Week 1 always sells hope first. Then the games start, and for a few fan bases, the rug gets pulled out before September even settles in.
Rutgers took the hardest hit of the opening weekend. The Scarlet Knights came into Thursday night as heavy favorites over UMass, only to fall 37-21 at home in a result that left their supporters sounding less frustrated than broken.
Rutgers was supposed to cruise; instead, the loss sent fans spiraling, with one post likening the reaction to Titanic passengers abandoning ship. Another fan called it “the single saddest thing l've ever seen,” pointing to Rutgers paying UMass $1.5M to play them Week 1 as 30-point favorites only to lose and then set off a pre-planned fireworks show postgame.
Even the most loyal backers were venting that they’ve spent years showing up, believing, and getting little back.
Baylor’s pain was different, but no less sharp. The Bears were underdogs against Auburn and stayed alive long enough to take a shot at the win, going for a two-point conversion with nine seconds left.
They came up inches short, and that was enough to turn a competitive night into a gut punch. The frustration wasn’t just about losing; it was about how familiar the ending felt.
One fan said the defeat brought an overwhelming sense of depression, while another argued the pattern has become too familiar under Dave Aranda to inspire much confidence. There was also anger over the final play itself, with one post blaming DJ Lagway and calling it “Great play call.
Terrible throw.”
Vanderbilt also gave its fans a strange kind of misery: a win that didn’t feel all that reassuring. The Commodores beat FCS Austin Peay 28-9, but life without Diego Pavia looked messy enough to leave plenty of supporters uneasy about what comes next.
Some fans left the game feeling worse about the season, not better, and one pointed out that the bigger story may be how much the last two years depended on Pavia. There was also noise from the stands about five-star quarterback Jared Curtis mostly watching from the sideline, which only added to the unease around a win that was supposed to calm things down.
Michigan escaped with a 13-12 win over Western Michigan, but it took a deeply controversial, or more accurately deeply errant, timing call to make it possible. The Wolverines survived on a Hail Mary and then stormed the field, a scene that split the fan base between relief and embarrassment.
Some were thrilled to get out alive, but others couldn’t get past the fact that this was the shape of the night in Week 1. One fan said, “I’m filled with so much disgust from that game last night.
Cannot get over it. What a shameful product to put on the field” Another simply wrote, “storming the field for Western Michigan wasn't on my bingo card”
Then there was Clemson, which may have had the bleakest final score of all. LSU was on the road, yes, but that doesn’t make a 51-10 loss any easier to swallow for a fan base that spent the offseason waiting for better things.
Instead, the Tigers looked overmatched, and the reaction was immediate and brutal. Some fans were already talking about the next week, the attendance, and what Dabo should do after what one poster called “this 4-8 season.”
Others said they were disappointed but not shocked, with one declaring the program “officially a dead program” and another calling for a reset.
For a week built on possibility, these fan bases got something else entirely: a reminder that September can be cruel.
In Other News...
Rutgers Women's Soccer Enters Princeton Match With One Leadership Question
Rutgers womens soccer closes its nonconference slate at Yurcak Field against Princeton, with a familiar look and a fresh twist. Mike ONeill is in his 13th season guiding a roster built around 22 returners and nine newcomers, giving the Scarlet Knights a blend of continuity and new pieces as they head into one of the last tune-ups before the schedule shifts for good.
Olivia Bodmer and Gabriela Gil have already been named captains for the 2026 season, which gives the program a clear starting point on the leadership front. The more immediate question is how that leadership develops in real time as Rutgers tries to keep sharpening its identity against Princeton and carry momentum out of the nonconference portion of the year. [Read more 🡒]
Rutgers Fans Are Already Debating A Greg Schiano Backup Plan
Brian Kelly is already back around the game in a different role, but he has not closed the door on another coaching run. The former Notre Dame and LSU head coach is part of CBS Sports coverage of the 2026 college football season, and he has said he wants to stay connected to football operations while even making plans to visit spring practices and keep tabs on how the sport is evolving.
That has been enough to get Rutgers fans talking about a hypothetical backup plan if Greg Schiano ever comes under real pressure. Kelly has not been linked to the job in any official sense, but the idea has taken hold because of his background and because Scarlet Knights supporters are always quick to game out what might come next. For now, it is only a fan conversation, but it is the kind that tends to linger when a veteran coach with New Jersey ties keeps his options open. [Read more 🡒]
Rutgers Fans Now Have One Big Reason To Judge Keli Zinn
Keli Zinn has spent much of her first year at Rutgers taking a hard look at what was working and what needed to change across the athletic department, and that evaluation has already produced a major decision in womens basketball. She moved on from Coquese Washington and brought in Gary Redus as the new head coach, a clear sign that the Scarlet Knights athletic director is willing to make an early call when she thinks the program needs a new direction.
Zinn has also pointed to progress in football under Greg Schiano, saying recruiting and the use of resources have improved since she arrived. For Rutgers fans, the larger question now is whether those moves are the start of a broader reset or just the first visible steps in a longer rebuild, with Zinns judgment on the departments biggest pieces set to be watched closely from here. [Read more 🡒]