Rutgers heads to Penn State on Saturday, Nov. 21, at 3:30 with the season winding down and the margin for error long gone. The Scarlet Knights are 2-8 after last week’s 31-0 home loss to Nebraska, while the 6-4 Nittany Lions come in off a 42-14 win over Minnesota.
The staff at OnTheBanks sees this one the same way: Penn State in control, Rutgers trying to survive the afternoon.
For Andrew Rice, the matchup is as lopsided as it looks on paper. He pointed to Penn State’s late-season surge and Rutgers’ injuries, quarterback uncertainty, and shaky defense, calling it a case of “a ‘Nittany’ Lion vs a wounded gazelle.” His pick: Penn State 35, Rutgers 3.
Ryan Castellano focused on the quarterback situation, noting that AJ Surace has reportedly been playing through three broken ribs. Even if Surace is available, Castellano would turn to Rocco Rainone, who saw action late in the Nebraska game.
He argued there’s little reason to keep sending a banged-up quarterback out there at 2-8, especially with Rutgers still searching for its first points since Greg Schiano was given another year last week. His prediction: Penn State 28, Rutgers 3.
Greg Patuto also zeroed in on the offense’s struggles, writing that Rutgers is looking to score its first point since Keli Zinn announced that Greg Schiano would be back. He acknowledged the injuries at quarterback and the absence of one of the nation’s best receivers, but said the bigger issue is that Schiano has done “a brutal job” and hired a staff that is “just not good enough.” Patuto took Penn State 31, Rutgers 6.
Bob Cancro saw no reason to complicate things. He said the Nittany Lions have found their footing under Matt Campbell, while Rutgers is as banged up at critical and other positions as he’s ever seen them.
He added that the Scarlet Knights’ defense started the year questionable and the offense has “simply nosedived” with injuries and problems up front. His pick: Penn State 38, Rutgers 6.
Arnav Sarkar framed the game as a sharp contrast to last year, when a dropped football kept Rutgers from snapping its long losing streak to Penn State in the 2025 season finale. This time, he wrote, the Nittany Lions are rolling after three straight wins, while Rutgers still does not know who will start at quarterback.
Sarkar noted that AJ Surace is questionable and likely the choice if he goes, with Rocco Rainone and Xavier Stearn ready behind him. He also pointed out that Rutgers’ defense will be without its top three safeties for the first half because of Tariq Hayer’s targeting suspension, and with the offensive injuries and a banged-up line, he expects Penn State to feast.
In Other News...
Notre Dames Rutgers Win Looks Better After What Those Rotation Players Did
Rutgers left the Players Era 8 Tournament with a 1-2 record, but the bigger takeaway for the Scarlet Knights may be how the rotation pieces held up in the spotlight. Against a field that included Notre Dame, several of the players who will shape the middle of the roster got meaningful run, and the early returns were encouraging enough to make that win look a little sturdier in hindsight.
Christian Gurdak and Lino Mark both turned in strong showings, giving Rutgers something to build on beyond the usual headline names. Darren Buchanan Jr. and Rasheed Jones had more uneven stretches, which is part of the reason the staff will likely keep sorting through the rotation as the season moves forward, but the tournament at least offered a clearer picture of who helped and who still has work to do. [Read more 🡒]
Houston Showed Rutgers Exactly What Made This Team So Tough
Houstons run through the Players Era 8 Tournament offered a clear reminder of why this team has been such a difficult matchup. The Cougars beat Florida in the semifinals and Kansas in the title game, and they did it with a deep, balanced rotation rather than leaning on one star alone. Dedan Thomas Jr. was named MVP after averaging 22.3 points per game, but the bigger story was how many different players kept showing up when the pressure rose.
Joseph Tugler, Mercy Miller, Chase McCarty, Delrecco Gillespie and Chendall Weaver all made meaningful contributions, giving Houston the kind of spread-out production that can wear opponents down over the course of a tournament. For Rutgers, the lesson is pretty straightforward: this is a team that can beat you in multiple ways, and it has enough pieces to keep coming even when one option is taken away. [Read more 🡒]
Rutgers Finally Ended Its Penn State Misery In Unbelievable Fashion
Rutgers finally got the kind of breakthrough that has haunted the program for nearly four decades, edging Penn State 25-24 in a finish that felt ripped from a highlight reel. The win snapped a 38-year drought against the Nittany Lions and came late in the season, giving Greg Schiano a signature moment not long after he had kept his job.
The Scarlet Knights had to survive a wild closing sequence to get there, with the offense leaning on a backup quarterback and the game turning on a frantic final play. What followed was the kind of ending that can change the way a season is remembered, from a desperate lateral to a touchdown and then a bold call that left Rutgers celebrating one of its most improbable wins in years. [Read more 🡒]
