Rutgers Heads Into Penn State Facing A Brutal Reality

Rutgers faces a daunting challenge against a resurgent Penn State, with experts predicting another difficult outing for the Scarlet Knights.

Rutgers heads to Happy Valley on Saturday carrying a long drought against Penn State and a roster that’s been hit hard by injuries. The Scarlet Knights haven’t beaten the Nittany Lions since 1988, and this matchup comes with Rutgers at 2-8 overall and 1-6 in conference play, while Penn State enters at 6-4 and 3-4 riding a three-game winning streak in Big Ten action.

The Daily Targum’s sports staff leaned heavily toward Penn State in its predictions, with most expecting the Nittany Lions to control the game from the start. Several writers pointed to Rutgers’ uncertainty at quarterback and the team’s lack of depth as major problems against a Penn State group that has found momentum in conference play.

James Mertz, the head sports editor, picked Penn State 34-7. “Between injuries and a lack of depth, Rutgers is a depleted team right now.

The defense will struggle to keep up with a potent rushing attack, but the Scarlet Knights' offense won't get shut out two games in a row. It will be a not-so-Happy Valley for Rutgers on Saturday.”

Sean Newcomb, the associate sports editor, went with 31-6. “Rutgers hasn't scored a touchdown in Happy Valley since ...

  1. Yes, that is real, and I don't see it changing this week.

Rutgers could be without its first, second and third options at quarterback in its penultimate game of the season. Penn State has found its hot streak, and Rocco Becht will torch the Scarlet Knights.

I fear that Rutgers may not score any points, but two field goals should be in store.”

Anthony Palumbo, another associate sports editor, predicted 38-10. “After the game against Nebraska, it's hard to say that Rutgers will show any sign of life.

Besides the quarterback room injuries, the rest of the team is also not performing at a level that gives the Scarlet Knights a chance to win. Expect Penn State to jump out to an early lead, one that they'll retain.”

Among the more lopsided picks, Nathan Thompson forecast Penn State 49-0. “No offensive firepower whatsoever and having no competent quarterback under center does not equate to much success for Rutgers against the powerful Penn State defense.

When you flip to the defensive side for the Scarlet Knights, there's not much to talk highly about either. It's going to be a rough one in Happy Valley.”

Matthew Risko also saw a shutout, choosing Penn State 42-0. “Penn State has one of the best pass defenses in the nation, playing against a Rutgers team that can't get anything going in the air.”

Jared Manne projected Penn State 38-14. “The Scarlet Knights' losing streak will continue this Saturday in Happy Valley.

After being shut out by Nebraska last week, I expect another ugly performance against a Nittany Lions squad that has found their footing after a rough start to the Matt Campbell era. With Rutgers' top (three) QBs all dealing with injuries, I expect this game to get out of hand early on, and the Knights will remain at the very bottom of the Big Ten standings for another week.”

Mike Silva picked Penn State 34-7. “The season is all but over.

Rutgers might get a lucky touchdown, but with a huge question mark at quarterback, it's hard to think they will do anything productive on offense. Penn State will win convincingly, and Rutgers will continue to spiral.”

Justin Cheeseman had Penn State 27-6. “While Rutgers is heading into Happy Valley for this game, it'll be far from a joyous occasion.

The injuries and struggles on both sides of the ball will be too much for the Scarlet Knights to overcome. The Nittany Lions will dominate and stifle the Rutgers offense.

On the other side of the ball, the RU defense won't have an answer for Penn State's rushing attack. The Nittany Lions pick up an easy win.”

Makali Pennycooke wrote, “This season is surely as dead as Rutgers' quarterback Room. It's hard to imagine this team picking up another win this season after a lifeless and embarrassing performance against Nebraska.

Penn State is coming off a very good showing against Minnesota, beating them 42-14, and many could argue that the same performance will happen in Happy Valley. This football team's core players are injured and could be more malpractice starting him against Penn State.”

Ryan Kindler closed with a similar outlook. “Rutgers will keep it close, as they tend to do, but then fall off a cliff in the second half and let Penn State get away with it. Surace will look decent, but Penn State will once again prevail against Rutgers.”

In Other News...

Rutgers Has A Bigger SHI Problem Than Greg Schiano Can Ignore

Rutgers has spent enough time staring at the same concern in the stands to know this is not a one-off. Home attendance has been sliding, and the drop has been especially noticeable after Thanksgiving, when the building has looked thinner than it did in previous years. For a program trying to keep momentum inside SHI Stadium, that kind of trend is hard to shrug off because it reaches beyond atmosphere and into the bottom line.

Greg Schianos return in 2027 is supposed to bring stability, but there is no guarantee it will automatically bring more people through the gates. Rutgers has also lived a lot of its recent football life on the Big Ten Network, where viewership can vary widely from one conference game to the next, which only adds to the challenge of building consistent buzz. The bigger question now is whether the program can find a way to make home Saturdays feel like a destination again before the financial pressure gets any more obvious. [Read more 🡒]

Rutgers Got A Much-Needed Lift From Two Unexpected Contributors

Rutgers got a needed reset in Las Vegas on Wednesday, and it came from a pair of unexpected sources. In the Players Era Festival seventh-place game, the Scarlet Knights handled UNLV 89-70 behind a season-high 23 points from Darin Smith Jr., while the group controlled the game from the start, won the rebounding battle 44-28 and piled up a season-high 20 assists.

Acting head coach Brandin Knight pointed to the defense as a major reason the performance looked so complete, and Rutgers needed it after a tournament stretch that had left plenty to clean up. The bigger question now is whether this kind of balanced effort can carry over once the Scarlet Knights get back home and into the next part of their schedule. [Read more 🡒]

Rutgers Just Got The Early Season Boost Fans Needed

Rutgers got the kind of early-season lift it was looking for with an 89-70 win over UNLV in the Players Era 8 Championship, a result that gave the Scarlet Knights their first victory in the event. Junior guard Darin Smith Jr. set the tone with a season-high 23 points, giving Rutgers a much-needed offensive spark in a game that felt like a step forward for a team still trying to settle in.

Brandin Knight and Smith both pointed to the performance as more than just a one-night scoring burst, with the focus landing on how Rutgers played together and carried out its plan. For a group trying to build confidence early, the win offered a cleaner picture of what the Scarlet Knights can look like when the ball is moving and the energy is there, even if the bigger questions around consistency are still waiting to be answered. [Read more 🡒]