The phone call came with no warm-up, no small talk, because there was no time for either. Rutgers had just beaten Penn State for the first time in 38 years, and the reaction on the other end sounded like a man who knew exactly how big the moment was.
“THE MOST IMPROBABLE, THE MOST STUNNING MOMENT IN THE HISTORY OF RUTGERS FOOTBALL! NO ONE IN THE WORLD THOUGHT THAT THEY WOULD WIN!”
That was the feeling around the Scarlet Knights’ 25-24 shocker, a win built on a backup quarterback playing through three broken ribs, a wild last-gasp lateral that will live in school lore, and a two-point conversion that finished the job. It came in a season that had already gone off the rails, with Greg Schiano still on the sideline only because the money left on his contract made moving on impossible.
For Rutgers fans, though, this was not the time to dwell on UMass, the Big Ten beatdowns, or the string of home losses that had drained the season. This was the night to exhale.
Bill Dubiel certainly did. He was in Beaver Stadium on Sept. 24, 1988, the last time Rutgers had beaten Penn State, and the FOX broadcast brought back clips from that game on Saturday.
The footage looked ancient. Joe Paterno, with jet-black hair, shook hands with Rutgers coach Dick Anderson and walked off the field after the loss.
Dubiel was a captain and starting guard on that team. He’s 61 now, and the 38-year wait has become such a familiar conversation that he once joked he ought to make “I Got You Babe” his ringtone whenever I called.
“Man, I cannot believe we’re still talking about this!” Dubiel said last year, when Rutgers had another chance and another heartbreak followed. That one ended with Athan Kaliakmanis losing the ball on a fumble that was returned for a touchdown.
This time, the Scarlet Knights were massive underdogs again, listed at 26.5 points. The history in this matchup was brutal enough on its own, and Rutgers hadn’t scored a touchdown in State College since 1994. So when Penn State jumped ahead 16-0 and outgained Rutgers 191-9 in the first quarter, it looked like the script was settling into place.
But Penn State never finished the job. The Nittany Lions kept handing Rutgers openings, with turnovers, penalties and a sloppy offense that refused to slam the door.
AJ Surace, playing with those three cracked ribs, led a 19-play, 75-yard march that ate nearly 10 minutes and trimmed the lead to 24-17 early in the fourth quarter. Suddenly, the impossible didn’t feel quite so impossible. The bigger question was whether Rutgers’ defense could get the stops it needed.
It did. Then it did again.
That gave Rutgers one more chance late, and a pass interference call put the Scarlet Knights two yards from the goal line with one play left. On that snap, Antwan Raymond took a pass from Surace and was stopped short in a wall of defenders. If the game had ended there, it would have been another cruel near-miss.
Instead, Raymond kept the play alive with a desperate lateral to Ben Black, who took it the rest of the way for the touchdown that pulled Rutgers within one.
Schiano didn’t settle for overtime. He went for two, and it paid off. Surace found Clay Thevenin, who walked into the end zone to complete the upset.
Afterward, Schiano sounded as emotional as he has in his second stint, and he called 2026 the hardest season of his four decades in coaching. That’s fitting for a year that began with a loss to UMass and kept sliding from there.
For now, though, the bigger picture can wait. This was a release, a rare and wild one, and maybe the rest can be sorted out later when Schiano starts an offseason that will demand major changes, major investment and a lot of luck.
Dubiel watched from Arizona, where his phone lit up with messages from friends, former teammates and well-wishers. He had hoped to be there in person for the day Rutgers finally broke through, but he admitted it was hard to believe this would be the one.
“I was telling my wife in the fourth quarter, ‘You might be watching something that hasn’t happened in a lifetime,’” Dubiel said.
On Saturday, for Rutgers fans of every generation, that was exactly what it felt like.
In Other News...
Notre Dames Rutgers Win Looks Better After What Those Rotation Players Did
Rutgers left the Players Era 8 Tournament with a 1-2 record, but the bigger takeaway for the Scarlet Knights may be how the rotation pieces held up in the spotlight. Against a field that included Notre Dame, several of the players who will shape the middle of the roster got meaningful run, and the early returns were encouraging enough to make that win look a little sturdier in hindsight.
Christian Gurdak and Lino Mark both turned in strong showings, giving Rutgers something to build on beyond the usual headline names. Darren Buchanan Jr. and Rasheed Jones had more uneven stretches, which is part of the reason the staff will likely keep sorting through the rotation as the season moves forward, but the tournament at least offered a clearer picture of who helped and who still has work to do. [Read more 🡒]
Rutgers Heads To Penn State With One Huge Offensive Concern
Rutgers heads into its final road game of the season on Nov. 21 with plenty to sort out and not much margin for error. The Scarlet Knights are 2-8 and dealing with significant injuries, including uncertainty at quarterback, which makes the trip to Penn State feel less like a late-season opportunity and more like another test of how much the offense can function under strain.
Penn State, meanwhile, is 6-4 and coming off a decisive win over Minnesota, so the matchup already tilts heavily toward the Nittany Lions. Around the Rutgers staff, the expectation is clear enough: this is the kind of game Penn State should control comfortably, leaving the Scarlet Knights to search for answers on the offensive side as the season winds down. [Read more 🡒]
Houston Showed Rutgers Exactly What Made This Team So Tough
Houstons run through the Players Era 8 Tournament offered a clear reminder of why this team has been such a difficult matchup. The Cougars beat Florida in the semifinals and Kansas in the title game, and they did it with a deep, balanced rotation rather than leaning on one star alone. Dedan Thomas Jr. was named MVP after averaging 22.3 points per game, but the bigger story was how many different players kept showing up when the pressure rose.
Joseph Tugler, Mercy Miller, Chase McCarty, Delrecco Gillespie and Chendall Weaver all made meaningful contributions, giving Houston the kind of spread-out production that can wear opponents down over the course of a tournament. For Rutgers, the lesson is pretty straightforward: this is a team that can beat you in multiple ways, and it has enough pieces to keep coming even when one option is taken away. [Read more 🡒]
