Rutgers walked out of its win over Maryland thinking it had finally turned a corner. A week later, Northwestern slammed that door back shut.
The No. 24 Wildcats controlled the game from the start and rolled to a 42-14 win, jumping out to a 28-3 lead before Rutgers could ever get close enough to make it uncomfortable. The Scarlet Knights never got within two scores, and by the time the afternoon was over, the margin had ballooned to 28.
Quarterback chaos defined the Rutgers offense, but the running backs kept the night from turning into a total wipeout. Dylan Lonergan left early with a concussion after diving headfirst on a scramble on third down, and for the second time in three games his day ended well before the finish. This time, he didn’t even get to attempt a pass.
AJ Surace took over and the results were rough. The offensive line gave him little protection, and Rutgers’ early field goal was quickly buried under a wave of Northwestern big plays.
Down 14-3, Surace was strip-sacked by defensive lineman Michael Killbane for a 17-yard loss, and Jamaal Johnson recovered at the Rutgers six-yard line. Northwestern cashed that in to push the lead to 21-3 before the first quarter ended.
Things didn’t improve from there. Surace was sacked on the next series, then threw an incompletion, and Rutgers punted again. Northwestern added another touchdown to make it 28-3, and Dane Pizarro’s second field goal of the day sent Rutgers into the locker room down 28-6.
Rutgers got one more decent offensive push after a 21-yard screen pass from Antwan Raymond moved the ball into Northwestern territory, but a fourth-and-five turned into a disaster. Surace threw an interception on a play that never had a real shot at a first down. The staff eventually turned to Sean Ashenfelder, but he didn’t steady things either, finishing 2 of 9 for 36 yards with an interception.
Still, the backs gave Rutgers something to hang onto. Raymond and Clay Thevenin both topped 100 yards on the ground, giving the Scarlet Knights their first pair of 100-yard rushers since Kyle Monangai and Gavin Wimsatt did it in 2023.
Raymond finished with 150 yards on 18 carries, while Thevenin added 116 on 14 carries. For stretches, they were the only reason Rutgers had any rhythm at all.
The duo also sparked Rutgers’ best third-quarter chance. Thevenin and Raymond ripped off 41-yard and 31-yard gains to set up first-and-goal at the Northwestern 8.
But the drive collapsed when Ashenfelder missed KJ Duff and Dyzier Carter before taking a nine-yard sack. Northwestern’s pass rush kept squeezing the life out of the game.
The only Rutgers touchdown came on a 46-yard Raymond run after an interception by DK Gilley. Without that, the Scarlet Knights would have finished empty-handed in the end zone.
Defensively, Rutgers was just as outmatched. Aidan Chiles picked apart the Scarlet Knights, finishing 19 of 25 for 219 yards and three passing touchdowns. He did throw his first interception of the season to DK Gilley, but that was a small blemish in a big afternoon.
Northwestern found space all over the field. Griffen Wilde was repeatedly left open and finished with 133 yards on nine catches, plus the game’s first touchdown. Rutgers’ defensive backs spent too much time playing off the line, and Chiles took advantage of the cushion.
The Wildcats also hit Rutgers on the ground. Caleb Komolafe broke loose for a 56-yard run up the middle on Northwestern’s second drive, and he finished with 150 yards and a touchdown on an eye-popping 11.5 yards per carry. Chiles added another blow when he kept it himself and scored from 37 yards out, with Rutgers failing to account for his mobility on the right side.
Rutgers had trouble across the board defensively: not enough pass rush, too many missed tackles, and coverage that left too much grass exposed. Rondo Porter was the one real bright spot, registering a sack on Chiles and finishing with three tackles for loss. Outside of Porter and Gilley, the defense spent most of the day getting sliced up.
Now Rutgers turns to Michigan at home, and that matchup has its own strange look. The Wolverines, under Kyle Whittingham, are not the version Big Ten fans are used to seeing.
They’ve lost three of their last four, including defeats to Iowa and Minnesota, and after benching Bryce Underwood for Tommy Carr, they managed just six points in a 13-6 overtime loss to No. 6 Indiana.
Michigan’s offense has been a mess, with the Wolverines held under 20 points in all but two games. Underwood has struggled badly, and Carr’s first collegiate action has been rocky enough to make the attack look stuck in place. Michigan has leaned on its defense and on scoring whenever it gets limited chances.
That defense has been the real problem for opponents. Indiana was held to six points in regulation and kept out of the end zone entirely. After what Rutgers just went through against Northwestern, scoring against Michigan figures to be a difficult assignment.
Still, there’s a path if Rutgers can find a few explosive plays. If Lonergan can connect on some shots to KJ Duff, or if the running backs can make any headway against Michigan’s front, the Scarlet Knights may at least give themselves a chance.
After another discouraging loss to a ranked team, though, confidence won’t be high. Rutgers gets Michigan next at SHI Stadium on Saturday.
In Other News...
Rutgers Never Recovered From The Start Fans Dreaded
Rutgers spent the afternoon chasing a game it never really got to settle into, and the early damage proved too much to overcome in a 42-14 loss to No. 24 Northwestern. The Scarlet Knights were undone by a rough first quarter and an offense that never found much rhythm, while Northwestern controlled the line of scrimmage and kept building its lead with a balanced attack.
The bigger concern for Rutgers was how little room it had to adjust once things started slipping. The defense had trouble slowing either the run or the pass, and the offense spent most of the day trying to manufacture momentum that never came. Now the Scarlet Knights have to reset quickly with Michigan next on the schedule, and the lesson from this one is hard to ignore: the margin for error disappeared almost immediately. [Read more 🡒]
Rutgers Faces A Brutal Test Against A Top 25 Team On Road
Rutgers heads to Evanston, Illinois, coming off a much-needed win over Maryland, but the challenge waiting on the other side looks significantly steeper. No. 24 Northwestern brings a sturdy running game and an offense that has given the Scarlet Knights plenty to think about, and the staff preview around the matchup paints this as the kind of road test that can quickly expose where a team is still vulnerable.
The biggest concern for Rutgers is familiar: the defense has had trouble against the run and against quarterbacks who can make plays with their legs. That makes this trip feel like a particularly tough stylistic fit, especially with Northwesterns offense built to stress those exact areas and the Wildcats positioned as the likelier winner going in. [Read more 🡒]
Rutgers Fans Should Know The N.J. QB Turning Heads Fast
Highland Park kept rolling Friday with a 35-0 Big Central Conference win over Metuchen, and senior Marcus Smith was at the center of it from start to finish. He helped pace the offense, ran the ball effectively, and even got involved on defense as Highland Park improved to 8-1 overall and 4-1 in conference play.
The night also carried a special moment for the home crowd with Highland Park honoring one of its own, as the school retired the jersey of alum L.J. Smith. For Rutgers fans keeping an eye on New Jersey talent, it was the kind of local showcase that can make a player stand out fast, especially when the stage is packed with the sort of attention that comes with a dominant win. [Read more 🡒]