe even more underrated than his reputation as a top-10 player suggests. [Read more 🡒]