Rutgers is back in a spot it has not solved since 2009: staring down a ranked opponent with a chance to finally end a 45-game losing streak.
The Scarlet Knights, 2-4 and 1-3, head to Evanston, Illinois, on Saturday to face No. 24 Northwestern at New Ryan Field. For Rutgers, it is the kind of road test that has lingered for years - and the kind of game the program badly needs to clean up a painful statistical stain.
The Daily Targum’s sports writers don’t agree on how it will go, but they do agree on one thing: this is the moment Rutgers fans have been waiting for.
James Mertz sees a breakthrough, with Rutgers escaping 34-31. He pointed to “offensive heroics from KJ Duff and the dynamic running back duo of Antwan Raymond and Clay Thevenin” and said the defense would do enough, including what he believes would be Aidan Chiles’ first interception of the season. In his view, Greg Schiano gets “his signature win and inches closer to keeping his job next season.”
Mertz’s second projection went the other way, with Northwestern winning 31-23. He wrote that Dylan Lonergan “looked comfortable for the first time all season in a win over Maryland,” but added that he did not trust Rutgers’ defense to keep pace with Aidan Chiles and Chip Kelly’s offense. Even so, he said he would not be shocked if Rutgers finally snapped the streak - or if it lost by three or more scores.
Anthony Palumbo also circled the game as a big opening for Rutgers, calling it “a golden opportunity” to land a ranked win. Still, he picked Northwestern 38-17, saying the Wildcats have been impressive and noting that Chip Kelly has the offense rolling, including “breaking out the Wing-T offense.” Palumbo said Rutgers should have some confidence after a close game against Michigan State, but he did not expect the Knights to pull the upset.
Nathan Thompson leaned even harder toward Northwestern, taking the Wildcats 38-21. He wrote that Rutgers’ streak against ranked opponents will continue because he cannot see the defense holding Northwestern down enough to win. Thompson expected the game to stay tight through halftime before Northwestern pulls away late.
Justin Cheeseman went in the opposite direction, picking Rutgers 27-24. He wrote that the streak may end this week and pointed to Northwestern looking vulnerable against Michigan State. Cheeseman said KJ Duff will “once again, make some huge plays,” and believed Rutgers could turn the game into a four-quarter fight if it pressures the Wildcats early.
Cheeseman also made a second call, this time with Northwestern winning 35-21. In that version, Rutgers hangs around for a while, but the defense cannot make the stop it needs. He projected another strong game from Dylan Lonergan and a touchdown from Clay Thevenin before Northwestern pulls away.
Makali Pennycooke picked Northwestern 38-17. Pennycooke cited injuries to tight end Luke Dehnicke and defensive back Josh Fussell, along with other doubtful defensive injuries, and said Rutgers has not beaten a ranked opponent in well over 15 years. The edge, in that prediction, stays with Northwestern at New Ryan Field behind Aidan Chiles, while Rutgers continues to struggle defensively.
Mike Silva offered a Rutgers upset at 31-28, arguing Northwestern “should not be ranked after their performance against the Big Ten’s worst team, Michigan State.” He said Rutgers is “riding high after a great win in College Park” and predicted the Scarlet Knights would walk out with a ranked victory and Northwestern’s first loss in the new stadium. Silva also noted that Chiles will be a major factor and added, “with the consistency of Greg Schiano, I don’t see it changing anytime soon.”
The final prediction went back to Northwestern, 31-14. That pick said this would not be the week Rutgers breaks the streak, cited Northwestern’s only loss this season as a 29-23 defeat at Indiana, and expected a loud crowd at New Ryan Field in Evanston. In that forecast, Dylan Lonergan keeps Rutgers close early, but the Wildcats’ rushing attack proves too much for the Scarlet Knights to handle.
In Other News...
Rutgers Gets A Rare Opening Against A Ranked Northwestern Team
Rutgers heads to Evanston with a chance to keep some momentum rolling after its recent conference win, and the matchup comes with an unusual opening against a ranked Northwestern team. The Scarlet Knights have spent too long trying to snap a long skid against ranked opponents, so this one carries more than the usual Big Ten weight, especially with a Wildcats squad that has been steady on both sides of the ball under David Braun and quarterback Aidan Chiles.
The opportunity for Rutgers gets a little more interesting because Northwestern is dealing with some notable injuries on defense, which could affect how the game is played at the line of scrimmage and in the secondary. For Rutgers, the challenge is simple enough to say and harder to solve: take advantage of the moment, avoid letting a ranked opponent settle in, and turn a solid conference performance into something bigger on the road. [Read more 🡒]
Rutgers Fans Are Back In A Debate They Never Wanted
Mike Locksleys dismissal at Maryland during the bye week put the first coaching change of the 2026 college football season on the board, and it inevitably sent Rutgers fans back to a conversation they know all too well. Around the sport, schools are weighing whether a midseason move is worth the cost or whether the smarter play is to put money into the roster and ride out the schedule, the kind of calculation Wisconsin and Virginia have already made this year.
For Rutgers, the timing only sharpens the unease because the current backdrop is less about one abrupt swing and more about what happens if a school waits. Greg Schiano remains part of that broader coaching-watch conversation, but the more relevant question for Scarlet Knights fans may be whether any decision would come after the season rather than in the middle of it. Rutgers bye week came and went without a move, which makes the next stretch feel less like a fire drill and more like a slow burn. [Read more 🡒]
Greg Schiano Keeps Cleaning Up Rutgers Messes Fans Know Too Well
When a national outlet starts ranking the roughest coaching tenures of the last half-century, Rutgers inevitably shows up in an uncomfortable place. The Athletics latest look back at the 25 worst stretches included the kinds of failures Scarlet Knights fans have spent years trying to forget, and it is a reminder of how often the program has had to climb out of its own wreckage before it can even think about moving forward.
Greg Schiano has been the one constant in that effort, twice walking into a Rutgers job that needed stabilizing before anything else. His track record there is tied to patience, damage control and incremental progress, which makes the current challenges around athletic director Keli Zinn and the schools NIL resources feel familiar in a frustrating way. For Rutgers, the hard part has never just been finding a coach. It has been giving that coach enough support to escape the same cycle. [Read more 🡒]